41 of 44 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
some good, some not so good... mostly worth it, December 7, 2000
This review is from: Record of Lodoss War - Chronicles of the Heroic Knight (Complete Series) (DVD)
I have to say that "Chronicles of the Heroic Knight" doesn't seem as good as the original Lodoss War series, but is still mostly worth it. There is a lot to this one, about 9 hours or so over 4 DVDs, and the quality is a bit up and down.
The series (broken up in 20 minute episodes) starts out with the familiar heroes (Parn and Deedlit, mainly) of the original series and passes the torch on to a new group of heroes. The storyline puts a little revisionist history on the original plot and sometimes seems as much a re-make as a sequel when it recycles some of the plots familiar from the first series. This is most prevalent in the first and last DVDs. The middle two are the high-point of the set and are what saves this series.
The first DVD focuses on the original heroes of the Lodoss War and is the most derivative. It's good to see the characters back again, like old friends, but after a few minutes you start to be bothered by things. The quality of the animation seems a bit below par and it feels as if it's being written towards a younger (pre-teen?) target audience. Dumbed down & too cutesy, in other words. This is also where they ignore some of the history of the first series and re-use an entire plot line.
The 2nd and 3rd DVDs, however, are much better. The quality of the animation comes back up to par, they pick up a new story thread with new heroes, and the writing/production seems to have been re-targeted to a more mature audience. This is the best part of the set and what makes it worth while, in my opinion.
The last DVD in the set loses some ground again, compared to the middle of the series. I almost wonder if they were running low on money or getting tired of making it or something. It brings the story to a satisfactory conclusion, but it does feel as if the quality of the animation slips some in the last few episodes, and as if the writers weren't making any great effort to do anything except get it over with.
DVD features include a bunch of previews and the expected language options, nothing much else. I quickly took to skipping over the last two minutes of every episode where they do their "comedy theatre" bit at the end. I really wish that had been done as a separate chapter so I didn't have to watch it (I, for one, hate that little featurette), but could still listen to the closing theme music. Instead, it's all one chapter. The music is excellent and worth suffering through some fast forwarding.
If you are a fan of the original Lodoss War, you will probably be disappointed at first, feel better about it in the middle, and then be left a little disappointed at the end. Still, overall, I think it is enjoyable and worth it. Could have been better, but it's still nice to come home to Lodoss again with this set.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
39 of 46 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
WOW...hard to beleave but Better then the First set., July 14, 2000
This review is from: Record of Lodoss War - Chronicles of the Heroic Knight (Complete Series) (DVD)
Five years past, a band of six adventurers defeated the conquering armies of Marmo, the dark island, and saved the accused island, LODOSS. Since that day, the survivors have been honored as heroes, and their deeds have become legends. But the darkness never perished... Now, a mad wizard threatens to raise an ancient evil - the goddess of destruction. Old heroes must heed the call to defend their homeland and new heroes are forged as the battle for LODOSS begins anew.
I saw this on the VHS tapes and all I can say is WOW. the First story drew me in and I loved it. this one is SO much more...almost Twice a long with even More adventures and better animation. if u enjoyed the First one this one will Blow you away.
Greg
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Read the incuded booklet thingie, May 9, 2001
This review is from: Record of Lodoss War - Chronicles of the Heroic Knight (Complete Series) (DVD)
People complain about the repeats in the story line and such, it seems as if they didn't take the time to read the booklet that was in the first disc. It explains that much of this series *is* just a rehash of the OVA because the OVA was an incomplete adaptation of the novels, the animators decided to do a more complete and accurate retelling of the novels. The things in this series that negate the previous series are suposed to be taken as true, what you saw before didn't happen. Just pretend it was something you heard 2nd hand from an unreliable source.
I find it different enough to remain intersting, the animation is great, as is the music (the opening sequence is fantastic on both aspects).
At the end of every episode you get a super-deformed short called "Welcome to Lodoss Island". I find it hilarious in an "Oh my god that is so stupid" kind of way. Those episodes alone are almost worth buying the video for.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No