Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Back to form, October 23, 2003
Alice Hoffman's PRACTICAL MAGIC is easily her most popular title, yet she hasn't written anything similar to that book in many years, much to the dismay of her many fans. Subsequent books have ranged from disturbing to unfulfilling, as she tackled such powerful themes as spousal abuse, hazing and identity change. But this book returns her to the genre that suits her best: magical realism. The wonderful book spins the tale of a family of magical women, who pass psychic gifts from generation to generation. It's up the the latest of the Sparrow women, a rebellious teenager, to trace the disturbing history of this haunted family. Meanwhile, her mother, unhappily married and attempting to turn her back on the Sparrow gifts, learns from her daughter the terrible truth of the original Sparrow "witch." It's glorious reading and done in the lush style that Hoffman wears like a kid glove. Any Hoffman fan who has been disappointed in recent years will love this book, as will newcomers to Hoffman's work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Amazing Storyteller, October 1, 2003
Alice Hoffman is utterly amazing. Her books are magical, and I'm not just refering to the storylines. Alice Hoffman's writing seems to take on a surreal quality. Her words take you places. As a reader, you are drawn into the lives of her characters. You can feel their heartache, their happiness and their frustrations. But her talent doesn't stop there. Alice Hoffman's ability to describe surroundings, smells, tastes and textures is truly magical. The Probable Future is just one shining example oh how talented she is. The story is set in the small town of Unity, Massachussets. Unity may be slight in terms of population and shopping malls, but it's history is massive. Many of Unity's families carry with them a dark past. Their ancesters took part in the murder of a young girl. Although centuries have past since the incident, Unity is still filled with regret, loss and mystery. The Sparrow women have been an intregal part of Unity's history for hundred's of years. Each woman is given a "special gift" on her thirteenth birthday. A magical, although sometimes practical, ability is given to each young girl. Eleanor Sparrown can spot a liar. Jenny Sparrow is plagued with the dreams of others, and Stella Sparrow is able to view death before it occurs. The Sparrow women are special, although they may not enjoy their talents. This is the story of how these woman live with each other, and discover the magic of their family history. The Probable Future is a unbelievable book. You will relish in the sights and sounds of Unity and feel the emotions of each and every character as clearly as if you were a Unity resident yourself. Alice Hoffman's ability to stimulate your senses will allow you to sniff the sweet scent of lake water, touch the old oak trees and taste the culinary delights of Hull's Teahouse. When you finish you feel the history of this small town and understand why those Sparrown women are such an intregal part of it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
possible good read marred by some clumsy plotting/characters, July 24, 2004
Probable Future had a future. The premise, a family history of girls (the only ones born into the family) coming into a "gift" at thirteen set up as prelude to some family dysfunction has a lot of promise. There are a few very strong characters and some wonderful passages, especially in the latter part. Unfortunately, the story never really lives up to its premise. Stella, newly come into her gifts of seeing people's "probably futures" (seemingly their deaths only), is daughter to Jenny whose own gift of being able to dream other people's dreams led her into an unhappy marriage which has recently ended. She in turn is daughter to Elinor, the stern matriarch whose gift of always being able to spot a lie hasn't prevented her from missing certain truths and has left her, along with some family tragedy, alone and bitter. All three of them are "Sparrow girls" descended from Rebecca Sparrow who long ago was drowned as a witch and who passed on the legacy of a single gift at thirteen. Had Hoffman stopped there and explored the family dynamics she could have had a great tale. Unfortunately, she feels the need to spice it up with some more urgent drama. The drama comes when Stella tells her dad Will, (a charming man of absolutely no responsibility we are told again and again) that a girl will have her throat slit and asks him to try to prevent it. When it happens anyway he becomes the target of the ensuing investigation due to his strange foreknowledge. The killer then tries to track Stella down to prevent him from being uncovered. This is by far the weakest part of the plot. The killer's actions make very little sense, the police and judicial systems are implausible at best in their own actions, Will is far too dim, and the way in which the killer pops up and gets resolved is just very awkwardly handled. All of this from a plot arc that is really unnecessary. The gifts themselves are handled in clumsy fashion and with a slapdash sort of fashion. Stella sees preventable deaths but only of some people. She knows when they'll die, but only for some people. The visions are metaphorical, except when they're literal. Elinor can spot a lie which she takes as meaning she can spot a liar (I'm not clear on if this is her flaw or Hoffman's), but not always. The gifts conveniently occur for plot movement. They are seemingly never discussed among the women yet somehow there is shared information--either an inconsistency or a section the reader should have seen. The biggest oversight with regard to the gifts is the way in which Stella's seems to have almost no emotional impact on her. A thirteen-year-old girl surrounded by people whose deaths she sees who seems to experience little to no emotion? Thirteen-year-old girls have emotional responses to the new paint on their lockers. The impact of her gift was just too easily glossed over. There are further flaws of too easy resolutions, too shallow characterization, and repetitive imagery where Hoffman batters the reader a bit too much to make a point or simply doesn't trust the reader to catch an allusion or thematic lead. And then there are simply throwaway lines like a character getting into Harvard due only to their SAT's. Harvard turns down kids with perfect scores; nobody gets in based on their SAT's. Interestingly, by far the strongest characters are also the oldest--Elinor and her doctor. His characterization stands out for its richness and depth, while hers is not as strong but still a highlight of the book. The doctor's son Hap is not drawn as fully but the details are rich and human. The others are weakly portrayed with some being only two-dimensional. The historical sections are some of the strongest writing and one wishes there could have been more. Just as one wishes Hoffman could have focused more on the relationships among the three generations without the distraction of the murder or a "bad-boy" dispute between mom and daughter that seldom rises above sitcom fare. People who like Hoffman will probably still enjoy the book despite its flaws. It's more a frustratingly weak book than a bad book. But those looking for an introduction to her work probably want to start elsewhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|