Customer Reviews

Pornocopia, Updated Edition: Porn, Sex, Technology and Desire (A Five Star Title)

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

there is a lot i like about pornocopia -- for one thing, there aren't many books that examine the relationship between porn, sex, technology, and desire. o'toole's book definitely occupies a unique niche in the pornography book genre. i also really appreciated o'toole's use of narratives and the voices of sex workers and porn viewers. too many theorists, writers, and academics have written about porn without talking to either sex workers or porn viewers. finally, o'toole's voice is witty and entertaining and it makes pornocopia a fast read.

however, there's something odd about this book ... it's tone constantly moves between being an academic text (there are thorough footnotes and o'toole references many well-known texts about pornography) and being exceedingly casual. it's hard to know exactly where o'toole is coming from. also, a lot of the ground he covers in this book is covered better by other writers. he spends a lot of time discussing the history of pornography -- linda williams does this brilliantly in her book hard core: power, pleasure, and the frenzy of the visible. (he does cite her a lot). what's unique about o'toole's work, his examiniation of the way technology has shaped and impacted the porn industry, doesn't come until the end of the book.

i think this is an interesting book which provides some unique theorizing about porn -- but, i think if you're going to read one book about pornography, this shouldn't be it.

What is a book titled "Pornocopia" about? The worditself means nothing, except it hints that the book is aboutpornography in abundance and variety..." All this is true about "Pornocopia," but the subtitle, "Porn, sex, technology and desire" is misleading..." I can imagine a book about porn without "sex" and "desire," but the inclusion of those words seems more to confirm that yes, we're talking about the regular usage of the term "porn" and not some non-sexual metaphor. But "technology" is the twist. The book must be about the nexus between porn and technology. Don't be fooled by the cover. It isn't.

Laurence O'Toole is an unabashed porn consumer advocate. His goal, with "Pornocopia," is finally articulated in the closing words of the book: "Legal change is unlikely to come about...without a continued and far greater shift within the mainstream towards a brighter, more informed view on porn. Hopefully this book can feature as part of this cultural change" (p. 350). The "legal change" O'Toole seeks is an easing of restrictions on porn, especially in the United Kingdom...O'Toole imagines a world where reliable "mainstream" publications review porn so consumers can make better choices, where the law comes down on the side of the porn consumer rather than the anti-porn activists, and where the content of porn is debated for its potential to arouse rather than its moral implications...In trying to change culture, his enthusiasm damages his credibility. We get the point early on that he likes porn and doesn't think much of the arguments of porn's critics. He dismisses the traditional objections with this statement: "it is possible to expose the moraltarians' ideological position as unacceptable to most people...their doctrine is refutable if you decide that you don't want to live in a theocratic state..." (p. 26). That's about it for the "moraltarian" view (although he later addresses laws conceived of by such under-explored views). Instead of the addressing the traditionalist objections, O'Toole promises to focus on the objections of some feminists such as Andrea Dworkin and Catherine MacKinnon...O'Toole starts to with vigor, but then he trails off into a brief history of the porn industry...

The history is one of the strongest sections of the book. Here, basically factual information is conveyed in a linear narrative. The logical next chapter would have been about the state of the industry today, but instead O'Toole veers off again, this time with a chapter that gripes about the lack of an industry in Britain...O'Toole jumps between only two countries, the U.S. and the U.K. The U.S. story is interesting, the U.K. story is not. I'd imagine that even a British reader would share this opinion, because this is essentially the author's point. The problem is that too much time and attention is spent proving how boring porn in the U.K. is...

But the weakest chapter of "Pornocopia" is the one that actually is devoted to technology. Up until "The perils of cyberspace," O'Toole's approach was basically to argue that "it's not as bad as you think."...But by the time O'Toole gets to "cyberporn was not so `pervasive' or `ubiquitous' after all," (p. 248) everything that came before seems suspect...There is a lot of porn on line, and it is almost impossible to miss it. That fact does not imply the rightness or wrongness of the state of affairs, but any argument based on the opposite premise is very weak.

O'Toole's writing only gets weaker as the book draws to a close. What exactly he's trying to do is very unclear...The resulting "Vox"- lite is worse than you're imagining and what it is doing in the book is anyone's guess.

