Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good (3.5 stars), January 22, 2010
This review is from: The Queen's Governess (Hardcover)
The Queen's Governess is the story of Kat Ashley (nee Champernowne), governess to Princess Elizabeth, later Queen Elizabeth I. Kat, like the Tudors and Boleyns (and Thomas Cromwell, for that matter), literally came from nowhere, plucked from obscurity by Thomas Cromwell and placed in the household of Anne Boleyn. The Tudor court was full of self-made men and women, and Kat became one of those who fought for her reputation in a place when one's position there was uncertain. Kat Ashley became the Princess's governess in 1537, eventually becoming one of Elizabeth's closest confidants and First Lady of the Bedchamber. The novel opens when Kat is a young girl and meets Thomas Cromwell by fortuitous chance, and closes when Elizabeth becomes Queen.
I wanted to like this novel better than I did. Karen Harper certainly knows her period--the 16th century--and her dialogue and characters seem mostly authentic (the exception being Thomas Seymour, who comes across as a lot worse than I think he really was, and Kat herelf, which I'll explain in a bit). Unfortunately, this didn't really translate into a really good story for me. It's sort of hard for me to see what the focus of the novel is--is it Kat, whose life wasn't really all that interesting (even her romance with John Ashley is underplayed), or is it the story of Elizabeth, who doesn't get all that much on-screen time?
Sometimes I felt as though this novel read like a recitation of facts, not fiction based upon facts; and I felt that the novel jumped around a lot in time. Maybe, if the novel had been a bit longer, it might have allowed the author to go more in depth with the plot. Also, I didn't really buy the idea that Thomas Cromwell used Kat Ashley as one of his spies--though, of course, knowing what Cromwell was like, it could very likely have happened as not. The novel portray Kat Ashley as a bit of an innocent, but I believe that she must not have been entirely scrupulous, as it took a certain amount of wiliness to survive in the Tudor court. In comparison with some of Harper's other books, I would rate this slightly below Mistress Shakespeare. It's not Karen Harper's best novel, but as usual, she's definitely done her research.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An intriguing novel of the woman who knew the secrets and the scandals of the Tudor era, January 21, 2010
This review is from: The Queen's Governess (Hardcover)
Have you ever wondered what it was like to be among the court of the English King Henry VIII? He was the only King to ever have absolute power during his reign. He had the power to build you up and also the power to destroy you. We often hear the tales of those who reign, their stories told from their perspectives. Now emerges the story of Katherine Ashley, the only woman to have been in the midst of it all. This is Kat's story which begins during the end of Queen Katherine's reign and ends during the reign of Queen Elizabeth.
Katherine's story begins with an unforeseen accident that land's Kat as Thomas Cromwell's nurse. Proving herself to be trustworthy, and highly educated for a girl of her means Cromwell decides to send Kat to be further educated so he could use her as a spy to help elevated his status at court. Placing Kat as the go between for himself and the Lady Anne, Cromwell soon discovers many secrets that can be used to his advantage. Quickly gaining the trust and friendship of the new crowned Queen Anne, Kat is now privy to more knowledge than she could have ever imagined. With the Queen's failed attempts to produce an heir for the throne, Henry's favor soon turns to young Jane Seymour. Wanting to please the King as well as increase his own coffers Cromwell is quick to draw up a list of treasonous charges regarding Anne to place before an eager King. With Anne's fate sealed, she placed her one true friend Kat in charge of her small daughter. Caring for Elizabeth as she would care for her own child Kat forms the beginning of the Princess who will later become one of the greatest Queen England has ever seen. Together they survived through claims of illegitimacy, scathing scandals, and imprisonments in the Tower of London. They also survived the turbulent reigns of 3 monarchs.
The poet Thomas Wyatt once wrote
"These bloody days have broke my heart,
My lust, my youth did them depart,
And blind desire of estate.
Who hastes to climb to seek revert.
Of truth, circa Regna tonat.
Circa Regna tonat, meaning around the throne thunder rolls. What better way to sum up the era in which Kat Ashley was living. Knowing at any minute her world and that of Elizabeth's could come crashing down around them at any minute. It was a world in which you kept your enemies close and trusted few. I think Karen Harper went to great lengths to research and accurately portray in The Queen's Governess. She chose to shed a new light on the perspective in which we as readers view the Tudor reign by having Kat Ashley a woman who was privy to an enormous amount of court secrets and as well as scandals during a 4 reign, to narrate this story. I believe that fans of the Tudor and Elizabethan era will find a The Queen's Governess to be one of their favorite books of 2010.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
fresh royal biographical fiction, January 22, 2010
This review is from: The Queen's Governess (Hardcover)
Katherine Ashley has no hope for her future ever since her mother drowned and her father married Maud. Her stepmother treats Kat with contempt and uses her as a drone nursemaid to her half siblings.
Her impoverished slavish life changes when she does something for Thomas Cromwell, advisor to King Henry VIII. He takes her from her father's home, has her educated and sent to the court serving Anne Boleyn, but actually is a spy for him. In 1536 when the Queen is executed, Kat survives becoming governess to Boleyn's daughter, Elizabeth. She remains with the Princess through some hard times and continues to serve when Elizabeth becomes queen.
This is an intriguing look at the Tudor sixteenth century reign from the perspective of a servant caught in the middle several times during the rule of King Henry and Queen Mary while serving as s surrogate mother in many ways to Elizabeth before she becomes queen in 1558, over two decades after her mom was executed. Imprisoned twice during plots and counterplots, The Queen's Governess survived family and court intrigue; as Karen Harper provides fans of English royal biographical fiction with a fresh perspective.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
