From Publishers Weekly
Although the subtitle suggests that Higgins, a lecturer in history at Cambridge University, has compiled a Bartlett's for gay readers, his book is much richer than that. It focuses not on memorable one-liners (though those abound) but on sustained anecdotes from literature, biographies, lyrics, dialogue from plays and films, and so on. Ovid, Michelangelo, Whitman and others praise homosexual love, but Higgins balances the picture by also citing denouncers. Linked series of quotations create thumbnail "biographies" of such figures as Oscar Wilde, W.H. Auden and Tennessee Williams. Chapters are organized chronologically, leading the reader from antiquity to the present: essays that begin a chapter are informed and accessible, putting the quotations that follow into historical context. This absorbing book rewards both casual and sustained attention.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Boasting "contributors" that include Liberace, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Diderot, and Barbara Pym, this "compendium of quotes by and about gay men throughout the ages" attempts to tell the story of male homosexuality. Betraying a peculiarly British bent, Higgins, a lecturer in history at Cambridge, has assembled an eclectic mishmash from a wide variety of sources, from Plato's Symposium through the London Gay News. "The Power Behind the Mask," an awkward and defensively written critique of "homosexual history," is followed by short excerpts (five words to two pages) from novels, speeches, histories, biographies, and ephemera, all of which fail to coalesce. The index includes personal names but no titles, places, or subjects, and complete citations for sources are inconveniently listed in fine print in the acknowledgments, frustrating further research. This mistitled collection is not recommended.
James E. Van Buskirk, San Francisco P.L.Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.