This cookbook is the most-used of any in my home. Having lived in Crimea (in southern Ukraine) with and amongst Russians, I find myself reading Anya von Bremzen's _Please to the Table_ for sheer pleasure and nostalgia. I infinitely prefer it to _The Art of Russian Cuisine_ by Anne Volokh. Although I admire Volokh's work as comprehensive, the results from her recipes taste less like the cooking I ate in my my own and my friends' homes on a daily basis, and more like the mediocre food I ate during rare hotel and restaurant meals. I also find _The Art of Russian Cuisine_ lacking in many dishes that were staples of home cooking and entertaining in my milieu.
In _Please to the Table_, I found the recipes for dishes that I know well to be very authentic indeed. I'd like to address specifically one criticism I saw here in a review, that von Bremzen uses paprika in her recipes. The reviewer wrote that "Paprika is not an ingredient which is traditionally used in Russian cooking. It is the spice of Central Europe (Hungary, Romania, Slovakia, etc.)..." True that Hungarian paprika is not a traditional ingredient of pure Russian cuisine. However, I disagree that it is inauthentic. First, this cookbook covers most of the former USSR, including the western republics such as Moldova and Ukraine, where influence from Central Europe shows up in the food. Second, the great home cooks I knew used what they called red pepper ("krasnij perets") more often than black pepper, and the red pepper where _I_ lived tasted much more like a mixture of hot and sweet paprika than like cayenne, which is what you get in the U.S. if you buy something called simply "red pepper". If von Bremzen's recipes called for "red pepper," then the recipes would taste spicier and much less authentic than they do. For myself, I care less about pure theoretical cuisine than recreating a powerful feeling of warmth and belonging which I associate with the tastes of my life in Crimea. My main authenticity gripe is that no authors (including von Bremzen) advocate the use of unrefined sunflower oil (available at Russian and Ukrainian shops), the rich aroma of which definitely imparts an authentic taste to the food.
As for the nuts and bolts of the book, it is splendidly put together. Amusing and informative vignettes, mostly von Bremzen's recollections of food associations from her childhood growing up in Moscow. The recipes are clearly written. A good proportion of them have lots of ingredients, but I just arrange some ingredients ahead of time and it goes smoothly. The index is excellent. The spread and diversity of the recipes is stunning; simply thumbing through the book will show you how incredibly rich are the cuisines of the former Soviet republics. I especially love that she included all the republics because that's the way people actually eat. I don't just eat hamburgers; I also eat Thai, Chinese, Mexican, etc. Russians eat ethnic food too.
Best recipes include:
A surprisingly easy and very impressive makivnek (poppy seed roll). A fantastic, thick, meaty Ukrainian borshch. Spectacular golubtsi (more tasty, actually, than any I ever ate in Ukraine). A recipe for beliashi that actually made me cry when I tasted them, they were so perfect (I used the yeast dough recipe, though, rather than Pillsbury biscuits which she listed in the recipe). Mixed vegetable caviar that tasted exactly right. A very authentic and filling Uzbek rice pilaf. Fresh zelyonie shchi (sorrel soup). Impossibly delicious Siberian pelmeni ("Honey, where's my spare stomach? There are more pelmeni here!"). Chebureki (Crimean lamb- or beef-filled half-moon pies, fried in oil and absolutely scrumptious). A "pickled mixed vegetable salad" which, if preserved in jars with some sunflower oil, would taste exactly like the delectable home-canned "autumn salad" we depended on all winter long for something like fresh vegetables. Quick Yeast Dough, which is a revelation. Now I understand how my friends' mothers would have pirozhki ready for us an hour after they arrived home from work.
Don't miss this book, even if you have lots of other Russian cookbooks. This one has so much more.