From Publishers Weekly
Starred Review. Talk about "ripped from today's headlines"—this exciting and moving audio version of a veteran
Baltimore Sun foreign correspondent's incredibly timely thriller still has hot ink and sound bytes emanating from it. Although Fesperman set his book at Guantánamo in 2003 after spending some time there, and presumably finished it months before the current outrage about the former military base now serving as a holding unit for suspected terrorists, it reads and sounds—thanks to a cool, ironic and subtly impassioned performance by Colacci—like an Internet news feed. A very young Yemeni prisoner disappears, other prisoners kill themselves and brutal examiners justify their extreme behavior by scoffing at the Geneva Conventions. Colacci brings a large cast to life, starting with FBI interrogator and Arabic speaker Revere Falk, and manages to make Falk's so-called friends and security colleagues as equivocal as they come without breaking a sweat. Even the Cubans—who play a surprising role in the story—come across as a varied group. The only problem with playing this in a car is listeners might think they've turned on NPR by mistake.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Dan Fesperman, who researched hundreds of documents and visited Gitmo in 2003, definitely did his homework, and it paid off. Critics uniformly praised the meticulous research that allowed the writer to paint a vivid picture of life at Guantánamo Bay, the United States' troubled history with Cuba, and some of the moral quandaries the U.S. faces in its war on terror. That's the good part. However, as a thriller, many reviewers felt
Prisoner came out short; they complained about hackneyed, spy-thriller clichés and an anticlimactic ending. And some of the same critics who enjoyed Fesperman's journalistic perspective would have liked to have seen him delve more deeply into the controversy surrounding the military's interrogation techniques at the detention center. So the book is topical but not topical enough and a thriller that's not quite thrilling.
Copyright © 2004 Phillips & Nelson Media, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.