1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Bibliotherapy: Jealously, January 26, 2005
This review is from: Rachel Parker, Kindergarten Show-Off (Paperback)
Rachel Parker, Kindergarten Show-off written by Ann Martin illustrated by Nancy Poydar
Olivia is a five-year-old kindergarten wiz. She loves the fact that she is the first to read in her class, and everyone tells her she is very good at kindergarten. Olivia gets new neighbors next door and the new neighbors have a daughter and she's in kindergarten too! Her name is Rachel and she is in the same class as Olivia. They begin to find out that they can do a lot of the same things and that when the competition and jealously comes into play. They dub each other show-offs and don't want to be each other's friend any more. The teacher helps them see that they can help each other and don't need to be jealous. The two girls become friends once again.
The subject matter in the book is current and up to date. There isn't any outdated material that I find to be present. The only thing that I found to be odd was that the class size in kindergarten was ten!
The reading level of this book is possibly first, but more along the lines of second grade. Some of the vocabulary is a little tough and is definitely not a book for beginning readers. I would have a student read it if they have been reading for a while and are comfortable readers.
The book is pretty long and contains a lot of words on the pages. I would recommend gauging your class to see whether or not they have the capability to sit through the book at that given time because it will take some time to read. I would break it up by stopping and discuss with them or have them talk to a neighbor about what's happening in the book.
The paragraphs are rather lengthy on the pages, however it is very child oriented so it should be interesting to the students. The pictures are plentiful, colorful and do a good job supporting the stories emotion.
The developmental level of this book is preschool through second grade. I don't think that I would read this book to a large group of preschoolers because I think you would probably loose them pretty quick. However, if you were reading it to one or two preschooler you would be able to engage them in the text by asking them specific questions and letting them respond. I think reading this book to a class of kindergarteners through second grader would work fine.
In the story Rachel Parker, Kindergarten Show-Off Olivia is an African American girl and Rachel is Caucasian. However, that's not made an issue in the story. It's just simply there. The issue in the story is jealousy within a friendship.
I would use this book with the whole class because I believe they could all relate in one-way or another. However, it may be appropriate to use with two students or one who is in situation where jealousy is getting in the way of their friendship with another person.
As I mentioned before the downfall of using this book is that it's rather long and you may loose some student's attention. Another one is that Olivia is in kindergarten and it may appear to be to young for first and second graders. However, once they get into the story they will see that the situation happens in all of the grades even though the story takes place in a kindergarten. The values in this book are friendship and belonging.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Long, but held the interest of my very active child, March 9, 2010
My daughter LOVED this book during her kindergarten and first grade year. She could really relate to the range of emotions portrayed in Martin's story, which are vividly brought to life by Poydar's illustrations. Now age 10, she has long since moved on to much more mature text - and yet this book was such a favorite that even now she refuses to part with it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
class assignment, March 13, 2003
This review is from: Rachel Parker, Kindergarten Show-Off (Paperback)
Olivia is an only child who is in kindergarten. She is the only one in her class who can read an write. Rachel Parker moves in next door. She also knows how to read and write. What happens between these two during class?
This is one of my favorite books. I have always enjoyed it. It shos how simple little things can get in the way of a friendship. They go back and forth trying to be better than each other and end up getting into a fight. I highly recommend this book for any child.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No