Most Helpful Customer Reviews
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Smashing Sequal to "Princess of the Midnight Ball", June 1, 2010
This review is from: Princess of Glass (Hardcover)
After all the nights she has spent dancing for the wicked King of Under Stone, Princess Poppy refuses to dance. She has plenty else to do: knitting, gambling, and participating in an exchange program concocted by her father and the rulers of Ionia. Enter a miserable servant named Ellen, a former lady who is desperate to reagain her wealth, no matter what. Add a vengeful fairy godmother, glass slippers, and spells, and you got a huge enchantment.
As a supporting character, Poppy gave off a determined and fiesty air. As a main character, you can't help but like her. She's got a mind of her own and is intelligent, but at the same time, she's haunted by nightmares of the King of Under Stone and his court. I'm glad she gets her own story.
Christian was a real person. He was neither the classic "perfect prince", or the selfish spoiled brat. He clearly knows his duty is to his country, yet at the same time, he feels the need to escape it all. Christian shows clear intelligence, loyalty, and courage. The only part of the book where he annoyed me was when he was mooning over "Lady Ella".
At first, Ellen seemed like a selfish brat. She can't do anything right, and she's rude to the people who have taken her in. But as the story progressed, you couldn't help but sympathise for her misfortune.
This is the most original "Cinderella" retelling that I've read. I enjoyed how Ms.George kept key points in the story (the glass slippers, fairy godmother), yet was able to write a whole new take on a popular tale. I would recomend this book to anyone who enjoys unique fairy tale retellings.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, May 31, 2010
This review is from: Princess of Glass (Hardcover)
Gold Star Award Winner!
Poppy from PRINCESS OF THE MIDNIGHT BALL returns and, along with her unmarried sisters, is currently helping her father regain political alliances by participating in a royal exchange. Now she's living with her cousins, Lord and Lady Seadown, and their daughter, Marianne.
She turns down invitations to balls because she refuses to dance after surviving the curse from her mother. Society soon frowns upon her absence, thus forcing Poppy to attend the balls. Instead of dancing, she joins the gentlemen and plays cards. She and Marianne become friends with the young royal prince staying with the King.
When Prince Christian notices how different Poppy is from other girls, he's intrigued and happy to spend time with her. Some assume a marriage isn't far behind, but before anything transpires, a young, mysterious, beautiful woman enters the picture.
Before long, all the men are falling in love with her and making absolute fools of themselves, while the women detest her. Poppy notices that something's not right. Could the magical protection she's wearing stop her from seeing an enchantment?
Seeing clearly, she recognizes the mystery girl as a previously wealthy young lady fallen on hard times. Instead of dancing and enjoying frivolity, Ellen's now forced to become a maid. Can Poppy stop Ellen from making a terrible bargain with a creature who will demand something horrible in return?
Just when Poppy thought she'd finished with evil, she must battle the Corley to save the lives of those she loves dearly.
One can only hope that Jessica Day George will continue to write more about these charming sisters and their battles with magical, evil creatures. The friendship, sense of self, evil beings, drama, and romance make PRINCESS OF GLASS a must-read for lovers of fairytales and fantasy stories.
Reviewed by: Jennifer Rummel
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fluffy fun!, September 2, 2010
This review is from: Princess of Glass (Hardcover)
Picking up where Princess of the Midnight Ball (George's excellent retelling of The Twelve Dancing Princesses) left off, Princess of Glass follows charismatic middle sister Poppy. After the events of the previous book strained the alliances of the neighboring kingdoms, the king of Breton concocts a princess/prince exchange to help smooth tensions and strengthen alliances through marriage. Poppy finds herself in Breton, mingling with the aristocrats and awkwardly trying to tactfully decline dance partners without going into the details of her family's former curse. Accompanying her is the warm and welcoming Seadown family and the charming and attractive prince Christian of Danelaw.
Though it is immensely fun to read about the gorgeous dresses, courtly juggling, and budding romance between Poppy and Christian, George also expertly weaves in a fresh reworking of the Cinderella story. Waiting on Poppy and the Seadowns is Ellen, a clumsy maid formerly of aristocratic status but recently fallen from grace after the death of her secretly destitute father. Ellen doesn't seem capable or motivated to do anything right, burning and wrinkling the clothing she is supposed to be ironing, dropping dishes, and losing garments.
Frustrated with her fallen status, Ellen eagerly accepts the patronage of a mysterious woman who refers to herself as the Corley and insists Ellen call her godmother. Bolstered by the support and gifts from her newfound godmother, Ellen attends ball after ball as the beautiful and mysterious Lady Ella. Enchanting all of the men in attendance, Ellen delights in her new life as Lady Ella, but she soon learns that her godmother's gifts come at a high price.
While not quite as good as Princess of the Midnight Ball, this sequel is still an enjoyable read and classic light and sweet JDG. The compulsively likable and plucky characters and beautiful imagery I've come to expect from JDG were both present. Poppy was just as delightful as she was in the first book, and the Seadowns made for a wonderfully warm and happy supporting cast. I liked how Poppy rose to the occasion, but I also like how she did still have realistic fears left over from her ordeal in the first book. The dresses described were so beautiful and really fun to read about.
As in PotMB, the villain's otherworld was gorgeously and vividly described, though unlike the previous book, the Corely was not as scary as King Understone, nor was her back story as satisfying.
Minor spoilers:
I also had a much harder time sympathizing with Ellen than I did with Rose and her sisters in the previous book. I spent so much time disliking Ellen, that it was difficult to switch gears toward the end and feel sorry for her. Similarly, while I liked Christian and thought he and Poppy made a good couple, he also spent so much time mooning over Lady Ella that it was a little difficult to get comfortable with the idea of his romance with Poppy. Granted, he was under enchantment, but he made such a fool out of himself falling all over Ella and completely neglecting Poppy. It was a little irritating to read about after a while. I wish the counter-charms Poppy made had worked more on him, though I understand why they couldn't.
End of spoilers.
While it isn't absolutely necessary to read Princess of the Midnight Ball before reading Princess of Glass, it would help the reader understand a lot of references a lot better. Also, if the second book is read before the first, then the first book is completely spoiled. Comparisons between the two are inevitable, and while PoG wasn't quite as good as PotMB, it was still a very enjoyable story and a fresh take on the Cinderella tale. Definitely recommended to JDG fans and fans of fantasy and fairy tale retellings.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|