Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb ! A well rounded, mature, intelligent bullseye survey of the historical Jesus of the new testament gospel accounts., August 4, 2007
This review is from: Recovering Jesus: The Witness of the New Testament (Paperback)
this is an outstanding guide to studying Jesus. basically this book in about 330 pages, covers most aspects of Jesus study. from the issues of the gospel writings themselves, to historical methods, and to the exposition of the historical Jesus as sketched in the gospel writings, this book does a tremendous job in the wide amount of coverage it handles. the author, Thomas Yoder Neufeld, a Harvard TH.D., shows in his writings an obvious profound, deep and dedicated perspective to the person of Jesus. yet, the author is no fundamentalist. Neufeld handles the issues with sobriety and sanity, employing a conservative scholars touch in a sober, cautious fashion, yet with a realist's inquiry, yet all the while with a dedicated love and trust for the significance of the Jesus of the gospels. Neufeld lays out the issues in Jesus/gospel study, then he exposits the whole gamut of Jesus from the new test. gospel writings. He does this according to the "epochs" of Jesus life as provided by the framework inherent in the gospel writings themselves. Neufeld excels in explaining deeply, yet within grasp, the meaning of Jesus' deeds, person, teachings and significance, from the literary context of the new test. as well as the historical, cultural, theological and redemptive context. The author has done his homework, and from Neufeld's study, one will truly learn an accurate presentation of the historical Jesus according to the new testament gospel memoirs. It easily ranks right up there in quality with Blomberg, Bock, Dunn and Wright. I have read plenty on the subject of Jesus and this is possibly my new favorite. This is a must have for studying Jesus. For a top notch, well written, accurate study of Jesus and the gospels, this is a must have.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exceptional Introduction to Understanding Jesus -- Then and Now, August 4, 2008
This review is from: Recovering Jesus: The Witness of the New Testament (Paperback)
"Recovering Jesus," by Thomas Yoder Newfeld, is a remarkable presentation not only of the New Testament as it developed in early Christian circles, but also of Christian faith as it may (even ought) be lived today.
As example, consider his treatment on the "parable of the talents" in Mathew 25. "If this parable is understood within the larger context of Jesus' teaching on wealth," Yoder Neufeld maintains, "then it becomes, ironically, the exact opposite of a lesson in capitalism. It becomes a terribly hard lesson about whether wealth has been invested to the benefit of the reign of God...The arrival of the kingdom represents not only the embrace of the wayward son and the lost sheep, but also the accounting before a demanding judge as to what was done with the treasure, whatever it may be.""
Written at an undergraduate college (or introductory seminary)-level, the individual reader will also find background sufficent to personal study.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Basic, well written, and unmemorable, August 2, 2008
This review is from: Recovering Jesus: The Witness of the New Testament (Paperback)
I anticipated much more. A recent M.Div graduate, I found this book lacking in many areas, specifically in the area of originality. Perhaps Christology, the study about Jesus, has a need for this book since it has gone through a time of confusion and/or lack of traditional teachings on Jesus. As such, originality is saying what has always been the Christian faith's understanding which makes this book original by repeating what has always been the core of the Faith. I guess I just contradicted myself...
However, I found many chapters so basic that I ended up skimming over several paragraphs because they contained little more than the introductions found in many study Bibles. The only chapter that really got my attention was chapter 10 (Living the Kingdom), with the following chapters barely more interesting than the previous ones.
The book is indeed balanced, offering quotes and information from liberal and ultra-liberal scholars (such as the Jesus Seminar), while it concludes with the author giving good reasons why a more conservative/traditional approach better explains the data in the Bible.
My major gripe with this book is its use of "Wisdom" instead of "Logos", catering to a crowd of feminist leanings (p. 317). There is exceedingly little material on the second person of the Trinity as "Wisdom" in the New Testament, or Old for that matter, and yet Neufeuld uses this "Wisdom" terminology over and over again making thinly veiled suggestions on the vast landscape of uncharted but promising territory of Wisdom theology as supposed to the masculine "Logos" theology so dominant for two millenia. Why does he do this? What can be gained by it? Where is the Biblical support for using "Wisdom" as the divine person we know as God incarnate in Jesus Christ instead of Logos (John 1:1)?
Neufeld uses the apochryphal books of Sirach and the Wisdom of Solomon to make his case that "Wisdom" is the grandest of all titles for Jesus Christ as the divine person. He argues that we can use "Wisdom" or "Sophia" just as well as "Logos", but he misses the point that John surely knew of these wellknown documents and chose not to write "Wisdom" but "Logos"!
This rather unnecessary foray into feminist-theology territory is unfortunate and leaves me with a bad taste as I ponder whether to keep this book on my shelf for future reading considering that great chapter on "Living the Kingdom," or if I should tear out those pages and put the book elsewhere. This book is good for a basic introduction to Jesus but there are much better books out there. A good start is the book by Pope Benedict, "Jesus of Nazareth". While I don't share his view on some things it is a really good and engaging book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|