From Publishers Weekly
Despite a bumblebee protagonist, there's little to buzz about in this didactic picture book by Canadian television personality Petty. The three eponymous characters abruptly decide to "sail through the air/ to the magical land of Who-Knows-Where" in the bear's red ship. When they land on a distant star, the Prince of Night presents the trio with a wish-granting crown. The queen asks for a pair of wings and the bear wants to take the form of a man so he can wear clothes instead of hair, which is "always just there" ("I want to wear shirts, hats, tails, and pants,/ and change every time I go out to a dance").The bumblebee, however, ignores his friends' suggestions to alter his look and decides to be content with what he's got a move that ultimately saves them all from danger. Unfortunately, the "be yourself" message is buried in the sometimes forced rhymes and rushed story. And it is not clear that the bumblebee resists change out of strong self-esteem (considering his size and shape, he says, "I know if I changed any one of those things,/ then someone would say, `I don't like your wings' "). Whimsical perspectives and crisp watercolors go far in redeeming Cowles's (Gilbert de la Frogponde) lumpy, often misshapen characters. Even so, the illustrations do little to enliven the proceedings. Ages 4-up. (Apr.) 12 issue.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From School Library Journal
K-Gr 2-Canadian TV talk show host Dini Petty narrates this musical fantasy-in-verse, which is reminiscent of Peter and the Wolf and The Little Prince. Three friends set out on a magical red ship that takes them to see the Prince of the Night. The Prince gives them a crown of stars that is capable of granting one wish to each of them, with the warnings that the wishes are irreversible, and that the demon Growliss may try to steal the crown. The Queen wishes to have wings like the Bumblebee so she can fly. The Bear wants to become a man so he can wear fancy clothes and be admired. The Bumblebee chooses to stay just as he is, despite the urgings of his friends to get rid of his stinger or change his size. When Growliss attacks, it is the clear-headed Bumblebee who saves the day using his own unique gifts. The Queen and the Bear decide they want to return to their original forms, but can't because the wishes are irreversible. So the Bumblebee uses his own wish to change his friends back to their true forms, and all ends happily. The narrated musical piece, featuring classical orchestration and songs, is followed by a straight narration. This recording is noteworthy for its originality and high quality, with an impressive score and lovely songs sung by beautiful voices. While the music accompanying the appearance of Growliss may be frightening for very young children, most youngsters will enjoy anticipating the scary parts as they listen to the recording again and again. While the message of self-acceptance seems heavy-handed at times, and the rhymes don't always flow smoothly, overall this is an artful production that demonstrates respect for children's intelligence and sensibilities, making it a good choice for most collections.
Rachel Quenk, Thomas Memorial Library, Cape Elizabeth, ME
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.