17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing Ritz., June 6, 2009
This review is from: Puttin' On the Ritz: Fred Astaire and the Fine Art of Panache, A Biography (Hardcover)
I hate to speak ill of the dead (Levinson) but this has to be the worst book on Fred Astaire that I have ever read and I have collected all the books there are about him over the years. It is full of blinding inaccuracies and worse still is extremely dull.
I am still struggling to finish it and somewhere after the chapter on Ginger Rogers I lost the will to live. I sincerely hope that the author didn't pay his researchers a lot of money as they got basic facts completely wrong. One of the most glaring was saying that Miss Roger's gown in "Top Hat," the feathered dress she fought tooth and nail to wear was pink. Wrong, every Fred and Ginger fan knows that this gown was ice blue. If he can't be bothered to check on little things like that then what can you trust?
My advice would be to not waste your money on this book, there are far better books out there such as the Hannah Hyam book, "Fred and Ginger, the Astaire-Rogers Partnership 1934-1938" Buy this one and you won't be disappointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Limited Perspective, April 6, 2009
This review is from: Puttin' On the Ritz: Fred Astaire and the Fine Art of Panache, A Biography (Hardcover)
I've read almost all of the books on Astaire and when they fail, they first fail the test of balance...the test of proper weighing. The central mistake is to weigh Astaire's great achievements in solo dance, significantly over his great achievements in paired dance. The duets are typically underrated, as is the evaluation of his early career. In setting out to further iconize Astaire, writers like Levinson, not only give second class status to his greatest dancer partner, Ginger Rogers, (Hyam, Croce, and Mueller), they also, quite mindlessly, give lower status Astaire's COMPLETE achievement...defeating their own stated purposes.
This results in damage to the good reputations of all concerned....even in spite of good intentions. I am sorry to hear of Mr. Levinson's passing, but this book should not have been written. There are better books on Fred than this one. Not only does it fail to weigh the establishment of Astaire's career correctly, it also has more than a few obvious errors on his formative films.
What makes the book additionally disturbing is that Levinson repeats the many false statements about the alleged conflict between Fred and Ginger...false stories that emanated from the RKO publicity department to explain their breakup to the public...when the real reason was their eventual declining box office. This would be understandable in earlier years, but today, it has been refuted by so many sources, that it is just unacceptable, and should be seen as the serious error it is. After ten films, of course, there would have had to have been a few short lived "snits", as Rogers called them. But the steady respect and affection that each had for the other, throughout their entire lives, seems not to have made an impression on critics like Levinson...no matter how many times they have been denied by the accused.
Levinson serves a half-baked souffle. It's disappointing, and honestly I ready to sent the whole dish back to the kitchen.
Astaire's career had several aspects, but his early career was crucial to all his future successes. In this phase, he established his formidable creative process in dance, singing, music, acting, and directing. In this phase, he perfected his integrated approach to all elements of the dance-musical. And in this phase, he established his modus operandi in both the paired and solo dances. Central to this effort was Ginger Rogers.
It is difficult today to recall the absolutely electrifying effect that the Fred and Ginger partnership had on audiences of the 1930s. When they were dancing on screen: quiet prevailed, breathing ceased, and hearts fluttered. Upon their completion, movie audiences burst into spontaneous applause.
It is difficult to recall this today...but it's only mathematics to note that typically, in each of their films, THREE of the FOUR dances were DUETS. Hollywood producers then (as now), were hard boiled money-men...so it's quite safe to say, that this was not just happenstance. It was the PAIRED dances that sparked the imaginations of millions and created the tremendous box office bonanza for RKO. It was the PAIRED dances that established Astaire's career and assured his success and legend.
And what did the often reticent Fred say about his pairing with his greatest dance partner? Here's his rare evaluation: "Ginger was brilliantly effective. She made everything work for her. Actually she made everything very fine for both of us and she deserves MOST of the credit for our success.". Emphasis mine.
By their third film, Ginger was filled with self-confidence under Astaire's and Hermes Pan's coaching. Not every dancer then could have withstood Fred's insistent perfectionism. Rogers, petite, 5-4, 105 pounds, was mentally strong, and highly motivated and determined. She never once cracked. She was the "tough cookie" who just practiced harder. The results in virtuosic performance show an ease and grace that was underlied...unlike Adele...by an extraordinary commitment and unheard of hours of practice.
With Rogers, first among his partners, Astaire was able to achieve greater and greater choreographic and rhythmic complexity, knowing full well that she was capable of handling anything he and Pan could imagine. And in fact, Ginger herself, as Fred and Pan acknowledged, made her own contributions in this sphere as well.
Now add to this, the chemistry, and genuine poignancy, between them...even when not dancing, but when acting...and you begin to see Ginger's central importance to the whole enterprise. Rogers was a quality actress who also danced...and beautifully so. She dramatized every dance, with great technical skill, in a whole range of emotions. Astaire and Rogers were of one mind, and heart, and soul, on the dance floor. They together, were much more than the sum of two parts...and as such, were much more than any other of Astaire's later pairings. They together entered that rarefied realm of the sublime, time and time again....in ten films.
Rather than buying this book, I would recommend John Mueller's "Astaire Dancing", or Hannah Hyam's "Fred and Ginger", and still Arlene Croce's "The Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers Book".
Well needless to say...that in missing all this, Levinsen's book misses much about what is most essential about Fred. The book's major shortcoming...and there are many others...is that it fails, on its own terms, to give an objective view of Astaire's life and career, by failing to properly weigh the key role of Ginger Rogers, in performance, of the greatest of all film partnerships. Fans of Fred Astaire ought to be indignant at such treatment. Fred was.
WAITER! OH, WAITER!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Overview of Levinson's book and comments, April 11, 2010
An in depth study of Astaire's life and era. This book uses many of Astaire's
words from his autobio "Steps in Time"......and then fills in a lengthy objective review of his life and career. Mr. Levinson fills in many facts and comments by Astaire's peers and associates not included in Astaire's book. I was especially enlightened by Mr. Levinson's comments on Fred Astaire's jewish roots. For whatever reason Mr. Astaire had for not including that biographical fact in his bio remains a mystery to me. Everyone of us has had some "warts" in our life. Mr. Levinson, while not trying to "damage" Astaire's career, faithfully includes these facts in his book.
I, as a professional pianist, having worked with some of the best choreographers
and dancers in the business, have had much input from many of the people mentioned
in Levinson's book. I have also worked with Ginger Rogers and played many times
under Hal Borne of whom I heard countless stories of the Fred and Ginger years.
Truthfully, I adore Astaire and his fabulous career. What a talent! We'll never
see another one.
Ron Simone
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No