Customer Reviews

A Question of Death: An Illustrated Phryne Fisher Treasury

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

"A Question of Death" is a compendium of Phryne Fisher short stories and memorabilia, including recipes, a look in Phryne's closet, and an interesting essay on the genesis of the series and the writing process from Miss Fisher's creator, Kerry Greenwood. Also included are lavish and gorgeous illustrations. Even the paper feels luxurious. This collection is a must-have for every serious Phryne aficionado.

I rated it only four stars for two reasons: one, it is quite expensive for a novel of its size; and two (and more importantly), many of these characters and situations are first attempts at materials that were later fleshed out into novels. Ms. Greenwood cheerfully acknowledges that in her introduction, but if someone buys the book without reading the introduction, they may find that disappointing. If that sort of thing offends you (even if printed on really, really nice paper), do not buy this book.

Personally, I enjoyed it, although I think both Ms. Greenwood and Miss Fisher do better in novel format. A short story isn't really long enough to do them justice.

I have yet to read a Phryne Fisher adventure that hasn't entertained and enlightened. This illustrated collection of shorts and Phryne favorites is a great way to learn about the beginnings of the delightful detective and her unique family and associates.