Customer Reviews

Political Machine 2008

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I bought this game and fully expected it to be like other political turn-based games: weak, unexciting, unchallenging. Boy, I was wrong.

You get to creae a candidate, their looks, their clothes. Then , you choose which of 20 characteristics they are strong in: charisma, experience, looks,etc. You can play alone or aginst friends. Each candidate participates in a week by week turn-based campaign of 41 weeks.

Each turn, a candidate can do 1 or more of the following in each state:

1. Travel there or have a political operative or VP fly there
2. Build campaign headquarters, consulting centers, or outreach centers
3. Create ongoing TV, radio, or newspaper ads
4 Make speeches for a given issue
5. Hold fund-raising activities

In addition, after acquiring political clout one can hire operatives of all kind: spin doctors, initimidators, money men, webmasters, smear artists,etc. Most can be sent to specific states and moved.

One can also seek the endorsement of few dozen groups ranging from NRA, Unions to minority groups.

I find the game fascinating. The graphics can be adjusted all the way up to 1080. No bugs found yet at all.

Challenging since playing alone..you are matched with an opponent and starts with beginners and after each victory, the opponents get tougher and tougher.

The great part is the map of US can be viewed several ways: by # of elecoralvotes, party affiliation, etc.

In addition, there is a weekly summary screen after each turn showing popular vote, electoral votes (projected), newsflashes. Occasionally, you will also be asked to appear on talk shows!

The conclusion,when the map lights up state by state either reed or blue is awesome. Also, win or lose..you receive an anaysis explaining your loss or victory, exit polls, etc.

I highly recommend this game to anyone interested in politics, elections, or just having fun. This game, while exceptionl, coudl have its heuristics enahnecd even further to be quite complex.

Enjoy! Best $20 I ever spent!

This is my first time purchasing a title from this series, and I have to say that I loved it! If you enjoy politics, you will love this game!

Can you get your favorite candidate (even if they did not make the general election) win the presidency? I will not say that it is an overly hard game if you are familiar with politics and you are willing to read the instruction booklet, but it is extremely fun, and the difficulty settings will let you make it as hard or easy as you like.

Enjoy!

Much like the earlier Political Machine title, the 2008 is a tongue-in-cheek interpretation of political campaigning. Updated for the 2008 race with cartoony mini avatars of Sens. McCain, Obama, Clinton and other major primary candidates, the game is a decent strategy title but lacks the depth needed to keep you playing past your bedtime. Production was rushed to get the title on shelves during the election season, and that is apparent in the many misspellings and grammatical errors. Graphics are good - I personally loved their take on real-life figures like Larry King, Bill O'Reilly and Stephen Colbert - yet, underneath it all, gameplay largely consists of zig-zagging around the map raising your candidate's awareness and manipulating percentages. After just one or two campaigns, I had a technique for winning every time. All in all though, for its price, it is a decent strategy game that offers a good value, and it would be particularly fitting as a gift for the political junkie in your family.

As a fan of the political game genre going back to the Doonsbury election simulator of the mid-90s I've been excited to try a new one every four years and the experience always feels fairly fresh by that time. Over the last two months I've gotten a lot of replay value out of this one and there are still goals I'm setting for myself (winning is one thing, sweeping all 50 states is another.) The game has a nice range of candidates - from frontrunners like Obama, McCain, Hillary and Romney, to also rans like Ron Paul and Bill Richardson, to former presidents like Lyndon Baines Johnson and Teddy Roosevelt) and makes it easy to design more, who look and act fairly close to how you'd pictured them. The scenarios do provide some fun variation (like running during the civil war on a platform of pro slavery, squatters rights and opposing the transatlantic railroad, or running on an alien planet in favor of banning non-violent television and breaking away from the federation.) The game play is simple enough to be very accessible while still requiring strategy to really master. (In what order should you advertise heavily, gather an army of fund raisers, build up credibility with The Federal Tax Payers Union and the Christian Coalition, and hire political operatives like Spin Doctors and Smear Merchants? Some strategies do work better than others.) The game even has code that's easy to hack so you could, in theory, make Al Gore really charismatic or give John McCain the energy of a young pup by playing with the Program Files.

That said, the game is far from perfect and has some issues, some really annoying and some fairly nit picky. The worst is a fairly notorious set of bugs. Not only does the game occasionally crash and lose your progress but it has some rather unfathomable problems (for some reason telling voters you favor high gas prices is a good thing, but it's far more effective if you do it with speeches than TV ads.) Sloppy. One of my biggest beefs is also that there's one side of every issue that will make you more popular than its opposite, and its the same side in every state. For example, I understand that opposing the War in Iraq would make you more popular in Massachusetts, but would it really make you more popular in Alabama, too? Why isn't there a single issue in which one side or the other seems to be the correct answer? I also can't decide what I think about the fact that so many of the political issues don't seem political. Voters apparently really like a politician that favors Improving the Economy, for example. And alternative energy. They like alternative energy. But every politician in every party favors those things. Is the game calling voters dumb for responding to platitudes over substance, and if so, are they right?

