PocketBook 360 eInk eReader / B003470UH4
NOTE: There is a video that accompanies this review. Amazon can't seem to upload it, so I've placed it on YouTube - the link is in the comments following this review. Thank you!
My household is quickly becoming quite the collection of eReaders - I have an android phone stuffed to the gills with various reading apps, a Nook Classic, a Nook Color, and now a PocketBook 360. I love all my eReaders, but I love my newest member of the family the most because it meets so many of my needs so eloquently.
I have a bad back, and lately I've found that instead of carting around my two (wonderful) Nooks with me everywhere I go, I've been relying more and more on my phone for my "out and about" reading fix. This was not an entirely satisfactory solution, though - my phone was almost impossible to read in full sunlight and my phone didn't easily hold a charge for very long and my constant reading was draining it too quickly. I decided that I needed something that was about the size of my phone (small, light, portable), but with the advantages of eInk (visible in sunlight, slow battery burn). After a LOT of searching online I finally narrowed my choices down to the PocketBook 360 and the Sony PRS-350.
I eventually went with the PocketBook 360 because I felt it met my needs more than the Sony PRS-350, but it's important to note that the differences between the two devices are slight and the relative importance of these differences is going to be subjective. My own mother was terribly excited to see my PocketBook 360 - after having heard so much about it, she had decided she wanted one for Mother's Day - but after sitting down with it for awhile, she finally admitted that it wasn't quite what she wanted after all. I asked her what was important to her in a device, and five minutes later, I told her what she needed was the Sony PRS-350. We went down to look at one and bought it that day, and she couldn't be happier - so it really is a matter of personal preference. With that in mind, here is my own run down of the differences (in my opinion) between the PocketBook 360 and the Sony PRS-350.
1. Memory size and expansion options. The PocketBook 360 comes with a relatively meager 512MB of memory, but has a micro SD card expansion slot that is capable of holding up to 32GB of extra memory. The Sony PRS-350, by contrast, has a nice-sized 2GB storage, but doesn't provide SD card expansion - 2GB is all you ever get. There's a lot of estimates online about library sizes, but for my own needs, my 740-book library is about 3.5GB, or in other words about 1.5GB more than the Sony can accommodate.
For me, SD card expansion was a crucial "deal breaker" issue for two reasons. Firstly, I have an almost compulsive need to have my library available at all times - it's the main reason that I set up my phone to be able to download any title in my library pretty much anywhere in the world (as long as I have 3G or wireless) from a private account I set up specifically for this purpose. I didn't want to give that up with my new portable eReader, since it would feel like a major step backwards. Secondly, I knew with this purchase that I would have 4 eReaders in the household and I didn't want to have to keep my library current on all four of them at once - better to just have my library on a single card that I could slap in and out of the different eReaders as necessary.
On the other hand, my mother basically uses her eReader to read library books and she might in the future start buying books for it, but I am fairly confident that 2GB will meet her needs for a long, long time. So where SD card expansion was a major deciding issue for me, it was almost meaningless as a factor when shopping for her.
2. Device weight and portability. The PocketBook 360 is almost exactly the size and shape of a standard CD jewel case. The Sony PRS-350 is a little larger and thicker, but not noticeably so. Both are extremely light - the PocketBook is 5.3 ounces by itself and 6.6 ounces with the snap-on cover, and the Sony PRS-350 is 5.65 ounces by itself with the covers coming in varying degrees of weight. (By contrast, the average CD jewel case with a single CD is 3 ounces. The
Kindle 3 is 8.7 ounces, and the iPad is approximately 24 ounces!)
Obviously, weight-wise, the PocketBook 360 and Sony PRS-350 are extremely similar. For me, the Sony PRS-350 *felt* heavier - the device has a solid metal chrome frame around it that seemed to feel weighty. By contrast, the PocketBook 360 has a very light plastic feel that seems (to me) easier to hold and balance over long periods of time. I can see some people preferring the Sony PRS-350 for the more solid feel and sturdier construction; for me, since I was looking for the lightest device on the market, the softer plastic feel was exactly what I wanted.
