Customer Reviews

Play by Play: Baseball, Radio, and Life in the Last Chance League

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Neal Conan is really telling two stories here...one is about his season as play-by-play announcer for the Albany Arsenal, the other is about his own mid-life crisis that led him to take a leave from his job at National Public Radio to spend a season as that team's play-by-play announcer.

The author introduces us to the manager of the team (major league veteran Darrell Evans) and to the players, none of whom are familiar at the beginning of the tale. That's because independent leagues are dependent on those young men who got sidetracked on the way to The Show...whether there was a flaw in their game or in their personality, they had been tossed aside by the big league organizations, and were out to make the most of one final chance with this independent club.

We follow Conan through his shaky start at the beginning of the season, which mirrors the difficult start the team experiences; while Conan steadily gains confidence and skill, it's much more of an up-and-down experience for the Arsenal. This is a thoughtful, sometimes funny, sometimes sad, very human story. I truly enjoyed reliving the year with Conan, and hope you will, too.

Neal Conan, longtime National Public Radio host/correspondent/producer, has offered up a fine volume on the subject of his sabbatical year as play-by-play announcer for a minor league baseball team. With baseball - and its labor disputes, nascent drug scandals, and rapidly tarnishing image as the American Game - much in the news these days, the fit is a most appropriate one. And he delivers the goods. Minor League ball is currently all the rage, and this book gives you the background and personal stories which fill in a complete picture of a fascinating world most of us know only from the grandstands. His writing flows nicely, his story is compelling, and his team...well, you'll just have to read it and find out what happens to the Aberdeen Arsenal during the course of this singular season. Let's just say that it's good Conan had a job waiting for him back at NPR. Can't wait to hear what his next book is going to be about.

Many books have been written about the minor league experience. But this one offers little new or refreshing. Rather, it is the obvious story of a man in the midst of a mid-life crisis. At one point, amazingly, his wife even asked him if he wanted permission to sleep around during his hiatus from home, children and ostensible repsonsibility. I'm surprised he declined. Grow up, Mr. Conan. You should have stayed at NPR.

For readers interested in a great book about life in the minors, check out David Lamb's classic, Stolen Season. That's a book worth owning and reading.

The author chose a very interesting subject and wrote about his year where he left NPR and became a minor league baseball announcer. I thought that the prospects of a great book were in order however the author chose to digrese to events that had nothing to do with his year in baseball. If he wanted to write an auto biography then these events would have been approptiate. He also could have expanded on his work in the minor leagues and covered the entire season instead of leaving gaps.

Loved this book. Conan is an excellent storyteller and he really captured the tale without falling into stereotypical story lines.

I love books about the minor leagues. If I didn't, I have to admit I would find it a bit difficult to get through this one.
Mr.Conan's journalistic credentials are impeccable, but there is something else going on here. It was written from the heart, and suffers from some very odd choices in editing - entire chapters where he goes off on a tangent had me checking the front of the book to see if I had missed a sub-title or something. This is particularly true of a very lengthy section where he describes how he was held captive in Iraq for a week. This was an experience which has clearly (and understandably) affected him, but surely that long tale did not belong in a baseball book, or at least, not such a detailed rendering. Perhaps this was just something he needed to get off his chest - I dont know.
I did, however, enjoy his description of life in the independent leagues of baseball, and especially of the odd ballparks in the circuit. I liked the way he outlined the life histories which brought the many players to the league, and his description of Darrell Evans, the team's manager, was particularly interesting.
If you are a fan of baseball and the minor/independent leagues, then the three-star rating will seem stingy. If you are just a general reader, however, this could be a tough read.

I'm a big Major League Baseball fan and I was looking for a book to read as I anxiously await the beginning of the season in a few months. This book is a quick and easy read but maybe not exactly what I was looking for. It is an account of the authors journey as he leaves his job at NPR on his quest to become a baseball announcer. With no previous experience in the booth he sets out to build his resume in the Independent leagues of minor league baseball becoming an announcer for the Aberdeen Arsenal.

The author's stories of people he met never really engaged me. His writing about his experiences a war correspondent in Iraq included in one chapter were surprisingly a bit more interesting. While I found I did not care much for the stories of the people he shared I did get a look into the world of minor league baseball. I admit I never really understood the attraction of be a fan of a minor league baseball. How could one follow a team that changes players for year to year? If a player is really good you can expect he won't be around for long. But book showed me a different vantage point and gave me a window of understanding into these leagues. I understand now the roll these leagues play for their fans, the local towns, the team owners, the businesses and the rest of the enterprise.

I enjoyed Neal Conan's book because he succeeded at doing something I always wanted to do. I've been in radio since I was sixteen, and I've been in love with baseball from an even earlier age, but I have never been able to combine my two loves. Neal Conan followed through on his dream -- on my dream -- if only for one season, and I thank him for the vicarious pleasure.

The premise of this book is delightful - baseball fan becomes play-by-play announcer. It was, in fact, the reason I bought the book. The book itself starts slowly and gets worse, finally bogging down in the author's Vietnam experience. I got the feeling it was heavily padded.

The truth is, I haven't read the book yet (though I am ordering it now). But I was a listener and loyal fan and the 5 star rating refers to his broadcasting ability. The community college radio station that broadcast his . . . uh, broadcasts, was so local that not everyone in Harford County, Maryland, could get it (and, in fact, I stopped going to games because I could hear him better at home than on my earbuds & portable!). The Baltimore baseball market has had some terrific broadcasters over the years, so the standards by which I judge are high indeed. What I loved best was how he handled the quirks that occured in a decidedly unprofessional ballpark, sitting in a portable trailer with barely a view of the entire field. And suffice it to say that no other broadcaster has ever sent me running for the dictionary to make sure I really understood his call. The Aberdeen Arsenal lasted just that one season, but the Ripkin Brothers (Cal and Billy) are opening a first-class minor league park and baseball academy in Aberdeen this summer. Neal, any chance you can come back to call a game or two??