9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
It's not simple., April 2, 2009
Let's get one thing straight. Ken Stern knows a lot about the stock market. He also knows a lot about marketing books.
Now that we have that out of the way, be warned. This is not a simple book or a simple system. Mr. Stern offers his P3 system based on Valuation, market sentiment, and trends direction.
Let me explain something to Mr. Stern. Do you really think that any sizeable number of investors, having seen their retirement savings erode by 30-50%, would use your system? No. Only those who haven't lost anything will be taken in by this book. And, given the complexity of the system and the blind faith needed to implement it CONSISTENTLY (another Stern word), would require more moxie than most of us have.
Stern says that the herd is stupid and usually gets it wrong. However, he has times when he recommends running with the herd. There will be more running away with the herd when things get tough, and his methods will be like all the others, dust left behind.
Mr. Stern's methods are supposed to logical and rational, eliminating emotion from your investment decisions. Just do the screens once a month, pounce at will, and watch the money grow. However, watch out for the Great Void, because you'll need to adjust. By the way, there's no way of knowing if we are in a Great Void or at a bottom right now. Logically, you could flip a coin.
To those of you who are new to investing, let me explain something. Neither Ken Stern, nor Jim Jubak, nor Jim Cramer, nor Warren Buffett, nor anyone else with experience does it this way. We invest our money and then bite our nails, because there are fallacies in EVERY system. And here is the important part:
We have recently seen an erosion of wealth in the world economy rivalling that of the depression era. There is a good probability, perhaps a very high probability, that the stock market as a whole will be up in 5 years. Many of you will invest, using Sterns system, or a fund, or some other means, and see your wealth grow in the next 5 years. I hope I do too.
But to credit a specific system with your success would be a big mistake, especially when the economy decides to tank again next time.
If you read through Stern's book, which is not easy reading by the way, you will find points at which he is more honest than other times. In several places he speaks of his methods as a cocktail. That's exactly what they are. He also talks about back testing, but later explains that the future is unpredictable. He's right. At times he says you invest at your own risk, and most of us don't understand risk. That's right too.
In short, you may get some wisdom out of this book, but don't bet the farm on it. Buyers and Sellers beware.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting system - Impossible Stock Screens, March 8, 2009
I have been eagerly awaiting this book for a while. Having read through the entire system, I am eager to put the principles into action. The problem is, the entire system revolves around running very particular stock screens that the author sets forth toward the end of the book. After a great deal of effort, I have found it impossible to set up stock screeners on the internet to run the particular screens from this book. I have tried MANY MANY publicly available screeners, including the ones that the author states will run these screens, and I have tried proprietary screeners from two brokerage accounts and my subscription research service. NO LUCK! In short, the stock screens set forth in this book are useless to the average person because there are no tools available for running the screens as written.
I'll give you an example. One element from the first (and supposedly most important screen) in the book is this: "5-year historic earnings growth >= 1.20 percent of the industry median (meaning 20 percent higher than the industry)."
If the screening tool you plan to use can't do this operation (and I am willing to bet that yours cannot) then don't waste your money on this book. You will waste your time reading "the system" in chapters 1-9, only to discover that the stock screens in chapter 10 and beyond cannot be run. Very disappointing and frustrating.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No