I also have minor nitpicks like the fact that FDR is programmed into the code but was apparently left unfinished and therefore can't be unlocked without altering the source. When you do unlock him he acts like FDR but he's identical to Mitt Romney. Just uses the same icon. Strange.

Anyway, this game would have been perfect if they'd just laid more of the groundwork for it more solidly before the last minute, and then just tweaked some of the specifics to make it seem ripped from the headlines. They could have made high gas prices one of the core issues of the election rather than universal health care (which they're spot on with) but simply weighted them in relative importance long after both were programmed into the game (which, judging from the bizarre bugs, they probably didn't.) Still, this all seems like nitpicking because for a political junky like me it's full of fun stuff to play around with and gives you a way to contemplate the political scene even on a slow news cycle day.

I bought this game for my 13 year old brother and he loves the game. He is quite interested in politics, and has learned quite a bit about the whole process from this game.

This is a game that will keep you interested for a few hours, but it gets pretty boring pretty fast. The cartoons are nice but don't expect too much from it. Just go with it for maybe 4 or 5 hours and then you're pretty much tired of it and ready to move on with your life.

This game is a pretty good one. When I first played it, it was so fun and addictive. Trying to outbeat the computer was a fun task. It is very fun the first 5 times... then it begins to feel repetitive and I stopped playing since. I paid 5.00, and was worth it to me. If you politics, I'd recommend this game. I will not go into much detail since I doubt much more people will buy it though.

It has a short learing curve, the first campaign game being easy enough. Just make sure you utilize the different map views (Drop down menu at the top of the screen). The strategy takes a little longer, not all candidates can campaign the same way. Some need to rely on money or influence, while others can talk their way through the campaign.

The game's life is extended by the use of alternate scenarios beyond the most recent election, including an alien election. For an added bonus you can start the game with out the CD in the computer, allowing for less headache in Lan play.

Although I purchased this game after the elections, I am still enjoying it enormously. Very clever!

Political Machine 2008 review

Well the new election is coming up and I was eagerly awaited the updated Political Machine 2008 release (PM08.)

The Good:
First, PM08 is easy to jump right into and start playing. It is more intuitive than PM04. The graphics are upgraded and cool. You can use the extensive controls to design your own bobble head to play with. I made an evil DNC hipster guy w/ multiple piercings and a GOP dominatrix with a cane. New 121 week campaign is awesome.

The Bad:
PM08 is not as hard as PM04. It might be the issues are more neutral this time, but I found, that on the Masochistic setting I had no problem beating the machine. It may just be my assumptions about the character settings that serve me so well. The AI is weak and fails to fully respond to my specific attacks. On the other hand, maybe I'm Karl Rove and Lee Atwater hybrid and don't know it. It does crash in Vista 64 every about 8-10 hours. Sometimes it is hard to find specific characters on a state in order to "Fix" them this isn't a big problem in short campaign but if your running 20-30 ads in California and have 3-4 Smear Merchants in state finding the enemy Definer is difficult.

The Ugly politics of it all.
Now for an example screwed up of player data. Money (wealth) is all screwed up. Starting with the richest John Kerry (7 rating) who doesn't count since Theresa doesn't let him touch it.

Mitt Romney (6 rating) worth 300-500 million should be getting a 10 but gets only a 6.
Cheney (7 rating) worth $90-110 million should be 9
Bush (8 rating) is worth $15-25 million should be 6
Obama (6 rating) is worth around $2 million including the corrupt Chicago land deals
McCain (6 rating) worth $25-40 million should be 6
Bill Clinton (6 rating) worth about $35 million is about right.
Hillary Clinton (8 rating) huh? worth the same, unless a divorcee came through.
John Edwards (6 rating) worth about $30 to 60 million. Should be 7.

So the numbers are all screwed up Obama only gets a 7 for fund raising. Bill Clinton rightfully gets a 9 and W gets a deserved proper 8. Obama should have a 2-3 for money and a 10 for fund razing. The polls are too kind to the GOP on Iraq. In the same vain they are far to kind to the DNP on High Gas Prices. I could go on.

This is really a great tool for learning demographics. Click on those states and learn the make-up of the people that live there. All in all it's worth the 20 bones.