Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Keep Your Corsets On ; Not Funny, November 12, 2004
Very disappointing. My daughter and I are Austen fanatics, and the idea of x-rated parodies of Jane was too delightful to pass up. Sadly, they are trite and predictable, and not funny for the most part. In a fit of madness, I bought each of us a copy of this tripe, and that was two too many. The idea had great promise, and it was a very clever idea, but the execution was poor. Try and find this on sale or at a garage sale. It's not worth the full price.
|
|
|
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Give it a chance......, December 15, 2001
I find myself in a state of disbelief that a group of Jane Austen readers, such as those that have preceded me in reviewing, could not get a laugh out of this work. I am not your average Jane Austen fan, for I am both male and 21, but I have noticed the custom that other Jane Austen lovers are some of the brightest and creative people per capita. I find her work delightfully humorous and, though not quite to same standard, I found Pride and Promiscuity rather enjoyable in its absurdity. There were obvious modernities throughout, but I found these to be part of the book's charm. I believe it goes with the territory of this parody; otherwise "Austen" would have been extraordinarily prophetic to write such an exact list of contemporary taboos. I never expect anyone to effectively simulate Austen's ideas or writing, but this was an agreeable farce. I found myself chuckling enough to compensate for those before me, "offended and disgusted." I dare not refer to it as a literary masterpiece, nor the self-proclaimed "discovery of the century," but, as a work of inexorable ludicrousness, I found it well worth my time.
|
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Pride and Promiscuity, August 5, 2004
I was in a quaint, northern Yorkshire bookstore when this work caught my eye. As I will typically buy anything even remotely related to Jane Austen, as the cover was very much in the style of an early 19th century publication, and as I do enjoy innuendo when done well, I bought it. I began reading it that very night, but was soon disappointed.
First, the circumstances are too bold; Mere insinuation would have better complemented Austen's own writings. Instead, even I was shocked and horrified at many of the downright disgusting scenarios. They ultimately detract from what could have been a very charming and humorous read.
Second, the writing, though superficially in the Jane Austen style, was not remarkable. I know of several people who can achieve the same effect of style with little difficulty (and in fact, I have read several more amusing Austen "sex scenes," written by amateur Austen devotees).
There are a few clever turns, but in considering both the bold scenarios and the mediocre writing, the book, in my opinion, can at most be deemed only mildly amusing.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|