Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Should have been better, August 11, 2009
This review is from: Plugged In: A Clinicians' and Families' Guide to Online Video Game Addiction (Paperback)
The author (Terry R. Waite) has valuable experience, and some good recommendations. Without those, however, I would have rated this book only 1 star, because of serious problems that could have been solved with some good editing. As others have noted, the publishers remark that they "allowed this work to remain exactly as the author intended, verbatim, without editorial input." This is a highly unusual and emphatic statement, and it explains several problems. First, the book is filled with typos ("clients" for "client's," "not" for "no," "whish" for "wish," etc.). If you are the kind of reader who is bothered by such errors -- and there are many, often several on a page -- then you should look for another book. There are also many stylistic inconsistencies and grammatical errors that could have been solved by an editor.
More troubling, the text is poorly organized. Sentence structure is clumsy, paragraph divisions are not meaningful, and at times the text seems to lurch from one topic to another. As another reviewer noted, the author seems uncertain whether he is writing for parents or other therapists. Some aspects of the topic are well explained, but others are not. Some jargon is included in a glossary, but other unusual terms and acronyms are introduced with no explanation. This is all a shame, because the author has valuable experience as both a therapist who deals with gaming addictions, and a game player himself.
If you have a child, partner or family members who is addicted to gaming, there are better books for you to read. If you are a therapist, you may find parts of this helpful, and you probably will want to own this to have a complete library on the subject. But I'm sorry I cannot give it a better review.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Reading this book was very easy and helpfull., July 15, 2007
This review is from: Plugged In: A Clinicians' and Families' Guide to Online Video Game Addiction (Paperback)
I bought this book because my husband and I have played many online games. He plays them much more than I and sometimes to a point that we have to "discuss" cutting back on the time spent online.
Reading this book was very easy and helpfull as well as interesting. With the length of the book about 80 pages it was a quick read and the author of the book was well aware of the type of people that would be reading it and directed the information to them. The only difficultly was if someone had no psychology background they might get a little lost in the clinical details. However, anyone that is interested in the subject and researching it should have touched on these behavioral details already. With both of us reading this book we where able to talk about the subject of online gaming openly. Information can be very powerful to solve problems and this book breaches the subject of online game addition as a friend that is right there with you instead of being accusatory. Several of our friends are also heavily involved in online gaming and I am strongly recommending this book to them. It is good information for any heavy gamer or their family.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Contains useful advice and tools gained from author's personal experience, June 12, 2009
This review is from: Plugged In: A Clinicians' and Families' Guide to Online Video Game Addiction (Paperback)
The publisher's page has the warning that they had no editorial input. Be warned! It is a great shame that the author's ambivalence about his target audience for this work interferes with his valuable message. By having it unedited I can only assume that he is trying to demonstrate to gamers a personal empathy. Perhaps he is trying to lower their defences and lure them into reading the book.
However, given that it is the desperate family member (me) that is likely to buy this, then recommend it to a therapist/clinician - then clinician recommend it to many - it needs to appeal to the latter two groups.
In this First Edition, the use of the wrong words (detoured instead of deterred, there instead of their, minuetes instead of minutes etc), over 30 typos and poor grammar is highly distracting. Some sentences have to be reread to understand what is being conveyed.
The author vacillates between his own addictive thrills and his hobby horse of having online gaming addiction listed in the DSM or ICD international disease classifications. These dalliances would be better compartmentalised within the work and not gratuitously and randomly infused.
I have a 24 year old son with a serious gaming addiction. He has lost his job because of it. His relationship is in jeopardy and his online tribal affiliations have more significance to him than his own family. He suffers narcolepsy after (and inspite of) gaming and cannot wake for up to 17 hrs. This follows a history of enuresis until his teenage years and learning difficulties. I was shocked recently to find that, after all these years, we as parents (and his GPs) had missed a major underlying syndrome. He has Klinefelter's. Other issues also made him more vulnerable with ADD, depression and esteem issues identified.
Finally we are starting to get to the bottom of what has made him vulnerable to this addiction and we can start a journey to work with professionals in support of our wonderful boy lost in space.
This book cost me about $60 when freight was added and I feel it is useful enough to be worth that to me. But PLEASE Mr Waite, swallow your ego and & let the editors help you with the Second Edition URGENTLY. This book is worth expanding on and improving
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|