Primal Vision [Paperback]

Gottfried Benn (Author), E. B. Ashton (Editor)

Product Details

• Paperback: 294 pages
• Publisher: New Directions Publishing (January 17, 1971)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0811200086
• ISBN-13: 978-0811200080
• Product Dimensions: 8 x 5.2 x 0.9 inches
• Shipping Weight: 10.4 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 3.7 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (3 customer reviews)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #1,474,875 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars a flawed genius, September 6, 2001

By 

Michael Sympson - See all my reviews

This review is from: Primal Vision (Paperback)

At present I am translating for an English publisher a collection of poetry and prose by Gottfried Benn. So I am familiar with the title piece ÒPrimal VisionÓ or ÒUrgesicht.Ó It is one of the pieces I have excluded from my collection, and here is why: It is very hard to translate. As a linguist, I am not afraid of the sheer difficulty, but there is also an other aspect. Translating imaginative literature is not like translating for the United Nations. There are 2 major barriers: an unfamiliar language and unfamiliar conventions of style. The problem is to translate faithfully without producing something too outlandish to be acceptable for the English/American reader.

BennÕs ÒPrimal VisionÓ is hard to categorize - it is not a story, but it also is not like the explanatory prose for an essay. At best we should think of it as a verbal collage or a prose poem in RimbaudÕs vein. There is a line of thought behind it - or rather an obsession, one of BennÕs pet-hates. It is a powerful expression of the authorÕs disgust with the empirical realism of modern science (written by an extremely well trained scientist) and also expresses a for the time very common sentiment of disappointment with rationalism and neo-Kantian idealism. Plenty of Ò-isms.Ó But none of this shows on the glittering surface created by one of the great linguistic geniuses in his language.

Benn had a small but devoted following in France, way back in the nineteen twentieth. He was credited to be one of the 4 major poets of his time in the whole of Europe. In his own country he was less appreciated, but still acknowledged as one of the leading intellectuals before 1933. Then came Hitler and Benn fell into the trap of his own irrationalism. He found the vulgarity of the Nazis despicable, and he certainly was no anti-Semite, but he agreed on a particularly nasty point, little debated, if at all, that made him a Nazi-sympathizer even after 1945: Benn was a physician by profession, he had a profound understanding of genetics and at least since 1930 his work is laced with approving remarks on eugenic policies, policies which in the hands of the Nazis meant Òmercy killingsÓ of the mentally impaired and mandatory castration of carriers with hereditary diseases. Benn himself had a sister suffering from hereditary glaucoma and he was convinced that even his own family had to be cut off from the gene pool.

The result was BennÕs very public commitment to the Nazis after 1933. It immediately ruined his international reputation and alienated him from most of his friends, of which many had fled into exile. However the new masters smelled a rat. Benn was too intellectual, too sharp, too ÒcynicalÓ for their taste; his publications before 1933 contained passages of what could be interpreted as ÒliberalÓ (read his essay on abortion) and lax on morals. BennÕs unflinching view on the facts of biological life earned him the denigration of a Òpervert and sodomite.Ó As a doctor he was stricken from the list of G.Ps. entitled to write subscriptions under the national health insurance act - which was tantamount to professional suicide. As an author he was still able to publish until 1938; then official censorship put an end to his literary career as well. Benn retreated into army service in the rank of a colonel in the medical corps. In this function he produced a study on the causes of suicide. Had this study sent the wrong message, widows of war veterans who had committed suicide could have lost their pensions. Benn knew this, and he argued therefore, that suicide is a completely spontaneous act out of a momentÕs inspiration. The widows continued to receive their pensions.

After the war Benn regained part of his literary reputation, but he never recanted the views that made him commit his political boo-boo in the first place - a fact conveniently glossed over by his admirers. ÒPrimal VisionÓ contains all the seeds and intellectual props which led to BennÕs downfall, but they are so thoroughly embedded in BennÕs dazzling rhetorics that it passed unnoticed. It is a brilliance that obscures the real issues under a veneer of an elitist but hollow art-philosophy which in its days had been influential for more than half a century. Benn was a great talent and the living example that even genius is no protection against flaws of character.

14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars An indispensable part of modern German poetry, December 10, 1999

By 

Adam P. Lounsbery (New York, NY) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Primal Vision (Paperback)

Gottfried Benn, a German writer and doctor who served in both World War I and World War II, occupies a curious place in the annals of modern literature. His contribution to German letters in the 20th century is undeniable, but his work centers so strongly on the grotesque and horrible that he has never risen to the levels of adoration reserved for poets like Rilke. This is understandable, but a bit of a shame. (Benn's obsession with images of death, decay, and disfigurement are not surprising, considering the fact that during World War I he was stationed in Brussels, where he was in charge of treating the venereal diseases of prostitutes and prisoners of war.) "Primal Vision" is a comprehensive collection of his poems and prose. The prose works are translated into English, and the poems are printed in both English translation and in the original German. This book is perfect for English readers who have never before encountered Benn. (Fans of Benn may want to also check out the album "Morgue" by the German band Das Ich, which sets many of Benn's early poems to music.)

2.0 out of 5 stars Not what I expected, January 26, 2012

By 

Emby - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This review is from: Primal Vision (Paperback)

I had read one or two of Gottfried Benn's medical poems in a poetry workshop. I loved them and bought this book thinking I'd discover more gems. Instead, I found myself challenged by language and construction that were, at best, obscure, and at worst, barely made sense, at least to me. Some of this problem might have had to do with the fact that the book translates essays and poems from German; perhaps some of the interpretations were awkward. Much of the content is also philosophical, which is not my cup of tea. Finally, it wasn't clear whether he was a Nazi sympathizer or not, and the ambiguity was unsettling. What was clear is that he identified strongly with whatever the national character was going through at the time the material was written, and that was the one aspect of the book that was provocative and compelling. I may still try to tough this one out, but it won't be easy.