3. Library management, software interaction, and device customization. The PocketBook 360 is a very easy-going little device - it's more than happy to help you customize it to your heart's content and interface with the device however you please, but conversely it doesn't really hold your hand through the process. The Sony PRS-350 is much more strict - you can only do certain things a certain way, but on the other hand, it's harder to muck those things up by accident. Where you fall in terms of preference will probably depend on how much of a control-freak you are over your electronics.
For me, it's absolutely essential that I be able to do precisely what I want with my device, so the PocketBook 360 is ideal. The device has eight buttons, all of which distinguish between "short press" and "long press", and it's possible to map almost every function on the device to one of those keys. I have my device setup so that a short press on the right directional key takes me to the next page, but a long press on the right directional key pulls up the "go to page..." prompt. Pressing the up directional key once zooms in the text, but holding the same key down for a long press creates a bookmark on the current page. Being able to customize my device completely like this feels incredibly intuitive to me, but for someone like my mother, this would be intimidating. Since the keys can be mapped to almost anything, there aren't helpful pictures next to the keys in case you don't immediately remember what does what. The Sony PRS-350, on the other hand, has helpful little pictures on the keys - the arrows turn the pages back and forth, the house button takes you to the home screen, the "options" buttons brings up the appropriate list of options every time. You can't change them, but if you don't *want* them changed, then that's a good thing.
You'll see the same mentality when interacting with the device on your computer. I'm a "drag-and-drop" kind of girl (or, recently, "hit Load Device on Calibre and go to bed while it works" kind of girl) and I use folders and nested structures to organize and navigate my huge library. The PocketBook 360 is extremely friendly to a drag-and-drop mentality, both on the device itself and on any SD card you load in. The Sony PRS-350 on the other hand, seems to really prefer that you use their "Reader Library" management software - you can't even authorize your device with Adobe Digital Editions (i.e., "the software you use to get library books onto your reader") until you've installed the Reader Library program on your computer! As for drag-and-drop, you *can* drag-and-drop books onto the device, but it seems like all the books sensed on the device are dumped into a single "Books" interface, and there's no real way that I could see to enforce nested structures for organization. This is okay if you only have a few dozen books on your device, but (again) if you want to carry your whole library with you at all times, you'll be in a bit of a bind.
For someone like my mother, having a nice new software program managing her device for her is a dream, but for someone like me, having to abandon my carefully controlled folder system is a nightmare. In the same way, I'm "techie" enough to pick and choose my firmware updates, but my mother doesn't want to handle that stuff when she could be reading her library books. When the Sony software insists that, no really, there's an update that needs to be installed, she doesn't mind clicking through and letting the update through. On the other hand, when my PocketBook 360 starting occasionally freezing during routine system locks (all buttons except the "power" button will lock up after a set period of time as a "sleep" method), I was pleased to find a MobileRead forum thread stating that the existing 101.15.1 firmware was a bit buggy and that flashing back to the 101.14.2 would take care of the issue. Five minutes later, my firmware was "back-dated" and problem solved. (Other things you can do quickly and easily from the PocketBook 360 device include resetting to factory settings, wiping your SD card entirely, moving books from SD card to the device and vice versa, and resetting your books to an "unread" state - i.e., no bookmarks, no notes, no last-read-page remembered, etc.) Once again, it's very much a matter of personal preference.
4. eBook formats and DRM limitations. The Sony PRS-350 supports ePub, LRF, PDF, RTF, and TXT; the PocketBook 360 supports CHM (now you, too, can read computer help files on your eReader on the go!), DJVU, DOC, DOCX, EPUB, FB2, FB2.ZIP, HTML, MOBI, PDF, PRC, RTF, TCR, TXT. The PocketBook 360 has different "reader apps" on the device and the user can set which readers to use with which formats by default. (For instance, PDF files can be viewed in "AdobeViewer" or "PDFviewer".
Read more ›