"Pornocopia" manages to make an inherently interesting topic very dull...O'Toole's position is not untenable. Far from it. He simply over-reaches, lets his enthusiasm get the better of his argument, and covers too many angles with too little depth.

While I will claim this book an important step towards demystifying the misinformed and injurious attitudes towards the "adult entertainment" industry, I say it with some reservation. O'Toole is very thorough (and amazingly convincing) in his examination and rebuttal of many of the unfair accusations against pornography. However, O'Toole's careful omissions of many of the tragic events in the porn world forced me to be a bit skeptical about his reportage. Nonetheless, I think this is an important text and a good read. O'Toole's defense is refreshing and, many times, enlightening, although I think his arguments are weakened by his unflinching one-sidedness (he asserts that "snuff" films don't exist and adult films aren't "obsence", yet he fails to report on "Bizarro-Sleaze" films of Robert Black and Gregory Dark--see "Neither Adult Nor Entertainment" by Willem R. Degroot and Matt Rundlet in Premiere, Sept. 1998). To conclude, I would suggest this text to anyone interested by the adult industries, but would suggest that the reader not be so credulous to accept all that O'Toole says without first checking up on his claims. In other words, O'Toole's Pornocopia would be a better work if he would have presented EVERYTHING and allowed the reader to come to his own conclusions about the porn-world. By leaving things out, it appears that O'Toole isn't confident that his championing of porn will be accepted and, subsequently an important trust can't be forged.

This book is not one sided. It looks at porn in a way that not many people care to---it looks at it from the inside (the industry and its stars---and the fact that O'Toole didn't go into Savannah's death in all it's gory detail is because that's not what the book is about! There are plenty of other places one can go to find out the dirty side of anything---the porn industy included) , the outside (how people...real people actually use porn, from a U.K. perspective (where censorship is rampant), etc. And all the while it is very even-handed and witty.

The book doesn't assume that all porn users are perverts, nor does O'Toole look down his nose at porn. He considers all sides and presents it. He doesn't make judgements for the reader. He's giving them the benefit of the doubt for having a brain and making their own decisions. Bravo!!!

Books on pornography are often salacious and amateurish. The flip side is that, if a writer wants to be taken seriously, he or she often overcompensates by being a bit dry. Thus is the issue with PORNOCOPIA by British writer Laurence O'Toole.

The book provides you with some good information on the world of smut, including the history of porn, legal constrictions, and how it is intersecting with technology. There is a good deal here that is original and thought provoking.

Yet PORNOCOPIA is just a tad too dry to merit a higher rating. No, I do not want the salaciousness (well, I do, but not here). But even a more academic book should have a readable tone. PORNOCOPIA barely manages that, and it is what keeps an ok book on the subject from being a better one.

I am a fan of porn, have been since I saw my first Playboy magazine. I am not only a fan though, I feel the need to learn as much about the history of adult films as much as just buying the new Jenna DVD. This book is enlightining in both Americas and British views of hardcore films, books etc.. The author has done his homework and writes with a real respect of the subject matter. The book also helped me realize their are other people like me who enjoy talking about and watching porn. Ilive in Tennessee and not many people outside of shop owners understand my fondness for porn. The book also opened my wife's eyes to a whole new form of entertainment that she previously just didnt understand. I highly recommend this book too all porn fans who want too better understand our hobby.

This is an ill-informed fan's one-sided look at the porn industry. The author was apparently so in awe of his subjects that he fearfully turned down the opportunity to be present at the taping of a sex scene between two porn actors. In addition, Mr. O'Toole inexplicably does not include the details of the porn star Savannah's untimely suicide at the end of her career. He refers to her as having "died" after quoting her at length on her financial success at the height of her career. This passage is intended to illustrate that many of the actresses working in adult films are completely happy doing so. It is inexcusable for him not to mention that she took her own life after being disfigured in a car accident. Pass on it.

This is a good book! Yes it takes a position, but that position is open and frank. Porn, sex, and profits are here to stay and in fact will boom during the next decade. If this makes you nervous you should consider leaving the planet. Accept it, live with it, in fact you should start enjoying it. We bet your neighbor does, your coworkers do, and probably your spouse. Read the book, it is fun and informative.