10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
This "Maze" is not worth wandering through, June 18, 2006
Having read all of the Savitch and Sherlock series I was truly looking forward to this book. Unfortunately, I was disappointed with the revenge and murder plotline as well as the poorly drawn characters. If you are a first time reader of Cathering Coulter, I would advise you to read the early Savitch/Sherlock books such as "The Maze", "The Edge" and "The Target". They are exciting, well plotted stories that are well worth the time you will invest reading them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I'm So Sorry, Catherine., March 3, 2006
I'm an avid reader who takes pleasure in spending (too much) money on books. Catherine Coulter, being that she's one of my favorite authors, takes up a large amount of space in my book cabinet along with Julie Garwood, Tami Hoag, and Patricia Cornwell. However, I've noticed Ms. Coulter's losing a bit of her pizzaz when it comes to her more recent works.
Before I read this book, although in honesty, I have yet to finish it, I was elated upon seeing that it would soon be in stores. I went to her website each and every day for the longest time, in hope that she'd post a preview as she always does. When I read about Ruth's adventure, I was excited and determined to purchase the book with all haste. Especially after witnessing the panic she was feeling. However, once I'd begun reading Point Blank, I realized she'd put everything she had into a powerful beginning and not so much into the rising action. To say in the least, I'm disappointed.
I'm currently stuck, for lack of a better word, on chapter twenty-one because I've been straying from reading this book. Instead, I've enveloped myself in the wonderfully written novels Julie Garwood has provided. I hate admitting the fact that although Coulter started out as my favorite author with novels such as The Maze, The Edge, Riptide, Eleventh Hour, Blindside, and Blowout, Julie Garwood is beginning to pull ahead with her brilliant works.
The dialogue in this book is so forced, along with the jokes and relationships. I took a bit of a peek ahead and witnessed a kiss between Ruth and Dix that was both expected yet unexpected. You see, he kissed her in a rather awkward moment. The dog had just wet himself (and her borrowed leather jacket) when Dix decides this is the time to kiss her. I'm sorry, but who does that? There was no indication, from what I saw, at that moment to suggest he even desired kissing her. Yes, it's bound to happen eventually- the two of them realizing they care about each other. But at such an awkward time? With no warning or no hint of what he'd been thinking or seeing? It was certainly a moment I'd like to forget because it's one of the worst moments she's written thus far between two characters.
Yes, the dialogue is indeed forced, as are the relationships, jokes, and laughter. I don't understand exactly what happened to my favorite author, but I sense this is perhaps a foreshadowing of the worst.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Hope you don't like closure..., August 31, 2005
I have read all of Catherine Coulter's previous FBI thrillers, and was looking forward to this one with anticipation. However, although overall this was a good yarn, this story did not have the coherence of Ms. Coulter's previous forays.
Trying to tie together essentially 2 stories -- the story of Savich & Sherlock and the story of Maestro, ends up shortchanging both stories. Ms. Coulters brings in certain facts in her story, making the read think, and then does not carry through. The reader is left hoping that a sequel will be published soon to answer all the questions, but, is left wondering if maybe Ms. Coulter lost 100 pages somewhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No