|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
a dense, swirling pop gallery, December 26, 2000
How can it be that people haven't reviewed this great band?? O.K., if you haven't heard them before, you owe it to yourself to do so. Yes, they can be compared to Minne-mates Husker Du, but only in the sense that they play loud, heady pop songs. Whereas the Huskers took a more straightforward approach to songwriting, Arcwelder gives off a more nebulous feel, as if an album sort of 'happens' when they get together. Live, the trading of bass and guitar between the brothers Graber lends the feeling that we are watching something being born - perhaps for the first time. Many songs here convey the feeling of being drawn into something dense and swirling ("Criminal") yet not entirely hostile. Another effective Arcwelder mood is the bored yet articulate pensiveness found in "Will When You Won't", featuring (uncredited) horns that add to the I-dont-wanna-go-outside rainy feeling. Their methods border on madness at times, and a penchance for distorted vocals (Bill Graber) and crashing noise cadences can become distracting or downright annoying, but the quality of songs here will still hold your interest. Some of Bill's songs take us on a tinny, trebly ride that prefers a dronelike linearity over chord changes, and can create an evocative mood such as the eastern-tinged "Lahabim". Scott Macdonald's vocals have been compared to those of Bob Mould, with personal themes shrouded in more complexity and dense tones. All this may sound too serious, but the 'Welder boys are usually either rocking out or poking fun at themselves, as in the opening cut "Truth" where Bill reminds us "When it's all done/This is just a song". "What Did You Call It That For" may be a hint at its title's irrelevance to the subject matter, but the seriousness of the spinning riff will keep you guessing with each successive play.
|