16 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Red Tree - The Black Day, January 24, 2002
Having gazed in awe for hours over Shaun Tan's previous books (which could be simply 'read' in minutes), I have been drawn to giggles, tears and several art-history references.
Shaun's tackled a difficult subject here in childhood depression. He's managed to handle it in such a way that kids who have just had a bad 'moment', and kids that are really having a terrible extended period of time, will not feel alone in their sadness and problems, and will ultimately, hopefully, feel uplifted.
Shauns words and images do not talk down to kids in any way. The images are mostly complex, dark, brooding - and filled with enough detail to entrance on many repeat readings.
His settings are otherworldly enough to keep up the sense of mystery and distance, but familiar enough to have the reader feel connected with the central figure - a little girl who is sad, feeling left-out and confused.
For young children, It's probably a book best kept for one of those 'moments', and read with an understanding parent or older friend.
For older kids and adults, it's a great book for a cheer-up on a bad day.
...and for anyone with an appreciation of art, get this and the rest of Shaun's back-catalogue - in hardback if you can, and treasure them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Shaun Tan's compelling masterpiece about the power of hope,, May 26, 2005
This review is from: The Red Tree (Hardcover)
Title: The Red Tree
Author: Shaun Tan
Type: fiction/non-fiction
Publisher: Lothian, November 2002
The Red Tree is a masterpiece that uses vibrant colored pictures of intense meaning to take readers on an emotional journey with the red haired girl who appears throughout the book. As the main character she is depicted wandering through numerous imaginary and dreamlike, landscape portraying hopelessness and isolation.
A small child awakes to discover blackness leaves falling from her bedroom ceiling, threatening to silently engulf her. As she wanders around a world that is intricate and puzzling she is overtaken by numerous feelings. The girl is overwhelmed by feelings of despair and sadness. The minimal text on each page conveys feelings and thoughts that accompany childhood depression. The simple and poetic text also communicates complicated themes such as the search for identity, escape from a confined space and lack of control of one's feelings.
When the girl returns to her bedroom at the end of the day, the red leaf is on the floor quietly waiting for her. When readers turn the page, the red leaf has blossomed into a red tree that is full of light and hope. The girl smiles and readers are reminded of the power of hope. Everything seemed hopeless until the child returns to her room to see the red tree. At that moment the child smiles and the beauty and purity of infancy is radiated.
The red leaf in each of Shaun Tan's visual works of art is symbolic as it represents hope, even in the darkest moments of despair and loneliness. The elaborate detail in Tan's illustrations is fascinating and demands close analysis and multiple viewings as much of the artwork in the book summarizes delicate imagery. Tan also uses colour to convey meaning in the final pages, as the red is the predominating colour symbolizing prosperity and happiness.
The book puts forward the idea that childhood depression is an illness that is never without hope. It shows that hope is always there, just like the tiny red leaf that is present throughout the book, even though the girl is oblivious to the glimmer of promise in the shape of a tiny red leaf in the end she finds it. Although the book is quite detailed it leaves out both the causes of the characters state and the influences that are encouraging this constant behaviour of isolation and sadness.
The author of the book The Red Tree puts forward his opinions on childhood depression and the feelings that are accompanied with it as well as the fact that hope is always there. I totally agree with Tan's opinions because I think that they are truly precise and realistic. I believe that hope is always present; we just need to recognize it for it to blossom.
The Red Tree is a fascinating and sophisticated picture book about a sensitive issue that is often ignored in children's literature. The picture book is one that is very interesting and memorable as it stays with people ceaselessly. The Red Tree is a book that I highly recommend for adults. Feelings too complex for words are rendered into an imaginary landscape where the child wanders. It is a compelling story about the power of hope, renewal and inspiration.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A thought-provoking, entertaining picture book, February 16, 2003
This review is from: The Red Tree (Hardcover)
Written and illustrated by award-winning artist and author Shaun Tan, The Red Tree is the story of a young girl who feels that sometimes days begin with nothing good to look forward to, and downwardly progresses from worse to even worse. She wanders an imaginary and surreal dreamscape of cold and misery, yet there is a curious red leaf which leads her to remember a bright possibility of purity and good things, both here and to come. Richly and imaginatively illustrated, The Red Tree is a thought-provoking, entertaining picture book for children that carries an ultimate message of hope.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No