From School Library Journal
Grade 1-4?In this sequel to No Dogs Allowed (Farrar, 1992), Cutler presents five, self-contained stories about seemingly routine events in the lives of Jason and his six-year-old brother Edward. The book begins just before the school year starts when the boys go on their annual shopping trip. Very conscious of his fourth-grade image, Jason insists on looking at everything before he makes any decisions. Edward, meanwhile, explores the wig department with hilarious results. The stories continue as Jason attempts to deal with the inexplicable courtship rites initiated by the girls; Edward struggles unsuccessfully with his Halloween fears; the boys run scientifically controlled experiments to prove that they are not really allergic to rats so they can have pets; and they cook up a clever plan to prevent their mother from learning that one of their new sweaters is ruined. What makes these stories so inviting and funny is Cutler's exceptional talent for describing events from the boys' rather literal point of view. The brothers are believable characters whose escapades and lively dialogue ring true. The subject matter and short chapters nicely broken up by Pearson's pen-and-ink illustrations should attract beginning chapter-book readers, but the author's wonderful sense of timing and the cadence and symmetry of her language make this title a natural for reading aloud to an even wider audience.?Maggie McEwen, Coffin Elementary School, Brunswick, ME
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
Gr. 3^-5. In this sequel to
No Dogs Allowed (1992), brothers Jason and Edward Fraser return to demonstrate again the humor found in everyday life: fourth-grader Jason unexpectedly finds himself going steady, first-grader Edward has his troubles at a haunted house, and the brothers must do some fast talking to get themselves the pet rats they feel they deserve. Although this does not have quite the ease of the last book (Edward walking around a department store with a wig on, being mistaken for a girl, seems particularly forced), there are still some very funny moments, and Tracey Campbell Pearson's drawings, as always, add to the fun. A logical alternative for kids who want books in the Cleary, Hurwitz vein.
Ilene Cooper
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.