From Library Journal
Grade 2-4-Addie's father promises her that when she is older, he'll send her to school. Then he goes off to war, serving as a guide to General Lee, and never returns. Addie, her mother, and her brother struggle to survive in the war-ravaged South, with only Papa's red flannel shirt to comfort them. When the time comes for Addie to go to school, she is dismayed to learn that the school has no supplies. Mama decides to make a quilt to raffle off and Addie gives up her father's shirt when her mother needs more fabric to complete it. The proceeds from the raffle are used to buy books and other materials, and Addie believes that Papa, in his own way, has kept his promise. This realistic tale, told from the point of view of a Southerner, is very touching. Like the pieces of the quilt, historical details are seamlessly interwoven in the story, bringing to life a very troubled time. Themes of resiliency, sacrifice, and hard work rewarded are gracefully woven into the narrative. Detailed illustrations give the flavor of the times with soft pastels complementing the tone of the story. Use this book with Patricia Polacco's Pink and Say (Philomel, 1994) as supplementary picture-book material for Civil War units, or use it alone as a good story of a family's values.
Anne Knickerbocker, Cedar Brook Elementary School, Houston, TX Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
When Addie is just five, her Papa leaves home to be General Lee's guide in the fight for something called "the Cause." In this poignant picture book, children find out how hard the Civil War was on the South, particularly on one little girl, Addie, whose father dies, leaving the family to struggle to find food and wrestle with their grief. What helps Addie is a promise her father once made--that she would one day go to school, learn to read and write, and make her mark in the world. In the devastated South, however, that seems unlikely. Then Mama begins a quilt she plans to sell. The money earned will go to books and supplies to start a school--but the quilt can't be completed until Addie sacrifices something she dearly treasures. Beier's pastoral watercolor paintings reflect both the mood and the ambience of a difficult time in history and a family's resolve to cope. Ransom includes an author's note about the war.
Shelley Townsend-Hudson