Customer Reviews

Quelqu'un m'a dit

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(6)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I encountered Carla Bruni pretty much by chance, because somebody happened to mention listening to the song "Quelqu'un M'a Dit" on the radio and he asked me to translate it since I speak French. I am so glad he asked this favor of me, because the song is now one of my favorites. It is incredibly beautiful in a mellow, hopeful, and loving way. Definitely a song I never mind having stuck in my head. After hearing that, I decided I wanted to hear more of Carla Bruni's work. While "Quelqu'un M'a Dit" is still probably my favorite song on the CD, I love the entire thing. There is some great variety. Some of the music is more upbeat. You can definitely enjoy the CD if you don't speak French (several of my friends are now addicted to her music even though they don't know what she's singing), but if you do speak French, it's an even better treat. I adore her lyrics. They are very catchy, meaningful, and clever. I highly recommend this CD!

There is great clarity in this singer. Bruni knows exactly what she wants. And, as we know, she usually gets it.

On the minus side, i could discern little progress in her musical or poetic evolution - the same throaty, self-consciously husky voice, the same cords, musical progressions & song structure, the same half-singing/speaking as in other French and English pieces from previous CDs suggest lack of artistic ambition. I imagine that Bruni unabashedly chooses the hedonic, the sensual and the lyrical/poetic over music itself. That her self-understanding is frozen in some kind of a stasis box. Unlike - say - Sinead O'Connor or Sheryl Crow - she never commits the totality of her inner resources to the song; there is always a distance, a veil between the singer and the song and therefore, between the song and the listener.

Nonetheless.

There are some catchy tunes on this CD, my personal favorite is Raphaël. And L'excessive. And, of course, "La plus belle du quartier"

I am grad I purchsed this album from Amazon weeks ago. Carla has s very sweet voice and those songs are lovely. It's too bad Amazon doesn't have much information about this set, it's a Korean limited edition, it has a EXTRA booklet translated in Korean, and a 10' by 13' beautiful POSTER! (not the same picture on the cover). Although I don't understand Korean, but the poster is worth it.

I bought this CD based on the reviews I've read. I have to say I'm slightly dissappointed. Don't get me wrong, this CD is worth a listen. Is it great or something I'd rave about? No. Carla Bruni's voice is calming and capable, but it lacks depth and character. It's missing a certain flavour that would make her music more interesting. When music is as pared down as this, you need a voice that carries more emotion or depth or at least evoke a certain mood. Take Francoiz Breut or Coralie Clement or even Vanessa Paradis for example, their voices are not powerhouses but they add a bit of flavour to the songs they sing. Carla's guitar playing is more impressive. All that said, I'd recommend this CD as a worthy listen, very suitable for a quiet, relaxing day. It is a CD that's pretty good for a model.

Carla Bruni's music reflects her unique personal style. You will appreciate her music more by knowing her life stand and background. However, her music is simple and light. Do not expect to carry it for long.

For a first album it is quite impressive. Of the lot only one song or two are average, the rest are originals, with a unique touch that have you come back again and again. One of the top 3 albums I have bought this year.

Carla Bruni has a unique, raspy voice and her songs are haunting and dreamy. I play this in the background while working from home and it magically makes the time fly!

I saw a documentary on PBS about Carla Bruni and liked her voice and decided to order this album. I have enjoyed listening to her as she brings a little bit of Paris into my living room.

Ms. Sarkozy has an enchanting voice; smooth and cheerful. Even the sad songs sound happy!

This is a quiet and gentle CD of the old French genre reminiscent of the 60's a little. When I want something soothing this is perfect. I am curious to try another.