49 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Augustine rediscovered, November 16, 2003
This review is from: A Reader's Companion to Augustine's Confessions (Paperback)
Augustine's 'Confessions' is among the most important books ever written. One of the first autobiographical works in the modern sense, it also represents the first time a psychological and theological enterprise were combined. It also helps to bridge the gap between the Classical world and the Medieval world, exhibiting strong elements identifying with each of those major historical periods.
Most undergraduates in the liberal arts encounter the book at some point; all seminarians do (or should!). Many adults find (or rediscover) the book later, after school. For many in these categories, there are concepts, narrative strands and historical data new and unusual for them. Notes, commentaries and guides are called for - this book by Paffenroth and Kennedy is a good one in many respects.
This book does not represent the thinking and analysis of one (or two) primary authors. Instead, Paffenroth and Kennedy have drawn together an outstanding team of Augustinian scholars to each focus upon one book (or chapter) of the thirteen that comprise the 'Confessions'. They do not look for one overarching theme (or even several) and then try to force the text into that narrow confine; rather, they let each book speak for itself, each one through the interpretative and scholarly lens of a different observer. Each essay can stand on its own - they are not interdependent, but they do all address the same topic, and thus relate in that basic way.
In many respects, this variation-viewing of 'Confessions' suits Augustine's personality well - he was a passionate person, but his focus wavered for much of his life until finally settling upon Christianity and the neoplatonic synthesis with this faith. Even while remaining a passionate Christian and rejecting the sort of dualism present in the Manichee teachings, he varied between various positions within these systems. The authors are conservative and liberal, young and old, Catholic and Protestant. Augustine's varied thought reaches through many denominational and scholarly paradigms.
These are not Cliff's Notes - they do not represent simple synopses of the books in the 'Confessions'. The authors assume the reader of this text will be reading (or will have read) the actual text of the 'Confessions'. These essays are relatively short (the longest is 18 pages) but insightful and engaging. There are extensive endnotes for those whose interest is more scholarly (35 pages of endnotes, to be exact - almost twice the number of pages of the longest chapter), but the texts of the essays can be read without these notes perfectly well for the more casual reader.
The book includes at the end suggestions for further reading, a list which includes some classic standards (Brown, Chadwick) and other pieces that were new to me. There are indexes for scripture and for subjects, and a brief biographical paragraph on each of the contributing authors.
This is a book that will be of interest to novice readers of Augustine as well as scholars, to students, clergy and laypersons, and anyone else who might have an historical, literary, philosophical, theological or other interest in Augustine - something for everyone, perhaps?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Augustine Confessions Ala Carte, March 18, 2009
This review is from: A Reader's Companion to Augustine's Confessions (Paperback)
If you are considering taking a course at University in the study of St. Augustine you will find this particular collection to be beneficial in helping you through the essential first ten chapters that deal with Augustine's life and the last three that are a bit of an analysis of the book of Genesis.
It cannot be used to give you a quick "What is it all about?". It will not reveal the humanity of St. Augustine in the proper venue. If you wish to do that, I recommend the great Italian scholar Augustine Trape', who produced a great work on the Human side of St. Augustine
The book therefore can be used as an overall Chapter help, to give you insight perhaps into important areas that you may have overlooked.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
With companions like this...., December 5, 2011
This review is from: A Reader's Companion to Augustine's Confessions (Paperback)
This book provides an essay for each book of Augustine's Confessions. But the essays make a very troublesome "companion" for a reader. Shouldn't the writing be at least as clear and precise as the book it is supposedly providing a guide to? Here's a sample from the first essay, on Augustine's first chapter, by Charles T. Mathewes:
"Rather than seeking to comprehend our lives better, Augustine hopes his readers will more appropriately fail to comprehend them; and insofar as one fails to fail to comprehend in the right way, one is blocked from understanding the deep character of what the Confessions is all about. . . . What do I mean by this?"
Beats the hell out of me.
Leaving aside the trouble of the dangling participial clause the sentence opens with, I would find this writing laughable, were it not so needlessly dense and inexcusably condescending to the reader. With companions like this, the reader needs no enemies. Augustine and his great book deserve better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
