5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A successful in depth look at a genius., June 18, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: The Unknown Poe (Paperback)
The book goes far beyond the myth and the macabre of E.A. Poe. It goes into his everyday life and shows you in his own words how Poe saw it. From ordinary letters written to friends and relatives, to essays and obscure of obscure poems from Poe's earlist days. A true gem for the Poe buff. This title shows how Poe became a legend so much in France that many of the French people thought him one of thier own. This of course you can read about in the book because of Charles Baudelaire's ceasless efforts to translate Poe for the French people. The downfalls of this book are few in that I felt that there should have been more of an effort to put Poe's letters in more context. The way they were printed was more in chronological order, rather than sensible order. Perhaps more narration between the letters were neccesary. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and especially the early work of Poe that he himself never thought much of publishing. This book is a steal at this price and should adorn every bookshelf of every Poe buff everywhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating little novelty, June 9, 2006
This review is from: The Unknown Poe (Paperback)
I've had "The Unknown Poe" for about five years now, and still can't understand how some of this material got past Poe scholars and found its way into this book. There are poems and aphorisms which are simply not available in the huge volumes of Poe's work and critical essays on the man.
The "Poems" section contains little of importance as regards his skill as a poet. I think these were lost for a reason, with the exception of "Deep In Earth", a two line couplet that foreshadows his later self-image as mega-sorrowful artist and "Lines on Ale" which is a sort of ode to his alcoholism.
His philosophical aphorisms range from banal and idiosyncratic to astoundingly brilliant. His constantly repeated belief that life is a "dream within a dream" gets less intriguing the fifth time he says it: but passages like "Men of Genius", which shows him to have been a close contemporary of Schopenhauer and Nietzsche, show quite plainly the unrealized potential he possessed in so many areas. He takes pains to contradict the image of himself as some mad, drunken genius. He expounds on the nature of instinct vs. reason, genius vs. talent, etc.
The comments of Mallarme, Valery and Breton can be seen anywhere. There is nothing unknown about the French adulation of Poe that began with Baudelaire, who never really knew him that well. There are some interesting illustrations/sketches of Poe in here also. This is a must have for many reasons.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A successful in depth look at a genius., June 19, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: The Unknown Poe (Paperback)
The book goes far beyond the myth and the macabre of E.A. Poe. It goes into his everyday life and shows you in his own words how Poe saw it. From ordinary letters written to friends and relatives, to essays and the obscure of obscure poems from Poe's earlist days. A true gem for the Poe buff. This title shows how Poe became a legend so much in France that many of the French people thought him one of thier own. This of course you can read about in the book because of Charles Baudelaire's ceasless efforts to translate Poe for the French people. The downfalls of this book are few in that I felt that there should have been more of an effort to put Poe's letters in more context. The way they were printed was more in chronological order, rather than sensible order. Perhaps more narration between the letters were neccesary. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and especially the early work of Poe that he himself never thought much of publishing. This book is a steal at this price and should adorn every bookshelf of every Poe buff everywhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No