Customer Reviews

Recapturing the Banjo

5 star:		(12)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

The rest of this review really speaks to the musicians other than the Great Don Vappie. Vappie's music reflects the tradition of four and six-string banjo and guitar playing that remained among Creoles in New Orleans as well as on the musics shared between African American Creoles in New Orleans with Afro-Caribbean Creoles on islands like Haiti, Martinique, and Guadaloupe. Vappie who was once one of the leading Jazz and R & B recording session guitarists and Bassists returned to the four and six string banjos played by the great banjoist of Jazz. In doing so Vappie is playing very authentic roots music in fact rooted in the very neighborhood in New Orleans he grew up in, yet he has become a world-class music.

Recapturing the Banjo is not chiefly about repeating or even elaborating on the traditional banjo styles created by Black traditional five-string banjoists or the great Jazz banjoists of the 20s and 1930s. Rather, it is about using the banjo for new styles and new music of African Americans today. Very few of the recordings here follow the traditional finger or frailing styles used by the last generations of Black banjoists who can be found on field recordings like Black Banjo Songsters or Black Appalachia. This terrain has been explored by traditionally oriented Black string bands like the Carolina Chocolate Drops or the Ebony Hillbillies or individual players like Sparkey Rucker,
Sule Greg Wilson, Rex Ellis, or my humble self.

Rather, the artists here use the banjo for the mostly blues related music that they have all been creating for years. All of these musicians are not new to the banjo. Otis has told me that the banjo was his first instrument and he plays his other instruments, the guitar and the mandolin, the way he plays the banjo, not the standard ways. There is a famous picture printed in the Denver Post in the early 1960s on his web site. A younger slimmer Otis Taylor is seen riding a unicycle and playing the banjo on his way to high school! You can find some great traditional banjo playing on older CDs by Corey Harris and Alvin Youngblood Hart.

What we have hear is blues and trance music and ballads influenced by this. What we have here is the creative use of amplification both in recording the banjo and in use of electric banjo and banjos with electric pickups. We have new rhythms for new times.

The importance of this is that in African American popular and folk culture, the arrival of Blues and the forms of pop and folk Ragtime and Jazz that were associated with the Blues was what led to the demise of the five-string banjo among Black folk. For reasons I will elaborate in a book forthcoming from Duke UP called _Lost in the Mix__ (I am just writing one chapter) the actual five string banjos available at the time the Blues rolled in at the turn of the century were not as suitable for Blues playing as the inexpesnive steel-stringed guitar that had become available to southern folk just as the blues spread at the turn of the 19th to the 20th Century.

The contemporary experience of Blues as a kind of caberet or concert music obscures the fact that Blues was a dance music. Blues singers like Robert Johnson, Charlie Patton, or Lightnin' Hopkins, may have played in the street at times, but they made their money playing for dancers in juke joints and at house parties. Rather than the two or three minute Blues performances we get from recordings and reproductions of recordings, these actual Blues performances were often fifteen, twenty, or even thirty minute dance numbers.

The five-string banjo was not condusive to playing the rhythm that Black folks danced these blues to. So, it retreated to smaller enclaves where the older music persisted, especially in the Piedmont and Appalachians of the Upper South. Even there, Black five string banjoists played the Blues, but blues that moved to the rhythm of the old dance movements. Very much of the revival of traditional Black banjo playing has been playing these old dance tunes and rhythms.

Yet, we live in a world whose musical culture has been transformed by the Blues and the musics it has spawned. In its Africanness, the five-string banjo provides a great platform for playing blues. The dance demands of a 1900 juke joint and the limitation of gut stringed banjos are gone. Steel stringed tone ringed banjos and modern amplication create different possibilities for the banjo. Blues rhythm has become more complex. These musicians expert in the Blues and in the Black banjo tradition, reverse history and bring back the Blues to the Banjo and the Banjo to the Blues.

The result is powerful music that returns the banjo to the arsnel of comtemporary African American music. It lives, not as a recreation of a lost past, but as a living expression of the present

As I listened to this, I thought of one of Steve Martin's old routines, back when he was a silly, unknown, stand-up comedian ca. 1976. He used to pull out a banjo and get "happy feet." No matter how glum the subject at hand, the banjo would give him ... "happy feet."

Yes, when you think of "Duelling Banjos" from "Deliverance," or the Flatt & Scruggs or Doc Watson flat-picking style, such as the theme from "The Beverly Hillbillies," or a zillion versions of "Orange Blossom Special," you get Martin's point.

But this c.d. isn't about that. This is Otis Taylor (tripling as producer and arranger), with other banjoists Alvin Youngblood Hart, Guy Davis, Corey Harris and Don Vappie, creating (for the most part) the "Negro experience" of the 19th Century. I say "for the most part"; the ubiquitous Keb' Mo' appears, with his set-ender "The Way It Goes." Just a guess here, but I doubt that the "Negro experience of the 19th Century" had anything to do with road rage!

