10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Better than 'Band of Brothers'; a good read for anyone, August 8, 2002
By A Customer
With all the `Band of Brothers' hoopla last year, this is a better book.
It's a simple story of a man trying to be the best there is -in this case an Army Ranger during two wars (Korea & Vietnam) - but he tells it in a way anyone can understand. No military credentials are needed. The sign of a good storyteller is getting the reader to have the same feelings the author does...I found myself full of pride, anger, frustration alongside Black; sometimes I wanted to cry and sometimes I wanted to pat this guy on the back. Sometimes I just went "Phew!"
This isn't a gung-ho book on "How I won the war". Its full of frailties, shortcomings, and reality. If you are looking for Gen. Patton's story, its not here. If you are looking for a coming of age story that includes finding identity, a successful path in life, and learning of the larger world around us, that is here. Black simply has the "good" misfortune of growing up in time that led him down a path to two wars, and his base of battle knowledge -- thick as a rocket launch pad - is the heart of the book.
The book includes also includes a fair amount of background of his early years as a farm kid, which is a good laugh. It's when the book takes off into his early training in Army is when this book really runs.
Anyone who ever protested the Vietnam War should read this - not to attack an agenda but to understand more about how the war affected us all. (This is coming from someone who remembers Walter Kronkite's reports from Saigon and whose Mom would have taken me to Canada had I been of draft age).
I usually don't read these types of military genre books, but I really loved it. This would be a great read on vacation, for anyone of any age. With all the stuff happening in world right now, we need more Blacks in this world to remind us what living is like when someone always wants you gone. Makes me appreciate the simple things in life. Makes me realize that we have heroes amongst us. But like Black, they don't think of themselves as one. It was a simple matter of just trying to be the best, and to come home.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Well Worth Reading, July 30, 2002
Dear Readers,
To properly praise a book means putting it in context with one's own background and experiences. US Army Ranger Bob Black's new book, A RANGER BORN, talks so well about his experiences in both the Korean and the Vietnam Wars, and has served in so many ways as a vivid reminder of my own Asian experiences, first as a USAF airman assigned to Osan Air Base south of Seoul in 1966, and then to Vietnam in 1967 and 1968.
That first tour in Korea was 13 years after the signing of the Armistice Agreement, and conditions were still very rough, with the war remaining very much in evidence.
Then, still as a military journalist, I went to Vietnam for a couple of back to back tours in the period before and after Tet 1968, ranging from the Mekong Delta fan to the bunkers of Dong Ha, at the eastern fringe of Leatherneck Square. I spent time at many of the air bases as well as on the ground or in the air above such places as Hue, Khe Sanh, Pleiku, Trang Sup, and Tay Ninh.
They were years of so much memory -- of people, events, places, sights, sounds, smells; some things sad, others horrible, some joyful, even proud, others so painful that wiped away would be a blessing.
You need to know this background so you will understand how crisp and sure, how factual and descriptive I found Colonel Black's narrative. He is a writer who has been there, done that, and come away mostly intact; first as a Corporal in Korea, up front as a Ranger, carrying a .30 caliber Browning Automatic Rifle in combat; then as a middle aged field grade officer trying so hard as an advisor to beat the politics while simultaneously trying so hard to instill a seed of military survival in Vietnamese units lacking so much while serving in the most terrible of circumstances.
Bob Black has a steel trap memory combined with the heart of a warrior. Searching for the words to tell it like it was, he used both heart and mind well, drawing from the well of experience in ample measure. Reading his passages, you can smell the garlic and kimchi, taste the fish sauce, feel the grit on your neck and the dust in your eyes, see the tracers bounce in nights lit only by flare light, hear the crunches, thumps and stutters of weaponry, and catch more than a whiff of cordite on some very hot, very humid, long and headache filled days.
It is my assessment that the Colonel, a very skilled writer as his other works so amply attest, has achieved great success in this, his latest endeavor, and this new book has the texture and feel of a classic, in the vein of Platoon Leader, Company Commander or even -- and yes, I believe this -- that great novel that continues to teach so many truths and realities about the military profession, Once An Eagle.
I am not a Ranger, though I am blessed to have Ranger friends, but I shared close contact with the Ranger community at Dugway, Utah a few years back, and take it as the strongest article of military faith that Rangers do indeed lead the way for all the rest of us. Back in those days, in the mid-1980s, I was an Army civilian, the installation PAO, and was between tours as the CINC speech writer in Korea.
Outside of incoming, that speech writing task held twice in Korea was the toughest job I ever had. Working deep in the shadows for such great soldiers as Robert Sennewald, Bill Livsey, Lou Menetrey and Robert RisCassi, and under friendly, sometimes stern guidance of CSMs Bill Gates, Ralph Phillips, Roosvelt Martain and Sam Smith, meant learning all I could learn about the Korean War, while not ignoring the valuable lessons of Vietnam and so many other conflicts and experiences, then putting it in context with the modern defense of Korea.
In the messages these men gave to a multiplicity of audiences, including hostile ones, credibility was a given, accuracy a must. Leadership examples had to be finely drawn. Facts had to be on time and on target, and adjustment of the message shot group continually required team effort in the building of a presentation and great skill by the individual speaker in its giving.
Noting the locale and delicacy of the speakers' positions, failure of communication carried grave risks. Designing words of praise intermingled with words of warning required a hefty library of resource materials.
Were I still doing that job today, A RANGER BORN, Bob Black's memoir of Asian war, would have a prominent and forward leaning place in my workspace; the book's pages turned and bent, sentences highlighted, paragraphs marked in search of truth about war; so huge and so visceral, so hard to ignore and yet so hard to describe in meaningful and complete language.
In a pair of deadly, terrible wars, Bob Black was there. He was the kind of soldier who saw both conflicts for what they were, and minced no words in telling the tale. His thoughts are of value for those who served, and of equal use for those who today protect our freedom in new, strange and deadly struggles.
If, in the next decade, you only read one work about the hot campaigns of the cold war, make it Bob Black's A RANGER BORN.
Respectfully Submitted for Consideration,
Rick Fulton
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No