Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Peter M. has the idea, but the execution is a little lacking, April 21, 2006
The author has the idea of polyrhythms right, and he explains it very well, and gives great audio examples. He also has right the idea of how to thoroughly teach polyrhythmic abilities, and enhance rhythmic dexterity. The book is lacking, however, when it comes to practice exercises. While the instructions say practice these exercises at all tempos, the accompanying CD has them only at one tempo per exercise (which is, surprise, close to the easiest tempo for that particular exercise)... of course, you're expected to do different tempos on your own, but since you're counting two rhythms at once, it is very difficult to objectively hear each of them, to know if you're not "cheating" one to make it fit into the correct rhythmic space provided by the other. The book provides the musician with some great new ways to think about rhythm. The problem is that the book advances too quickly to some really difficult stuff. If you sit with it for hours, and practice on your own (drumming on a desk, as I have done), you can ascend its steep slope and help your rhythmic abilities. (In the end, I didn't get very far along in the book). This takes a hell of a lot of patience, discipline, and work, and It would've been much easier if there were more exercises, which slowly increased in difficulty, rather than the few exercises which demand a leap in difficulty from one to the next.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Practice Required, January 2, 2008
This book is a wonderful tool for those who are serious about musicianship. However, unlike most books which spend their lengthy breadth trying to lead you along "12 stupid-simple steps," this book spends its pages with application. You will not get anything from this book if you just want to read about polyrhythms. This book is for those who want specific practice on the subject, and "Polyrhythms: A Musician's Guide" does that very well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
It's it really the "best book.", February 14, 2011
Polyrhythms are a complex subject and this book is listed in Modern Drummer magazine as "by far the best book on the subject." Is it really? This is NOT one of my favorite books. I think the topic is presented in a "dry" manner and lacks a creative presentation. My Problem is that I don't know much about Polyrhythms to offer an alternative way to present it. I do know what type of styles that I learn from in books and this is not it. It's not that the topic is hard to understand or extremely complicated. It is challenging but that is something I look for when purchasing a book. I think I have an issue with the "best book" annotation on the back cover. So here is my advice: Find a copy of this book before you buy it and look through it. If you can't find it at least click on the review and look at some of the pages. This book is defiantly not for all drummers but I can't say who would benefit and who would not. Normally, I could do that with other books that I have reviewed, but not this one. The only way to know If this book is right for you is to do some research on the topic of Polyrhythms and click on the book review and look at a few of the pages. I did not do that and I may not have purchased this book if I had.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|