Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Father, A Son, And Mother Memory, October 22, 2005
About a fourth of the way into this graceful memoir, and just before he starts to unfold the tale-within-a-tale concerning the eponymous 'red letters', author-narrator Ved Mehta admits to a moment of agonizing self-doubt:
"In writing a series of books about myself and my family, among other things, with the title Continents of Exile, I have often been torn between loyalty to my family and loyalty to my craft, to which any kind of censorship is anathema. My father, who served as a source for some of the material, knew all too well how such conflicts tormented me."
Mehta is especially troubled by the material at hand in the current book. While all the eleven volumes of his long autobiographical series have been immensely revealing about his family and himself, the revelations in question have been more of an intellectual and cultural nature, concerning themselves more with the impact of a lifetime spent abroad (in exile, as he calls it) upon a writer's mind and relationships.
The series to date, as anyone who has been following it even occasionally since the first volumes, Daddyji and Mummyji, were published decades ago, are gentle, self-probing intellectual studies that are as much observational records of their place and time as literary autobiography.
But in The Red Letters, he is about to introduce an unxpected 'twist' in the tale. Mehta's father, a genial public health official with unfulfilled literary ambitions ("I may still surprise you, son, by writing a bestseller one of these days"), comes to New York with his wife for their daughter's confinement, and behaves peculiarly at a party hosted by the author.
After his return to India, the father makes good his literary threat, and begins to send Mehta chapters of a "novel" he claims to be writing. He later reveals that the "novel" is nothing more than a thinly-disguised memoir of a certain period in his life, dating back forty years.
As Mehta reads on, and then agrees to collaborate with his father in this joint act of turning remembered history into literary fiction, he learns with growing unease that his father is really confessing to a secret extramarital love affair from that period. To make matters worse, rather than wallowing in guilt or self-remose, his father seems quite unabashed about revealing the more intimate details of the matter. "Sex, as you would call it today."
In the end, Mehta agrees to proceed with the work because as he puts it in one of the quietly eloquent passages which mark his work, "he, like me, sensed, even as he was confiding in me, that the story had a larger significance, something neither of us could yet verbalize, but which we imagine would far transcend his life--and maybe mine too."
What follows is a fascinating narrative, like one of the Russian dolls-within-dolls-within-dolls that so fascinated Mehta during his childhood. Unpeeling the onion of the past in carefully revealing layers, he proceeds to give us his father's transparently autobiographical 'novel' fragments, alternating with the real events described in those fragments, then his own reactions to these revelations.
This being Ved Mehta, the gentle "uncleji" of contemporary Indian novelists, there is nothing sordid or truly shocking about the revelations. With painful grace and elegance, he winds his way through past and present, mind and body, real and perceived, to weave an enticing tale. In the end, the real relationship being explored and studied is not really that of his father and the 'other woman'; it is Ved and his father themselves. Completing--and often revising--the first novel of the Continents of Exile series, Daddyji, Mehta produces a deceptively simple, impressively artful book, one that manages to fulfil its aspiration to transcend mere autobiography and achieve the status of literature.
Interestingly, the red letters of the title don't exist. They are a fictional device suggested by his father to Ved as a means of conveying the details and passion of his remembered liaision. After all, as Daddyji points out, Mehta has frequently altered important details such as names, places, and some events, to make the material of life more suitable for purposes of literary recreation.
And in any case, this particular story, by Mehta's choice, will only be published after all parties concerned have passed away and are far removed from any potential hurt which such revelations or alterations may cause. It's a significant reminder to all vicarious readers and over-zealous critics that the final work exists as a literary entity unto itself, not merely as a bare documentary record of real people and events. The best autobiography, as this book is, transcends itself to become a tale of the human condition.
Mehta may not have achieved the heights of his self-declared literary aspirations, Proust and Joyce, but he has produced a valuable insight into the Indian diaspora that deserves a place on our shelves, alongside the best work of Naipaul and Rushdie. In a chapter at the end of The Red Letters, Mehta provides a brief synopsis of the themes covered by the previous ten volumes, and readers who may have missed entries in this long roman fleuve, running into some two thousand pages, flowing through the disparate lands of India, England and America, covering events from the late 19th century to the early 21st (though not in strictly chronological order), would do well to start at the beginning and work their way through to this very satisfying and illuminatory work.
Rarely does an author get to write 'The End' not only to a long series of novels but in effect, to his own life story. With The Red Letters, Mehta performs that miraculous literary act.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Yet another wonderful book by Ved Mehta, October 29, 2005
Warning: If The Red Letters is your first Ved Mehta book, it is only the beginning. Reading a book by Mehta is like trying to eat just one bite of Swiss chocolate. It's not enough. You'll have to read another, and then another, till they're all read. And by the way, don't be surprised if you find yourself booking a trip to India before you're finished, for your curiosity about that intriguing country will be severely provoked.
Don't worry if you read the other books in Mehta's autobiographical series in mixed order. Many characters appear and reappear like old friends woven into the simple and complex stories of Mehta's life. It is a life both ordinary and extraordinary, described with uncommon vulnerability, and I can't think of a writer who uses language better, with a simple style and great narrative skill.
Ved Mehta claims that The Red Letters is the last of the eleven autobiographical books in his Continent of Exile series. I hope not. Changing one's mind is perfectly acceptable.
|
|
|
|