- File Size: 539 KB
- Print Length: 276 pages
- Publisher: Nimble Books LLC (April 17, 2011)
- Publication Date: April 17, 2011
- Sold by: Amazon Digital Services LLC
- Language: English
- ASIN: B004X1TYH2
- Text-to-Speech: Enabled
- Word Wise: Enabled
- Lending: Enabled
- Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #641,389 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store)
|Digital List Price:||$2.99|
Save $0.48 (16%)
Re-reading A GAME OF THRONES: An Unauthorized Response to George R. R. Martin's Fantasy Classic Kindle Edition
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
More About the Author
Top Customer Reviews
I appreciate that the author loves GRRM's writing, and he is very enthusiastic in his prose. Just remember, it's a BLOG, not really a BOOK, and it was written as the author reread "A Game of Thrones" for the 10th time. There was definitely stuff he got on the 10th reading that you and I missed on the first or even third reading, and I am thankful to the author for sharing those insights with us (I just raised my review from 1 star to 2). As a blog, I can forgive the dashed-off style, and probably would have read it and loved it as he posted it if I'd been aware of it at the time. As a book, though, it fails, though at $2.50 for the Kindle Edition it's probably worth reading to get you ready for the new book. Ok, I've just convinced myself to up my review to 3 stars. I need to stop.
Heck, anyone who loves AGoT this much is ok with me. Maybe I'm just jealous that he has a book out and I don't. I considered giving the book 4 stars just now, simply because the author is obviously a kindred spirit, but I'm not drunk enough yet to go that far so 3 it will remain.
And then it degenerated into a personal hissy fit about moderators and flame wars on internet forums, and after struggling on for several pages without a mention of the book this work is supposed to be reviewing, I gave up. I didn't pay money to listen to ranting I can get for free.
Pity. If there's any good stuff in the rest of this work, I won't find it. A little more discipline on the part of the author and less autobiographical venting, and I'd have kept going.
The Kindle Edition of this text is less than $3.00, so on that level it's money well-spent. Seriously, this is somewhat essential to 'Thrones' fans.
Now, the critical: This is "essential" reading in that in more ways than not it demonstrates what's *wrong* with fanboy criticism (and if that's not what this is supposed to be, then it's failed on yet another level):
- waaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much emphasis on the HBO characterization;
- reminds me waaaaaaaaaaaaaay too many times he's read it 10x (when clearly he has not);
- waaaaaaaaaaaaaay too little useful/critical content (to be fair, I had high expectattions);
- waaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much "I like this chapter a lot" and not enough "... because ..."
- Time and time again, he makes conclusions that simply don't support the text.
For example (spoiler!!), he goes on about how Dany's pregnancy could only occur as a result of three deaths. Fine so far. But we don't really need him going on for about a dozen pages (on a mobile app, that is) about him changing his mind. And, his final conclusion is inaccurate, dismissive, and misleading (i.e., is arguably essential to understanding the second book, A CLASH OF KINGS. I don't expect him to be able to recite lines from the book after ten readings; but I do expect him to talk about the book in a way that sounds like he's read it ten times. And the only times I ever got that feeling is when he's reminding me he's on the tenth reading.
The "book" (let's be honest, the author just copy and pasted his blog entries without editing them or even rereading them) descends into madness in the last half. I'm sure it didn't sound this bad when the author only updated his blog once of twice a week, but when you're reading it as a book, the constant harping about how late A Dance With Dragons is is not only annoying and pulls you out of the book, but makes the author sound like a crazy person.
Also, the author is a huge hypocrite at the end- he criticizes GRRM for being a little pervy on HIS blog, only to turn around and be a perv while discussing the HBO adaptation casting. Michelle Fairley (Catelyn) isn't hot enough, so she'll "really have to convince" you? Not to mention him saying "I wouldn't mind suckling on Emily Clarke myself" when discussing Daenerys' final, fairly iconic scene. Super gross.
But like I said, there's some okay insight, and some okay theories as to what may happen later in the series, totally worth $2.51 or however much I paid for it. The repetitive whininess though? Absolutely ruins it. If you think you can troll through the muck for the good bits, more power to you. Go for it. But don't say I didn't warn you.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
I am a great fan of the HBO GoT series, and re-watch all seasons every year while waiting for the next one to premiere. Read morePublished 10 months ago by Chicago Gal
A bit critical of GRRM's slowness in writing, but, hey, so am I! A good companion read and put some things together for me that I had not thought about.Published 22 months ago by Phyl Worm
If like me you're tired of waiting for the next installment of A Song of Ice and Fire by George RR Martin, then you need something to hold you over. Read morePublished 24 months ago by John Wao
There's a lot of fluffy bits out there with people analyzing A Game of Thrones by George (not the Beatle) Martin. This isn't one of them. Read morePublished 24 months ago by Atreyu
It was kind of interesting to read Mr. Verhoeve's comments about the book, but its not like reading an actual book.Published on November 1, 2013 by Daniel G.
First of all, that is a very _strong_ three stars up there. I was tempted to give it four.
However, the book could have done with some editing. Read more
If you are a fan of the A Song of Fire and Ice series, once you have read all in the series (that are published at least), this is something you NEED to pick up. Read morePublished on December 9, 2012 by missylette5
I had great hopes for this as I thought it would be interesting to follow along with someone re-reading Game Of Thrones. It may have worked better as a blog... Read morePublished on May 28, 2012 by DestinyintheDark
This work shows that you can read one book ten times and still have nothing to say about it. From the first ten chapters I read I found that the author likes "Star Wars", doesn't... Read morePublished on March 11, 2012 by zmeischa
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Look for Similar Items by Category
- Books > Literature & Fiction > History & Criticism > Genres & Styles > Science Fiction & Fantasy
- Books > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Fantasy > Sword & Sorcery
- Books > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Science Fiction > History & Criticism
- Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Literature & Fiction > History & Criticism > Criticism & Theory
- Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Fantasy > Sword & Sorcery