7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
4 1/2* Brilliantly Illustrated, but Story Plays it Safe, February 17, 2007
This review is from: Play, Mozart, Play! (Hardcover)
The excellence of Peter SIs' illustrations is evident even from the frontispiece (that page before the title page). The line drawings of diverse musical instruments against dappled watercolor backgrounds, are simple, elegant, and completely caught my eye. The rest of the book fulfills this initial promise, as Sis displays a dazzling variety of technique and style: Close-ups and silhouettes, various backgrounds for the text (faux parchment paper, musical scores, patterned paper), watermarks and age spots, and period drawings of European capitals--like the ones you see on old Porcelain teacups and plates. The pictures consistently amaze. Unfortunately, Sis' kid bio of Mozart takes the easy way out after an imaginative beginning.
Mozart was a" famous composer and a child genius. His father turned him into a child sensation." Yet, as the story progresses, it becomes clear that his father's hand is on the tyrannical side. More on that later... Mozart plays for "kings and princes and dukes." Sis dispalys these royal appearnces as decorations on six ornate fans (with fan-holding courtiers placing the fans in historical context). Moreover, Mozart was apparently the Jimi Hendrix of his era, playing blindfolded, backwards, with covered keys, and while standing on furniture (there's no mention of whether he played with his teeth or burned his pianos).
This light tone shifts abruptly, however, as the silhouetted figure of his stern father points a commanding finger at him, We learn of Mozart's dilemma: "...Mozart did not play with other children, because his father made him practice all the time." We view young Mozart from above, as we hear the commands from Dad: "Play, Mozart, Play!" Mozart escapes into his music amid this fevered atmosphere, and things in the piano room morph into animated, slightly bizarre objects with faces: An airborne clock, a melting candlestick, winged potatoes, a whale spouting notes from his blow hole. The slightly bizarre "Alice in Wonderland" like images are even larger on the next 2-page spread, commanding an entire stage, with Mozart playing a flute (no doubt a reference to his Opera, "The Magic Flute"). In the only reference to his father's regimen, Sis has him asking, "Wolfgang, are you playing," and Mozart scampers back to his piano, looking like he's been caught with his hands in the cookie jar, not on the keyboard. The objects in the room return to normal, and they're in an austere black and white. They appear defeated.
This is where Sis lets us down. He could have continued the father/son conflict, the battle between ambition and playing for fun and emotional release. This theme was explored in the great "The 5,000 FIngers of Dr. T.," the film that revealed the double-edged sword of striving for musical perfection. However, having led us to this point, Sis abandons it, showing us only that Mozart continued to play day and night, in his imagination, in his dreams, and throughout his life. In the biggest betrayal, the last scene shows Mozart's dad lifting the smiling young Mozart above him, as the story applauds his "beautiful music." This rendering of the father is almost repulsive.
Sure it's a kids' book, and we shouldn't expect the dark revelations of either "Amadeus" or "Mommie Dearest." Still, it's clear that something is wrong here (in fact, Mr. Sis leads us right up to that idea): Herr Mozart's demands, the lack of friends, the inward escape (albeit, beautiful captured), and the book plays it safe. The pictures remain brilliant, but it's unfortunate that we have a sanitized, fairly bland conclusion, rather than further play with the discordant side of ambition. 'Dr. T' showed that this complexity could be achieved in an intelligent mix of comedy and mock horror. Still, an excellent book that can be enjoyed (on very different levels) by toddlers and those in the first few grades of elementary school.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Scratching my head, March 21, 2007
This review is from: Play, Mozart, Play! (Hardcover)
The title of this book and the cover are incredibly inviting. We checked it out at the library because my 3-year-old loves the piano. We both found the content and the illustrations, well, boring. That Mozart's dad was a tyrant about the piano is not something I even want to share with my daughter at this point. I want to draw her into music, not give examples of abusive parenting related to music. It's a strange angle for a kid's book. Much of Mozart's music is very child-like and approachable. Too bad the qualities of the music didn't get more 'play' than the production of it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No