From Publishers Weekly
"The moon was full the night they disappeared." This hushed, cryptic opening sets up readers for disappointment in this disjointed tale told through several viewpoints. The first perspective is from a woman fleeing with a baby by boat under cover of darkness, "to the hidden valley she remembered from so long ago." Almost nine years have passed in the next chapter, when Lester (Tess Snaps Snakes) introduces Biddy, who lives on a sheep and cattle farm with her parents and grandfather. Next, Biddy's best friend (who doesn't appear again until near the end of the book) reveals a family "secret" about her aunt Joycie, a young grieving widow who ran away from home and allegedly drowned with her infant son, Joe. Eventually the threads of the story join during a cattle drive on the headland when Biddy's horse, Bella, gets trapped in quicksand and Joe saves the animal. Intermittently, the author offers a rather sluggish account of how Joycie and Joe subsist in the wild, undetected, for years (sleeping in a cave, spearing fish and occasionally snatching essentials from a ranger's supplies). Though the author treats readers to some lyrical passages, she never fully develops the relationships between Biddy and her horse, or Joycie and Joe, so that the dramatic scene when Biddy abandons Bella to the quicksand doesn't have much impact. The vague time lapses between chapters from different characters' perspectives exacerbate the problem. Unfortunately, this novel does not succeed either as fully realized horse story or mystery. Ages 10-14.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 4-7-How exciting to read a novel for this audience that is so rich and multilayered. It is a gripping adventure story, a tale of survival, an engaging mystery, a touching animal story, and a family saga. All of these elements are held together by a wonderful sense of place and incorporate important yet subtly delivered themes of resilience, independence, and dependence. The opening chapter tells of a bereft young woman who chooses to leave behind her life and family in town to raise her son alone in the remote Australian headlands. With a shift forward nine years, readers meet a new character, 10-year-old Biddy, who is allowed for the first time to muster and drive the cattle home with her parents. When her beloved horse is caught in quicksand, Biddy is devastated that she must leave Bella, with only a slim hope that the animal will somehow get free. Returning the next day to the desolate beach, the child finds that the horse has escaped, with help provided by a set of small human footprints. Her search for Bella takes her into a wild, secret country where she discovers the truth about the mother and child's mysterious disappearance nine years earlier. The story shifts back and forth between Biddy and the boy until their meeting near the novel's conclusion when Joe's loneliness, Biddy's search for her horse, and their mutual curiosity bring them together. Australian idioms and bush customs are explained in context. This book will be easy to recommend to readers of varied interests.
Connie Tyrrell Burns, Mahoney Middle School, South Portland, MECopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.