From School Library Journal
Grades 3-6--An insightful look at the immigrant experience in America. Eleven-year-old Nathan McClelland, who lives on a farm in a small Pennsylvania town, becomes increasingly lonely after a coal-mining company buys up neighboring properties and his friends move away. In their place, Italian immigrant miners move in, among them Arturo Tozzi and his family. While they want to forge a new and better life, the remaining townspeople, including Nathan's father, worry about losing everything they have worked for. At first Nathan dislikes the changes, but as the two boys develop a friendship, he becomes more sympathetic to the newcomers and their plight. When Arturo is injured in an accident in the mine that leads to a threatened strike, Nathan and his parents align themselves with the workers and reach out to the Tozzis. While the protagonist is a well-developed character with doubts, worries, and curiosity, the novel's strength is its unbiased view of the complexities surrounding its theme. Fans of the "Dear America" series (Scholastic) will especially appreciate this engaging story that flows swiftly and builds to a satisfying conclusion.
Kristen Oravec, Cuyahoga County Public Library, Strongsville, OHCopyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 4-7. The story takes place more than 100 years ago in Pennsylvania when Italian immigrants arrived to work in the new coal mines that drove the farmers off their land. The racist rhetoric is not too different from what is heard today: the immigrants are "stinking foreigners"; it's better to keep to our own kind. But the hope is also timeless: two kids reach beyond the grownups' barriers to become friends. First-novelist Easton tells the story through the viewpoint of farm boy Nathan McClelland, 11, who defies his bigoted dad by getting to know his new neighbor, Arturo Tozzi, who works with his dad and brother in the mines. The setting is realistic, and the characters are drawn with complexity. There are neither saints nor demons among the natives or the newcomers. Through the personal experiences, the labor history comes alive: the harsh, dangerous working conditions; the uprooting of the farmers; the greed of those cashing in; the aborted attempt to start a union. A fine companion to Susan Bartoletti's
Growing Up in Coal Country (1996).
Hazel RochmanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved