Customer Reviews

Reason of Things

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This collection of essays is extraordinary and very thought provoking. Some of them are more interesting than others but in general, they make the reader think about a vast set of idea without trying to change his or her opinion. It is written with a lot of skill. As far as the criticism in other reviews regarding "attacks on God" and "calling people that believe in God uneducated", reader beware! The author is not directly attacking God nor doubting his existence but rather pinpoints institutionalized religion, which in my opinion IS one of the roots of evil in the world right now. Al-Qaeda? Extreme Islam? Child molesting by Catholic priests? Jews and Palestines killing each other mercilessly? Bush's conservative and discriminatory Christian-right agenda? Need I say more???

I could go on and on about all the thoughts and ideas this book provokes. Without a doubt, the essay on MEAT is the most powerful one. It presents many ugly realities that we choose not to see. Read this book and let yourself be compelled to think alternatively about life's issues.

I moved directly to reading this book having enjoyed reading Graylings previous book, The Meaning of Things, and I wasn't disappointed.

Given the brevity of the articles, sure they can't give you an in-depth discussion on the topic, but its just deep enough to get one thinking about the topics.

I'm sure any reader of this book will take away some favourite sections. For me, the entries on Religion & Evil were particularly thought-provoking (no connection intended).

I think this would be an excellent 'pocket-book' to dip into for anyone in their late teens trying to come to terms with the world.

Only disappointment - no Bibliography, so when Grayling frequently quotes other Authors / Philosophers, I don't know where to go to for further reading; so now I'm trying to find a work by Midas Dekkers (from the entry on Decay).

Grayling doesn't profess to be a Philosopher (contrary to what someone else wrote about him on the flyleaf) - but says that (a) he teaches Philosophy and (b) he studies Philosophy. He writes very well.

I won't deny I'm somewhat biased, but Grayling is an excellent writer and these essays are stunningly stimulating food for thought. Though I might suggest it be read in bed, after reading it you may just wish to get up and walk off the meal.

Grayling's succinct philosophizing is always insightful, informed, and persuasive. It needs to be noted, however, that this title contains exactly the same text as Grayling's "Life, Sex and Ideas" (Oxford UP, 2003).

I teach the A-level General Paper and encounter much difficulty at attempting to engage students to discuss issues which are theme-based. This book is an excellent resource for me to get students to express their viewpoints as they read and respond to the chapters in this delightful collection of Grayling's work. Most of the chapters are quite accessible to 17/18-year old students, even though English Language is not their native language. This is by far the most accessible title amongst those in the series by Grayling. Highly recommended for the casual reader as well.

This book is really a collection of superficial open-ended essays on various topics, and the author does not develop or defend any central thesis or explanation of his personal life philosophy. He also doesn't include any relevant facts or statistics, which might make such an open-ended book an enjoyable starting-point for conversation. On the contrary, he often makes arrogant unsubstantiated comments assuming the reader shares his liberal humanist world-view. I often agree with the ideas, but the snide unsupported barbs are only enjoyable when read with an equally-petty and supercilious attitude.

I liked The Meaning of Things so much that I had to have and read
other books by this author so I bought The Reason of things with
three hard-working hours only to find out that the author has gone astray in this one!
I got mad instead of relaxing because on page 35 the author insults the readers bluntly by calling people who'll believe in
God uneducated.
Anyways as you can imagine I had no energy to carry on reading
and since I was at page 35 and the book wasn't so damaged I went
to the bookshop and exchanged it for some smart author who must
appreciate my hard-working earned money (not to mention my energy and time to go through what they bla-bla'd about).

"I know what I have given you but I do not know what have you recieved" - goes one of my favorite sayings by Porchia.
In this case I must change it and say that "I don't know what you have given me but I do know what I have received".