That is the question unintentionally posed by the Pogoplug 4. Or not. As you read through the reviews, you will find eloquent opinions on both sides.
At first I really didn't know what to make of this device, or what use it could be to me. I had the same feeling with the Seagate GoFlex and the Maxell AirStash. While similar in nature, those two items must be in range of the device in order for the user to access files previously loaded thereupon. The Pogo is in the middle- between local WiFi mass storage, and the Real Cloud. I am sure if you are reading this, you know what cloud computing is- if not, in brief, it is a way in which all (or some of) your data is stored at a remote server farm somewhere, and you access it via the Internet. To some it is the future of data storage, to others it is a security risk. I work in IT and see both sides. Some clients embrace it fully, others run from it saying something about "security issues".
It has been proposed as the only bulletproof way to do a system backup with complete confidence. But most IT managers I know prefer to have a backup they can take home, not depend on a remote server and the Internet. However, I have seen more local backup solutions fail that cloud-based. However, I have not yet discovered how one might set up a schedule to run backups.
Enter the Pogo, a halfway step. With it, you can attach any number of mass storage devices and access it anywhere via the Internet. It accepts almost any storage you may have at your disposal- USB drives, external HDD's, SD card and most weird of all, a bare 2.5" HD, which sits upright in the middle, like an iPod dock. I had to wonder, how many people have such a drive just lying around, or would be willing to buy one just to use with the Pogo? I did, but that's a long story.
Setup is nearly instantaneous, just pop the lid- no easy task at first- (and, it should be able to snap onto the base so the cats don't carry it off. And mine will.) power it up, plug into your device(s), go to the Pogo website and set up an account. I was up in about 5 minutes. I plugged in my 2.5 drive, a MyBook, a USB stick and an SD card.
The Web interface is, compared to the Seagate and Maxell, simple, a bit odd, but once you catch on, fairly easy to navigate-except backing up, mainly from photo and video folders- you have to go to the root of the device rather than just up a folder.. You can set preferences on how to view your files, tiled or list. The list of files is fairly familiar when in list view, and loads quickly, depending on the size of the original folder.
I found connecting to photos almost instantaneous, being displayed in the Windows "slideshow" mode. Audio streams quite quickly as well, although the "play" sidebar is pervasive, and seems to remain through an open session.
Video and almost everything else is quite different- almost any other type of file "must be uploaded for Web conversion". PDF's, Word docs and Excel workbooks are fairly quick, but seem able to convert only one page at a time.
Video, however, is handled differently. left clicking seems to do nothing, but a right click gives you a drop down menu with several options- Download, Watch Movie, Copy/Move, Delete, Get Ling and Send Link. As I am still waiting to view a fairly small MPG file, I find the Download option is just like any other download from a "real" website, at whatever speed your connection will allow. You can also, of course, upload files to the Pogo and manage files and folders as if you were there.
One peculiar quirk has popped up, but for a reason I have yet to discover, the status light went from green to red. Resetting the power clears it, but that could be a drag if you were depending on it and it times out on you. On rebooting the device, the light blinks steady green, then goes dark, finally going to solid green.
Here we go (from their website):
"The solid orange or red LED indicates your Pogoplug device cannot contact the Pogoplug service. Please power down your Pogoplug with the drive(s) still attached, and then physically detach your drive(s) before proceeding with the following troubleshooting steps.
1) Your connection issue could be resolved with something as simple as a different Ethernet cable. Please substitute a different Ethernet cable and try a different Ethernet port on your router. You will need to power cycle Pogoplug to refresh the network connection attempt.
2) If this fails, look for your Pogoplug in the list of DHCP clients on the status page of your router. Look for an unnamed device with the same MAC address as on the bottom of your Pogoplug. (Note: a MAC address looks similar to aa:00:bb:99:cc:88)
3) If your Pogoplug is assigned a DHCP IP address, you are most likely experiencing an issue with your I.S.P.'s DNS server. We recommend entering a static entry in the DNS server field(s) of your router's basic Internet setup page. We've had good experience with 4.2.2.3. and 208.67.222.222. You can find more addresses by searching "fast free DNS server" on a search engine. You will need to power cycle Pogoplug to refresh your network connection."
What could be simpler, right? I hope the "average" user of this device is comfortable with assigning static IP addresses and messing with DNS entries. Too much like work- literally.
I have not yet worked with the Pogo Cloud- or any other really, so I am not truly qualified to compare. On of my main objection to the cloud is silly- how long would it take to upload the 500+ GB of data I store? I realize once it's done it's done- but the Pogo allows the process to be instantaneous- and just as easily disabled.
I am not sure how practical this will be for a lot of people already sold on the cloud, or people who are still unaware of it. I accidentally discovered a perfect example of a great use for it- or any cloud, for that matter- the day I connected it. I happened to be talking to a co-worker about a hike I took last summer through some unusual and spectacular countryside. I thought at first, "I'll bring the pictures in tomorrow"- and then, "Hey, wait a minute, they're right here!"
It also comes with a variety of real cloud capability- 5 GB for free, and variously priced incrementally larger clouds. In the face of other free cloud solutions which can also be configured to store locally as well, this device is, by some, to be slightly archaic. I'd have to agree, but as I said, consider it "Cloud 101"
So in conclusion, I have not yet drawn one. If you are unsold on the cloud notion, this might be a way to break yourself into it quickly and make up your own mind. I do not think a lot of people would pay even the most price of the Pogo to find out, but it might also be money well spent.