Most Helpful Customer Reviews
106 of 107 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Abstraction brought down to Earth, June 1, 2006
Those of us who read and enjoyed Prime Obsession (even the title has a delicious tabloid flavor, reminiscent of Basic Instinct or Fatal Attraction) may have been most amazed at the very idea of popularizing something as arcane and difficult as the Riemann Hypothesis. What made that book work so well was Derbyshire's brilliant alternation between historical narrative and description with chapters that served as a mathematical primer on number theory and other background material. The mathematically challenged reader could peruse these more technical chapters or leave them be by choice: there was still much knowledge to be gained in either case. For the more mathematically sophisticated, a complete reading of the book served as a reasonably deep (if popularized) analysis of the famous Riemann Hypothesis. Short of tackling H. M. Edward's Riemann's Zeta Function, the classic discussion and much more difficult, Derbyshire provided the most cogent introduction to the RH. Unknown Quantity is similarly constructed, with historical and biographical material alternating with chapters Derbyshire once again describes as mathematical primers. Although trained as a molecular biologist, I have a fairly strong background in mathematics. I still found much to learn. Especially interesting is the material on Vector Spaces and Algebras, the introduction to Hamiltonian Quaternions, Rings and Fields (with the vista of Abstract Algebra just over the hill) and a short introduction to Algebraic Geometry. I found even more to enjoy. The historical and biographical threads make the unfolding mathematics that much clearer and easier to visualize, hence more enjoyable. Derbyshire has produced another superb book that makes mathematics live and breath. To breath life into abstraction is a great gift. I reread Prime Obsession and will do the same for this newest work. If you find mathematics at all amenable to your taste, I urge you to sample this book. I look forward to being pleasantly surprised by the topic of his next work. Mike Birman
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
92 of 93 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
ALGEBRA THEN AND NOW, May 16, 2006
John Derbyshire's Prime Obsession, the story of the Riemann Hypothesis,was a mathematical tour de force but Mr. Derbyshire has done it again. He has written an extraordinary book which traces the history of algebra from its beginnings in the Fertile Crescent nearly four thousand years ago to such modern day abstractions as Category Theory. To assist the reader who has never encountered higher undergradate mathematics or who has forgotten the content of courses taken long ago, Mr. Derbyshire has provided well written, concise MATH PRIMERS on such diverse topics as Cubic and Quartic Equations, Roots of Unity, Vector Spaces and Algebras, Field Theory, and Algebraic Geometry. These Primers are scattered through the text and serve as guide-posts for the reader as she/he treks through the historical development of Algebra. If you have ever wondered how Algebra began and what groups, rings, fields, vector spaces, and algebras are then purchase this book. The author has also done a wonderful job of bringing alive the many men and women who, through the centuries, created modern day abstract algebra. This is not a light read but the prose and logic are superb. The reader who is willing to invest the time to complete this book will emerge all the richer for completing a thrilling intellectual adventure of the highest order.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
44 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another great read from Derbyshire, June 20, 2006
Mathematics is not a topic that is easy to read or write about. How lucky we are, then, that John Derbyshire has chosen once more to grace us with his talent for writing clear, concise, coherent prose on higher math. In Unknown Quantity, Derb has again achieved the near-impossible feat of writing an approachable, relatively easy-to-read book on mathematics. Reading Mr. Derbyshire's mathematical writings allows one to experience some of the awe and majesty of the deepest, most esoteric reaches of higher mathematics. In giving the common reader this chance, he does a service both to mathematics by allowing those who would rarely even hear about such topics to learn something of them and also to the reader by allowing him for a moment to feel smarter than he probably has any reason to. I cannot disagree with others who found Prime Obsession to be the better read, however this should not be taken as a serious criticism of Mr. Derbyshire or Unknown Quantity. Prime Obsession was helped by its more limited focus - not that the author had any shortage of interesting and enlightening information and insight to share. Unknown Quantity's goal of presenting a readable, reasonably approachable history of algebra is definitely met, but it would probably require a book several times the length of this one to properly explore all the intricacies of the story with the thoroughness that Mr. Derbyshire could. That book might not be as broadly marketable but I feel it would be gladly received by those of us who have discovered Derb's genius. If you have any interest in math or the history of human thought, you cannot go wrong with Unknown Quantity.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|