1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
From Russia With Hate: VVS Fighters!, July 30, 2008
This review is from: Polikarpov's Biplane Fighters - Red Star Vol. 6 (Paperback)
In 1939, over 90% of ALL Russian fighters in service were machines designed by Nikolay Polikarpov. 90%!! Apart from the I-16, all were biplane fighters, specifically, the I-5, I-15, I-15bis and I-153. Those last-named fighters are the subject of this excellent book by noted Russian aviation historian Yefim Gordon.
Though mention of Polikarpov biplanes brings up the image of stubby, rugged, maneuverable dogfighters powered by radial engines, Polikarpov's first fighter, the unsuccessful I-3, utilized an in-line engine. Switching to radial engines, the follow-up I-5 was a great success, eventually equipping 40% of the fighter force in 1933. The next model, the I-15, was a first-rate dogfighter but its production run was terminated prematurely by VVS brass who hated its gull-wing design. Its replacement - the I-15bis - went back to straight wings but was a disappointment. The I-153 returned to the gull-wing design but engine problems limited its usefulness. The final design - the I-190 - never got beyond the prototype stage.
Gordon and his co-author Keith Dexter do an excellent job summarizing the Polikarpov fighters, separate chapters being devoted to each design. After a short section summarizing initial development, Gordon and Dexter present a structural description of the aircraft followed by its operational history, special models produced and information on surviving examples or replicas.
POLIKARPOV'S BIPLANE FIGHTERS is a photographic treasure trove filled with hundreds of photos. The chapter on the I-15, for example, features 51 photos, many of which are new to this reviewer. Photo quality ranges from excellent to awful. The book also includes eight pages of front, upper and profile views of the basic and special one-off designs AND 15 pages of nicely done color profiles. Gordon and Dexter cram a lot of material in 127 pages; at $27.95, the book is a steal.
An excellent addition to Midland Publishing's 'Red Star' series, this book should appeal to anyone interested in Russian military aviation history. Recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No