From School Library Journal
Gr 9 Up-A well-chosen collection of critical readings representing perspectives that range from nearly obsequious praise to detached deconstruction to qualified condemnation. As stated in the front matter, the selections "may have been edited for content, length, and/or reading level." This is not to say they've been dumbed down, however. Students will be healthily challenged by these critics' ideas, and yet not overwhelmed by dry, incomprehensible scholasticism. Following a short but comprehensive biography of Twain, the book is divided into easily digestible units. Each 8-to-10 page essay offers insight individually, but chapter headings intelligently bind the points of view together. The overlying theme is the relationship between literature, history, and culture. Each essay is a fine jumping-off point for thought, discussion, or report writing, and together they cohere into a well-informed understanding of Huckleberry Finn and its author. For the most part, the writings are vivid and provocative-Jane Smiley's stands out for its stunningly sharp jabs at the novel's status. In addition to their interesting arguments, the essays are worthy of study for their artful elements of structure and style. This accessible volume could definitely get kids excited about reading and writing.-Peg Solonika, Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, PA
Copyright 1998 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
