11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Quintissential Guide to Guys, January 26, 2000
I didn't want to read this book. I really didn't. I passed it by dozens of times in the bookstore, reaching for something else instead, a confection when I had the taste for meat. Male angst-again. Updike, Heller, Russo, I've been there, done that. So not again. Not now.
I finally picked it up one day after an hour-long search found me still novel-less. Oh, well. Whatever. Three days later, I put it down.
"Preston Falls" is so gripping, so real, so harrowing, you'll let the phone ring off the hook until you're finished. You want to tell Willis to shape up, do the right thing; but if you're a guy, you know that it wouldn't do any good. I'd write more but I just picked up "Jernigan" and feel the need to get started.
Oh, one more thing: why only four stars you ask? Hey, if I gave the man five, he'd only let me down next time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The skill of close reading is dead in America, September 12, 1999
Though Gates is very careful to give his readers three of the central epic journeys of Western culture--PILGRIM'S PROGRESS, THE LORD OF THE RINGS, and PARSIFAL--against which to judge his ambition for Willis's quest, no one in these reviews seems to have noticed, or tried to understand the import, of these other quests in the text. Are they only ironic commentaries on Willis's fumbling? Or are they intended to signify that Willis, like Christian and Frodo and Parsifal, is a holy fool--albeit of a very late 20th. c. American sort? What are we to make of a world in which, as Champ puts it, "Like what if the Higher Power blew off the weekend?" What ought to be the object of a spiritual quest at this point in human history?
Sure, Willis is self-indulgent, and weak, and terminally ironic. But as he says to Jean, "You're not actually telling me anything about myself I don't know." And the fact that Willis fails in his quest does not make the quest less significant, nor him less honorable (or hilarious). At least he seems to be aware that life ought to be more than a house in Westchester, a job in the City as a p.r. flack, a family complete with dog and Cherokee, and a weekend retreat.
Even Carol, Jean's sister, is aware of all this. But Jean? The character everyone seems to feel sorry for? While she is Willis's utter counterpart, whose caustic judgmental attitude is barely held in check by her kneejerk "in fairness" shtick, she lacks his belief that there is something out there worth finding, something other than--in E.B. White's phrase from "The Second Tree From The Corner"--"a new wing."
When RABBIT, RUN was first published, many readers and critics seemed to miss Harry Angstrom's quest for grace, even though Updike used as part of his epigram "the motions of Grace." Here, Gates uses an epigram from PILGRIM'S PROGRESS, which reads, in part, "...his wife and children...began to cry after him to return; but the man put his fingers in his ears, and ran on, crying, "Life! life! eternal life!" I might have questioned Gates's bluntness. But obviously, he wasn't blunt enough.
While it may be true that Willis isn't someone you'd want to have as a friend--maybe--he, and the other characters, happen to be some of the most acutely self-aware, intelligent, and comic characters who have come our way in a long time.
Read this book. PRESTON FALLS is a masterpiece, dark and ruthless, and utterly lacking in innocence.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Pure Bitterness, June 26, 2000
This review is from: Preston Falls: A Novel (Paperback)
Willis is one of the most compelling characters I have ever encountered. As his marriage crumbles and his children avoid him, he isolates himself so as to be able to concentrate on his bitterness. He dervies so much pleasure from being able to justify his anger, addictions and selfishness that I was actually rooting him on in his quest for self destruction. He has no idea what it is that he really wants from his life, but you can be sure that it's everyone elses fault that he isn't getting it. His indignation at the world and the people in his life is so encompassing, so without personal blame, that rock bottom just doesn't exist for him. He never looks back, not once, and the result is horrifying, but delicious to watch.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No