Most Helpful Customer Reviews
37 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great horror collection, November 4, 2008
This review is from: Poe's Children: The New Horror: An Anthology (Hardcover)
Poe's Children: The New Horror, an Anthology edited by Peter Straub is a terrific collection of short stories by a varied collection of authors. Straub includes one of his own stories, Little Red's Tango, a story that is sure to grab the reader's attention. I have to admit that I had a little difficulty getting into the rhythm of the story, but once I did I found Little Red's Tango to be truly worthwhile. Also included is a great story by Stephen King, The Ballad of the Flexible Bullet, another story dealing with an author who is convinced that his typewriter is possessed. I think this is King at is "short story" best.
I was also pleased to see that Neil Gaiman was included with his October in the Chair. Here's a list of all the stories included in Poe's Children:
The Bees Dan Chaon
Cleopatra Brimstone Elizabeth Hand
The Man on the Ceiling Steve Rasnic Tem and Melanie Tem
The Great God Pan M. John Harrison
The Voice of the Beach Ramsey Campbell
Body Brian Evenson
Louise's Ghost Kelly Link
The Sadness of Detail Jonathan Caroll
Leda M. Rickert
In Praise of Folly Thomas Tessier
Plot Twist David J. Schow
The Two Sams Glen Hirshberg
Notes on the Writing of Horror: A Story Thomas Ligotti
Unearthed Benjamin Percy
Gardner of Heart Bradford Morrow
Little Red's Tango Peter Straub
The Ballad of the Flixible Bullet Stephen King
20th Century Ghost Joe Hill
The Green Glass Sea Ellen Klages
The Kiss Tia V. Travis
Black Dust Graham Joyce
October in the Chair Neil Gaiman
Missolonghi 1824 John Crowley
Insect Dreams Rosilind Palermo Stevenson
Also included at the end is a brief biography of each of the authors.
I suspect that like many readers, I have just a wee bit of difficulty reading when the story/author changes. Authors write with their own cadence. It always takes me a page or two to get in step, but other than that, I look forward to new anthologies, especially in the horror genre.
The best story in the collection, in my opinion only has to be October in the Chair by Gaiman, followed closely by Cleopatra's Brimstone. Picking these over the others is really pretty arbitrary since all of the stories are grabbers.
All things considered, Poe's Children is a unique collection by a diverse group of authors.
I highly recommend.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
All right, if you don't mind wading, December 10, 2010
There are two problems with Poe's Children, a collection edited by Peter Straub. One is inherent to all anthologies composed of different authors: you aren't going to like everyone.
The second problem is the editing. The stories have all been previously published, so the words haven't been tampered with. But Poe's Children is an example of how the reader's perception of individual stories can be influenced within the context of their order within an anthology. Stories are placed in sort of thematic chunks that in theory seems like a good idea but in practice gets to feeling rather redundant. By the third story in a row about a protagonist trying to cope with the death of a loved one ("The Two Sams," "Unearthed," "Gardener of Heart") you're sick of grieving heroes. It's unfair to the individual merits of each story to lump them together so you can only really see their similarities rather than their differences, and in this capacity I feel Straub did his authors a disservice.
Of 24 stories there were only two I loved unreservedly. Twentieth Century Ghost, by Joe Hill, is a brooding modern Gothic piece about a haunted theater. (Ghosts always seem to haunt theaters, don't they?) And Louise's Ghost is dark, funny, incisive, bizarre, and heartbreaking--in other words, a Kelly Link story. I highly recommend short story collections by either author.
Stories that I enjoyed: "The Sadness of Detail," by Jonathan Caroll, was good, and refreshingly brief, an existentialist validation of art with disturbing theological implications. "The Bees" is a good story about past regrets that uses genre elements as a metaphor, though it seems almost like an afterthought. "In Praise of Folly" is a brief story with an obvious cymbal clash climax, which works because it doesn't overstay its welcome. I rather liked "The Kiss," about a woman coming to terms with her infamous jazz-singing Jezebel mother's untimely death. "The Green Glass Sea" is a stomach-churning exercise in dramatic irony about a vacation to a nuclear bomb test site. David Schow has fun with "Plot Twist," a study of survival in the face of personality clash for three immature adults on an aborted vacation to Vegas. "Missolonghi 1824" is a pretty neat story of the long-ago and far away and forgotten, when Lord Byron happens upon a captured Greek god. And "Gardener of Heart" is a story of going home again, as the protagonist returns to his hometown to bury his twin sister.
The rest is a mishmash of varying degrees of quality. "The Voice of the Beach" is pretty typical neo-Lovecraftian gobbledygook of the sort that Ramsey Campbell is known for; it's well-written but personally I don't have much fascination for the spaces between reality that Lovecraft fans seem to embrace. "The Great God Pan," "The Man on the Ceiling," and "Body" are another unofficial trio, this time united by surrealism and ambiguity. I don't mind ambiguity, in fact I rather enjoy it, but with all these stories I felt like the authors didn't know any more than I did and just wanted an excuse to connect vague ideas.
"Black Dust," "The Two Sams," and "Unearthed" are perfectly functional but none of them really stood out to me. I like the iconography of "Cleopatra Brimstone" but it was overlong and felt random at points; what was the meaning of all the S&M counterculture apart from a superficial representation of character development? "Insect Dreams" has some interesting ideas and touches on a true horror (slavery) in a way that doesn't feel cheap, but it could have been briefer. And King's early piece "The Ballad of the Flexible Bullet" just doesn't do anything new.
"Notes on the Writing of Horror" is long-winded and dull. "Little Red's Tango" is sporadically intriguing but ultimately I failed to grasp the point. "Leda" is just bizarre. And "October in the Chair" was disappointing. Neil Gaiman is my favorite author and I really like the device of having the months gathered around a campfire to tell tales, but that same device also felt like a meager justification allowing the story-within-a-story to remain unfinished.
Is the collection worth checking out? More than definitely. But don't expect a grand slam of every story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A quality anthology of horror short stories, October 26, 2008
This review is from: Poe's Children: The New Horror: An Anthology (Hardcover)
Peter Straub selects 24 short stories that represent "the most interesting development in our literature during the last two decades." The crossover between works usually classified as fantasy, sci-fi, and horror genres and those considered to be literary, he asserts, "erases boundaries and blurs distinctions."
Two of the better tales are Stephen King's "The Ballad of the Flexible Bullet" (1984)--a story about the genesis of insanity, featuring a writer who suffers from the paranoid delusion that an imp inhabits his typewriter--and Elizabeth Hand's "Cleopatra Brimstone" (2001), a story about an entomologist who is sexually assaulted and wreaks her revenge on men by "collecting" them in bizarre fashion.
King and Hand, plus 22 other New Wave horror writers, exhibit telltale affinities with the spooky imagination of Edgar A. Poe.
If you are a fan of horror stories written by inventive wordsmiths, this quality work is just your cup of tea!
About the author: Peter Straub is the author of 17 novels, including Ghost Story and Koko, as well as two collaborations with Stephen King. Winner of eight Bram Stoker Awards, two International Horror Guild Awards, two world Fantasy Awards, and both a Lifetime Achievement Award and election as a Grand Master from the Horror Writers Association. He lives in New York City.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|