I don't understand the major contrast about this charger. I bought it, I put my phone in it. I set it in the tray and it charges. Simple as that. I didn't buy it to protect my phone, the tray makes the phone set in only one spot and when it is in that spot it charges. I've not noticed any discharge during the day while I have it in the case. I've not had to take it out of the case. I think my phone connection port will last longer since I'm not plugging it in and unplugging it daily. This thing just works. My only complaint about it is the noise it makes when you insert the phone or remove the phone from the base, it makes a really unique sound which is no big deal, unless you plan on leaving it by your bed at night. When it finishes charging, at around 2-3 am, it makes this sound, just enough to wake me up. The noise is coming from the base, not the phone. I've contacted the power-mat CS folks to see if this can be quieter or turned off and am waiting for a response. This is my only issue.