Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Promised (The Birthmarked Trilogy) Hardcover – October 2, 2012
|New from||Used from|
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
“An interesting mixture of fantasy and science fiction.” ―VOYA
“…a satisfying finish to a strong series that deftly mixed romance and, of all things, genetics.” ―Booklist
“Readers […] will want to see Gaia succeed against the odds once again.” ―Kirkus
“Readers who relish romance, lots of action and drama that includes overthrowing an evil regime, and strong female characters will love this book.” ―School Library Journal
Top Customer Reviews
Promised by Caragh O'Brien is the third installment of the Birthmarked trilogy. I really enjoyed Birthmarked and Prized, and was excited to see what Gaia and her friends were up to next since they were travelling back to the Enclave, where the scary Protectorat (and Leon's father) rules with an iron fist. Gaia is traveling back with her company, now Matrarch of New Sylum, after the death of Olivia. Her goal is to set up another community outside of the Enclave and broker for water and peace between their people. Unsurprisingly, she runs into difficulty.
I was so incredibly frustrated with this book from start to finish. First, we have Gaia, who I really liked in the first two books, but just couldn't like in this book. She has become Matrarch and fumbles around like someone who has no experience. This is the third book in the trilogy, she is allowed to be pretty awesome now in knowledge and skill, especially with all that she's been through. Instead, she makes mistake after mistake (pretty obvious ones too, ones where I was yelling to myself, WHY are you doing that??).
MAJOR SPOILER ALERT. She has supposedly PICKED Leon, but we still have Will and Peter Chardo in the background, always hanging around, because everyone is in love with Gaia. The thing that is most annoying is that she is bothered by the fact that these two boys may start developing feelings for other women. I almost stood up and gave Peter a high five when he asked Gaia if she enjoyed having two backups just in case things with Leon didn't work out.Read more ›
Promised starts off with the exodus of 1800 Sylum residents traipsing across the wasteland for weeks to get to The Enclave to set up a city outside the walls next to Wharfton. On the way, they rescue Gaia's older brother, Jack who has been stabbed, and his 8 year old brave friend, Angie. Will and Peter are still in the story and are still in love with Gaia, but have resolved that she is with Leon and their chances with her are over while still being fiercely protective of her. Upon arriving, Gaia is immediately arrested and only the quick thinking of Leon's sister Evelyn is she able to get free. The Protectorate and Mabrother Iris are just as evil as they were in Birthmarked and continue with the torture and lies, taking them to a new level of wickedness.
I did love that Leon is back and is a co-leader with Gaia, not just her lackey. I love that he is strong and stands up to Gaia, protecting her, standing up to his father and courageously taking the physical and mental torture the insane Iris dishes out. He was a main character in this book who did what he thought was right and was a powerful force against his father and in helping the revolution get started. He was extremely romantic with Gaia and beyond understanding in his love for her. He makes my heart melt and was the best thing about this story.Read more ›
What does not make any sense:
- the first night at their destination, she abandons the people she "leads" to sleep in her old house in a comfy bed
- when she meets her second brother for the very first time, they do not spend one sentence on "oh wow, so nice to fnally meet you" - they have a conversation about something or other, but zero emotional reaction to their first ever encounter
-someone said it before, she goes into some tunnel for some idiotic reason, gets lost, and after hours, finally finds someone who can tell her how to get back out. Umm, yeah. Idiot.
There are so many things that do not make sense, and, as a reader, I am so disengaged from the story, that I think I'll skip the rest of this. Too bad, I really loved the first two books, and this one kind of ruined the way I now perceive the series.
I don't know how many stars to rate it. Maybe two? And, Macmillan should have done a better job proofreading. There were typos, ommited words, and grammatical errors in the kindle edition.
In the second book the heroine flees the torture and the villain who runs the enclave seeking another society which may provide safety. She finds them, but it turns out that there are environmental hazards that also affect fertility of this population. This leads to the third book. To escape this toxic environment not only does the heroine return, but she leads an entire group of people back to the enclave with the villain who then tortures her, as well as her main love interest and has a henchman perform surgery to remove all of her eggs so they may be fertilized and given to other people with money.
These are really complicated themes, that get short shrift. You have to really willingly suspend all disbelief to get through the last book. At one point, the heroine draws the attention of the villain to a family who helped her escape in the first book and it apparantly takes days for the villain to get around to targeting them, though it takes much less time for them to remove and fertilize her eggs. The boy friends are cardboard characters. One is suspected by the "adoptive parents" of having molested a sister who kills herself - though apparantly the allegations are false.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Bored out of my mind with this series that was a whole lot of to-do about nothing. The writer would take up three pages to describe a brick wall that had no significance to the... Read morePublished 6 days ago by Rebecca
Overall this series has been losing speed since book one. The characters are interesting but the events seem less believable because you've got a 17 yr old girl as the elected... Read morePublished 2 months ago by mapleleafmanny
What a disappointing end to a series that started out so strong. In the first book I adored Gaia. She was strong, brave, and an all around dynamic character. Read morePublished 4 months ago by Amazon Customer
One of the best series I have read so I'm hoping that there will be more. Easy to become addicted!Published 4 months ago by Pam Owen
Disappointing and dreary ending to the trilogy This smart young woman made so many stupid and illogical choices and the ending was just depressing.Published 5 months ago by Ms. Albatross
Refreshing and interesting! The story flowed very well, kept my attention. Wonderful book. I purchased this series and I will be rereading it many times over.Published 7 months ago by book lover
Quite a terrible ending to a trilogy that had so much potential. I absolutely HATED this book. While the first one was exciting and had potential, this was a complete flop. Read morePublished 8 months ago by C. Winstead
This good had a great ending and the story didn't get stretched passed it's limits! I love this genre and this book is a great one for a lot of different people.Published 9 months ago by Kelsey
Terrific writing!!!! Kept me guessing then left me crying. The third book was the perfect ending to Gaia's journey. I recommend this to teenagers and their mothers!Published 11 months ago by T. Kimmel