Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
79 of 91 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Too Much of a Wallow, Not Enough Overcoming..., April 22, 2004
As a victim of bullying from grade school through high school, I wanted to like this book. In fact, I was annoyed when I read some of the negative reviews here. They seemed to be written by bullies themselves. Then I read the book. Oh boy. A great deal has been made of it being written in response to the Columbine shootings. Recent information, however, reveals the Columbine shooters weren't victims of bullying so much as they were contemptuous psychopaths who thought themselves superior to EVERYONE and planned to kill EVERYONE from the meanest jock to the lowliest nerd. I'm not sure "Please Stop" is going to help stop the creation of future Klebolds and Harrises. Nor is it going to do much for victims of bullies beyond assuring them that lots of other people get bullied--some worse than others. I would ten times rather Jodee had expounded on the resources she had to draw upon to get through high school. I would like to have heard about the skills she developed to go from high school victim to real-world success story. (How DOES someone so hated and so downtrodden become a publicist for Muhammad Ali and Jim Carrey?) I would rather have read about what kinds of support she and her various outsider friends gave each other to buffer the cruelty they suffered. Instead, we get 200 plus pages of graphic description of how mean everyone was, how clueless the world was, and (apparently) what a nice, saintly girl Jodee was. (I was bullied,too, but even I know that I wasn't Bernadette of Lourdes--I could be snarky and prissy and deliberately dorky. Does this excuse my tormentors? No. Does it explain their behavior? A little. Did I knock myself out trying to make them like me? Not on your life. I found my own strange little circle of buddies and together we got through it. Do I have days when I get mad on behalf of the teenager I was? Sure. Then I remember I am NOT the teenager I was and I get back to my real life.) Would I recommend this to victims of bullies? Well, I'm a librarian and I know some kids who would likely eat this up with a spoon. Sure, I'd recommend it. I would caution them that it won't help them with their troubles beyond the "you're not alone out there" speech. Would I recommend this to people who might be bullies? Chances are they are the ones reading it. I know waaaay too many kids who viciously pick at their classmates, peers and friends, yet read all of David Pelzer's books and comment on how much they wish they could save the child he was from being abused. They attend popular films in which underdogs overcome tremendous obstacles tossed in their paths by bullies--and they will root for that underdog. But even though their often do and say to their peers things much worse than Jodee suffered, they will not recognize themselves in the bullies at her schools. (Heck, almost none of Jodee's tormentors saw themselves as bullies, either. They remain clueless and, I suspect, some of them suck up to her because of who she is now and who she knows.) I wish I could recommend it for the detailed descriptions of the inner resources Jodee discovered and the phenomenal skills she developed to become the person she is today. Sadly, I can only recommend it as a kind of "printed pity party" that will leave victims wondering how to heal themselves and move on.
|
|
|
22 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Huge disappointment, April 5, 2007
Judging by the two comments on my original review below, I should have added more supporting information about my opinion of this book. Here it is.
I do not find this story enlightening, illuminating or useful, as the comments about my review imply I should. Here is what I have found to be the most useful writer on the topic: Michael Thompson, author of "Raising Caine" and the more relevant book to bullying: "Best Friends, Worst Enemies: Understanding the Social Lives of Children." Of course, he has the advantage of being a psychologist and expert on the topic of children's social lives.
Another detriment to the credibility of "Stop Laughing At Me" is the fact that Jodee's parents indulged her in ways that neither my parents nor any parents of anyone else I know who was bullied ever did. They let her change schools. They sent her to the Greek island of Santorini for months. Hey, there's a nice way to escape the bullying! I would have settled for just changing schools (in fact, when I entered college, the bullying was over for me).
My point about Jodee's book is that it offers no inspiration or solution to bullying if you don't have parents who can afford to send you to different schools or to an overseas resort. I sure can't afford to do that with my children. It does not address the responsibility of schools and adults in general to maintain a safe environment for children.
Here is my original review:
As someone who was bullied growing up and who now has children in school, I was eager to read this book. But I was disappointed and in some ways disgusted. Perhaps part of that is my own fault -- my expectations held all the way to the end that I would get some insight, just some little peak into why bullying happens, whether it can be stopped, what adults can do to stop it or negate its effects. Anything useful. I also grew up with the attitude that kids (and adults) shouldn't be bullying each other, period. They shouldn't be obsessed with popularity, wealth, beauty, social climbing. Just let me be me and stop laughing at me, and I'll let you be you and treat you with equal respect. Well, Jodee isn't coming from that perspective. Her entire book is a rant based on the assumption that she should have been popular among her peers and that cruel kids and cruel fate robbed her of this right -- the right to be one of the other bullies! And how does she deal with it? By becoming a narcissist for life and writing a book bragging about how she now hobnobs with celebrities -- while taking her jabs at her peers who didn't give her the status she felt she deserved. I'm sorry, but I cannot relate to that at all. It is disgusting and pathetic, and an injustice to see this recommended by so many people. How does this help kids? It tells them that they can be popular too if they fight, scratch, complain their way to the "top" of something, and write a book to say "see, I told you I should have been popular! Nyah!" If I could give this book a zero or negative stars, I would have.
|
|
|
29 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
We have the right to expect more....., February 18, 2006
Like other reviewers, I picked up Blanco's book hoping for a balanced and self-reflective biographical read about the experiences and effects of bullying in one woman's life. I was looking forward to learning about the transformative process Blanco must have gone through as a result of her experiences (hence the subtitle, "One Woman's Inspirational Story"). I was even hoping to understand better the phenomenon of bullying and what we can do to address it. However, I was disappointed to discover that the book lacked these elements. Like other reviewers, I began to notice that something seemed "off" early on in the chapters.
Most glaring is the lack of objectivity in Blanco's retelling of her story. When we are children experiencing trauma, everything is subjective. We are in the mix of it, and survival itself is a triumph. However, since Blanco is putting her story out there as an adult, and in the form of an inspirational book, I hoped to discover an analysis of the role she herself played in creating and perpetuating her own experiences.
Nobody asks to be abused and shunned, and merely surviving this trauma can create compassion and depth in a person. However, it has been my experience that a key to healing, and to stopping the cycle abuse, is to realize that we are not the perpetual victim, that things don't just "happen" to us over and over due to bad luck, and that the "characters" who have played in the stories of our lives are not merely one-dimensional. While Blanco makes a couple of attempts to examine her own culpability in her experiences, her insights appear cloaked in self-aggrandizement (i.e., the other kids resented her because of her advanced vocabulary and speaking skills, and because of her elevated morals).
Children can indeed be cruel, and I am not diminishing or doubting Blanco's pain, the seriousness of bullying, or the emotional scars she still carries as a result of it. I have no doubt that many young people who are experiencing bullying will connect with the horrors depicted in this book; however, my question is: will the book offer them the tools, resources, and insights they need to become catalysts for change in their own lives? Blanco doesn't seem to be able to offer this yet. And since she is putting her story out there for public consumption, we, as readers, have the right to expect more.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|