Refractions of Violence [Paperback]

Martin Jay (Author)

Book Description

ISBN-10: 0415966663 | ISBN-13: 978-0415966665 | Publication Date: September 21, 2003 | Edition: 1

A new collection of essays by the internationally recognized cultural critic and intellectual historian Martin Jay that revolves around the themes of violence and visuality, with essays on the Holocaust and virtual reality, religious violence, the art world, and the Unicorn Killer, among a wide range of other topics.

Editorial Reviews

Review

Refractions of Violence is a work of incidental greatness. Setting out to write a series of occasional pieces largely centering on issues of visuality and visual culture, Jay has produced almost as a side-effect a sustained and penetrating inquiry into the 'finite economy' of violence in the contemporary world. As a further, unexpected bonus, he has given us an intimate, witty, nuanced, and altogether memorable account of the conditions of intellectual life in a culture of extremity. All the many virtues of Jay's remarkable oeuvre are in evidence here, but in a form at once accessible and deeply serious, informal and fully engaged.
–Geoffrey Galt Harpham, National Humanities Center

Well known for his histories of comprehensive scope and conceptual drive, such as Marxism and Totality and Downcast Eyes: The Denigration of Vision in Twentieth-Century French Thought, Martin Jay is also one of most astute analysts of contemporary culture. Refractions of Violence shows him at his best, developing lucid insights into the new force of violence today, exploring its strange symbiosis with visual culture, tracking its unpredictable effects in political debate, delivering his critical assessments with characteristic curiosity, sensitivity, and generosity.
–Hal Foster, Townsend Martin Professor of Art and Archaeology, Princeton University

The 20th century has been called the age of extremes. The 21st may well become known as the age of violence. In this broad-ranging series of essays -- for the most part scholarly but at times striking a personal note -- Martin Jay skillfully traces the multiple intersecting rays cast by violence and its representations in both elite and popular culture. This excellent book should be of great interest not only to historians but to anyone wanting greater insight into a troubled present as it is shaped by a turbulent past.
–Dominick LaCapra, Bryce and Edith M. Bowmar Professor of Humanistic Studies, Cornell University

About the Author

Martin Jay is Professor of History at University of California, Berkeley. He is the author of several books including Fin-de-Siéle Socialism and Other Essays (1988), Force Fields (1993) and co-editor of Vision in Context (1996), all published by Routledge.

Product Details

• Paperback: 256 pages
• Publisher: Routledge; 1 edition (September 21, 2003)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0415966663
• ISBN-13: 978-0415966665
• Product Dimensions: 9.2 x 6 x 0.7 inches
• Shipping Weight: 14.1 ounces
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #2,199,310 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

More About the Author

Discover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Post-traumatic Stress Disorders in the Postmodern Age, March 7, 2007

By 

Richard Gringeri (Miami Beach, FL United States) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: Refractions of Violence (Paperback)

Berkeley historian and critic, Martin Jay, offers sixteen reflections on violence and reactions to it. He aims the book against "Sorelian threnodies to [the] redemptive power [of violence]" (10), referring to French social theorist Georges Sorel's "Reflections on Violence" (1908) that argued for the myth of a general strike to frighten capitalists into concessions for workers. He is rightly worried that today "violence... looms ever larger as a feature of human interaction" (10). In the chapters that follow, he cites some modalities of violence prefiguring our own violent turn but focuses mainly on examples from the news or his own experience. The subjects are varied and interesting, and they are treated with some originality. We learn about Walter Benjamin's complicated refusal to mourn the carnage of World War I; the inefficacy of Berlin's new Peace University to reduce violence today; a wealthy German leftist atoning for his father's Nazi fortune through his own harrowing kidnap experience; the inability of historians to date the end of the Holocaust as a testament to that horror's continuing trauma in our lives; a Jewish colleague's deathbed conversion to Anglicanism as a blow struck for reconciliation and peace; and Jay's rejection of violence inspired by religious or quasi-religious belief, as in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and 9/11. Some entries don't quite fit the rubric. For example, his fascinating analysis of "blind justice," which finds that there is always a kind of violence done in the name of justice, whether algorithmic or decisionist, nonetheless is not devoted to specific acts of violence. Or his essay on "astronomical hindsight," which reminds us that the light we receive from other worlds is always a trace of a reality that once was, even if it no longer exists. This fact of physics helps us to evade the claims of synchronic self-sufficiency made for virtual reality today. Apparently, according to Jay, even the late Jean Baudrillard had to admit that there is more to our current reality than mere simulacra produced by a seductive media. Once recast as at least a partially grounded reality, the present day invites us to mourn or even, in spite of its ramifying violence, "to wonder at the survival of the seemingly dead past" (131). Other essays contain similarly surprising positive judgments about violence, such as the claim that transgressive body art "may be a version of somaesthetics that has something to teach democracy after all" (176) or that "rights talk [i.e., human rights] has often functioned as a legitimation for violent resistance to oppressive authority" (161). Jay is rightly cautious about these judgments because he knows these practices--in artistic and political action, respectively--have led to violent outcomes he cannot condone.

This book is well worth reading, for it shows how difficult it is to treat violence objectively, as just another inevitable dimension of the human condition. Inexorably, under Jay's steady hand, we are drawn into a series of perplexing questions about the nature and function of the violence surrounding us. To be sure, Jay himself condemns virtually all forms of violence he treats. He concludes that in today's world, "only a dialectics that...honors the irreducible value of individual lives can hope to have any emancipatory effect" (187). How to enact this dialectics of honor in a world of mounting global terrorism against "guiltless victims" (187) and a continuing academic onslaught against the "traditional conception of the [human] subject" (187) are questions Jay, quite properly, raises but does not answer. He is scrupulously honest that he can't answer them because we live "in an age of increasing opacity and incoherence" (10). Perhaps this book, and others like it, will help us recover our bearings.