4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Yes, this is what you want., April 25, 2008
This review is from: ROBOTECH: 20th Anniversary Soundtrack (Audio CD)
First of all, remember what the purpose of a soundtrack compilation is. You are so hard-core into the movie or TV show, or the music is so superb (as with John Williams, etc.) that you get the CD as part of the macro-entertainment experience.
A soundtrack is not like a conventional album. There is no concept, leitmotifs, one-hit wonders, and so forth. So keep that in mind when you picking and choosing to buy this. Disc one is the instrumental half, with that subconscious background music that is both wonderful and familiar.
Most of these tracks are short--for example track 24 "Eyecatch" used in the commercial breaks. Some are longer. But do not expect
Handel - Messiah - Mormon Tabernacle. The music exists to meet the needs of the TV show.
Disc 2 is a more conventional album, with Minmei and Yellow Dancer, plus other odds and ends from ROBOTECH II. You'll need the
Robotech - Protoculture Collection to see the aborted series.
(Parenthetically, you could bring disc 2 to your next 80s-Retro party. The music is a good sample of mid-80s synth-pop and rock. Much better than that Milli Vanilli nonsense!
How can they call this junk music? Or, how seeing Milli Vanilli in concert made me feel ready for the geriatric ward.: An article from: Music Trades)
In the ROBOTECHverse, music is an undergirding concept. It is Minmei's music that inspires the RDF, and eventually turns the Zentraedi into civilized beings. At the end of the saga, Yellow Dancer performs a similar role as morale-builder. Also, the Yellow Dancer personal enables Scott Bernard's freedom force to sneak in and out of Invid strongholds and to move about in the gamma world.
And in-between the sagas we have the romance of Bowie Grant and Musica. Taking a nod from Tolkien's music of the Ainur (
The Silmarillion), Musica's harp controls all of the clone Robotech Masters soldiers. Music is probably Protoculture's greatest gift to the series.
If you are a fan you really need a collection like this. Instead of the brief clips of Yellow Dancer singing, you get the full tune that the refugees and war victims heard at the concerts. In essence, this collection pulls you into the story in a way that the DVDs could not.
(I also recommed the McKinney novels to round out the macro-fan experience.
Robotech: The Macross Saga: Battle Cry (Robotech),
Robotech: The Macross Saga: Doomsday (Robotech 3-In-1),
Robotech: The Masters Saga: The Southern Cross (Robotech),
Robotech: The New Generation: The Invid invasion (Robotech: New Generation))
So, in sum ...
This collection has all that you would expect or need in a 20th anniversary retrospective. Except, of course, Lisa Hayes slurring "Miss Macross" while totally plastered (Episode 35 "Romanesque"). The only excuse for omitting this is space. But they could make it a free download on their webpage.
I haven't seen the source series (Macross, Calvary, Mosspeda), nor have I heard previous incarnations. Therefore I am not competent to comment on the comparative qualities. But for a mid-range ROBOTECH fan (as I am), this collection works for me. It rekindles wonderful memories of the ideals that I formed while watching ROBOTECH.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Robotech Soundtrack, October 8, 2010
This review is from: ROBOTECH: 20th Anniversary Soundtrack (Audio CD)
Hi There
This Soundtrack is an excellent choice, therefore it is a must have for any Robotech fan. I was so pleased to hear the new tracks therefore I give it 5 stars all the way.
Regards
Gerann
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No