76 of 82 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
If you like building more than blowing up, November 22, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Railroad Tycoon 2 Gold (CD-ROM)
This is a satisfying and constructive game in which the gamer starts a company, lays track, builds stations, and decides what cars (loads) to carry. Among its STRENGTHS are the many scenarios; complexity varying from "sandbox" mode (build what you want without regard to cost or competitors) to difficult (facing AI opponents, and using an economic model involving stock market manipulations); easily available maps on the net; easy scenario and map creator;and the truly wonderful graphics, evocative of Thomas Hart Benton paintings. Among the WEAKNESSES are the absence of an undo button, useful because track-laying can be tricky; the relatively restricted choice of raw materials and industries to service; and a general sameness among scenarios, excepting the different areas of the world being covered. This is a very good game if you want to construct a (railroad) empire without devoting all your energies to fighting off military attacks, and if you find repeated actions, like changing the railroad cars, fun. This game will quickly become tedious to action junkies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great enhancements but also big omissions from the original, December 2, 2000
This review is from: Railroad Tycoon 2 Gold (CD-ROM)
I browsed through the reviews by other players, and I am surprised that noone mentioned the original Railroad Tycoon, one of my all-time favorite games. My guess is that most people are too young here to have played it. For those who did, I think a comparison to the original would be in order.
First, I should say, I loved Railroad Tycoon 2. Railroad building is probably the most fun among the building games, I think because you not only build, but run your empire as well. RR2 is a good game on its own, and it builds on the strengths of the original and gives great enhancements.
GREAT IMPROVEMENTS over the original are obviously the graphics... since about 10 years has passed, this was a must. The addition of scenarios, is great, and provides not only loads of fun, but knowledge about the history of trains over the world as well. The addition of the stock market brings a new dimension to the game that is fun, however I found that sometimes it got in the way of railroad building fun, requiring too much attention to finances with too little control. I also liked the building of tracks with one click a lot; although an "undo" feature is greatly missing - the easy building also means it is easy to make a mistake, and often a costly one. My recommendation is to save before every major track building effort.
DISAPPOINTING OMISSIONS from the original include the often mentioned tunnel building, but my biggest disappointment was the less operational control over your trains. That really manifests itself when you already have a big railroad network, and your trains keep waiting on each other, because they are all using the same track, and you have no way to route them on an alternate track. Therefore I greatly miss the feature where you can tell a train to go through a station but not stop there, and the signals; both can be a great help in avoiding the crowding of trains. Another disappointment was the interface; although it is OK, and a lot of the immaturities of the original have been cleaned up, but it still follows the layout of the original that is largely menu-driven. The added-on financial market interface is rather tedious and unintuitive.
All in all, this is a very good game, greatly because it follows closely the original, and updates it to the new game standards. This game is great for everyone, but if you have played the original, you will wonder why PopTop omitted some great features that could have made this game so much better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the best business sims around!, December 24, 1999
This review is from: Railroad Tycoon 2 Gold (CD-ROM)
If you like making money and a good challenge, this is the game for you. Laying track, building stations, and buying train engines is just the beginning of this complex game. You have to make decisions on where to lay track, which towns to service, and (in the scenerios provided) what is the best way to complete each scenerio. For scenerios, you are given at least 10 different maps to choose from, each with a different scenerio to complete and each with different computer opponents. In addition to trying to complete the requirements of each scenerio, you have to make decisions that keep your investors happy (or they will cut your salary) as well as personal financial decisions (or where to invest that salary) which gives the game a very "real-life" feel. To add to the "real-life" feel, the game can be played on-line or over a network with a group of your buddies which makes it even more fun. Overall, it is a great game which has incrediable graphics (trains, stations, towns, and landscape are drawn beautifully), a good manual, and is highly addictive. Actually, that is my only warning - if you like business simulation games like Rollercoaster Tycoon or previous versions of Railroad Tycoon - expect to spend several hours playing this game.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No