As such, this c.d. is dark. No flashiness here. And songs - a mix of originals, "traditional folk songs," and folks songs such as "Walk Right In" (originally made famous in the early 1960's by The Rooftop Singers, but in fact, written by an African American banjo player, Gus Cannon, in the early 20th century about a kind housewife who invites a peddler in to her house) - which are quite dark. We have songs about a man running from the Ku Klux Klan, about a "scary drunk" on absinthe, about a Black cowboy who shoots in self-defense and knows he will get no justice, about a drowning man, and about a White sheriff who refuses to investigate the disappearance of a Black woman. No "happy feet" in this recording!

But it all sounds authentic. This recording reminds me of the best of John Fahey. Nothing flashy - just real. A stark recapture of times past, and uncomfortable times at that. But times past that always need to be remembered. And if we didn't know that the banjo was part of those times before, we certainly know it now. This c.d. got a 5-star review in "Down Beat," which gives maybe 3 5-star reviews a year. I think the historic and sociological significance of the album is the reason for that. RC

This is a really nice adaptation of the banjo to the misic. I especially liked the version of the traditional "Deep Blue Sea,"the timely "That's the Way it Goes," and the bluesy-folky-funky style of some of the songs. Not your traditional banjo recording, but that's said in a good way. The banjo is a very versatile instrument that can blend with all kinds of music and be used with finess, and this album lets that be known.

La verdad es que compré este album por una sóla canción que escuché en la película " Enemigos Públicos ", concretamente " Ten Million Slaves " y tengo que decir, que aparte de este temazo, el Sr. Taylor me ha sorprendido muy gratamente, ya que no lo conocía. El resto del album no tiene desperdicio ninguno, y el homenaje que hacen al " banjo " es espectacular, recomendable 100%. Además los coros que hace su hija en los temas son maravillosos.

At first I resisted even listening to this CD, figuring anything with banjo in the title was going to be some sort of hillbilly, boring music. But after seeing the great line up of musicians, I figured it was worth at least checking out. What a surprise! A lot of good songs here, most done with a band with the banjo out front. An unbelievable version of "Hey Joe" as well. Well worth checking into. It's something different in a generic world.

Man.
Between Mavis Staples's new Ry Cooder produced album and this new piece of awe-inspiring artistry from Otis Taylor and friends, I'm just not sure which album lands in my top spot for the past year. But it has been an amazing year for Roots Music.
Buy this. You won't regret it. Even if you aren't a Banjo Fan (and didn't grow up in a little town that had yearly Banjo and Fiddler's contests, like I did,)...you'll love this album. Even if you aren't aware of THE OTIS TAYLOR and the fact that he left music for 20 years only to come back and make my idiot self cry with joy and sadness over his content on the first album back. Buy this disc.

Even if you aren't sure you could enjoy a Blues album? Buy it.

***Mavis? If you or Mssr. Cooder are reading this, I'll buy This Amazing Disc for each of you. You guys decide. Otis? If you or Cassie are reading this, I'll buy The Mavis Album for you both. Then you guys decide. Until then, It's a tie. Buy both.***
We'll Never Turn Back

otis taylor continues to reinvent the blues in his own personal way. with this album, he does it again, featuring the banjo. it's haunting and beautiful. otis is one of a few artists whose cd's i will buy before i even hear them.

Otis Taylor's songwriting typically takes me to places I normally wouldn't venture. This cd is no exception. An excellent inside cover with history of the banjo and description of the musicians and their playing styles (in regards to the banjo). Thanks otis, Definition of a Circle and this follow-up are two of my favorite back to backs of any musician. p.s Cassie (his daughter) kicks it on bass.

Here Otis Taylor assembled the finest line-up of contemporary African-American bluesmen who have featured the banjo in their roots-blues, at a time when that African-American instrument had all been abdicated to white Appalachian mountain music,bluegrass and such.
While each of the musicians is individually superb, this album is not convincing me that they have actually succeeded yet in reclaiming the banjo for Afro-Americans. I love Otis' daughter Cassie's harmonies. She adds much to the record and I am a huge Otis Taylor fan from the get-go. This is a fine record, quite good and interesting, with Otis Taylor's usual musical prowess and fabulous deep-roots songwriting. However, from the mere perspective of the banjo, something is missing here. I love every one of these musicians and expected some true virtuosity or individuality, or a true return to the old songster/blues banjo tradition, the way Mike Seeger has presented. But, all it is is a bunch of cool brothers playing the blues- and roots banjo really well, but not good enough to brag about it. Keb Mo comes off strong and it's all good, but honestly, it's not a milestone in the history of banjo music.

This is real roots music - the lyrics are thoughtful and powerful stories and the music is beyond fantastic. Be sure to read the liner notes to gain a better understanding of where this sound orignated and why it strikes right to the core of your musical soul. Check it out, you'll be glad you did.