30 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointed, February 2, 2009
This review is from: Refuse to Regain!: 12 Tough Rules to Maintain the Body You've Earned! (Hardcover)
After being overweight or obese for all my life (I'm now 51) about four years ago, I lost 80 pounds - and I've kept it off ever since. So, I was eager to like this book - I wanted to see if what the author suggested was consistent with my experience, and if she had any "new" info that wold be helpful. I'm sorry to say that I was quite disappointed. In brief, here's why:
Fisrt, her approach is a "one size fits all" stratgey that will not work for everyone. Although she says it doesn't matter "how you lost your weight," she does propose only one approach - hers - for maintaining. Quite frankly, I have done almost exactly the opposite of what she recommends: I eat mostly whole grains, vegetables and fruit, and some dairy, with minimal animal-based protetin...and this, after losing wiehgt on a protein-based weight-loss plan (kind of a modified South Beach). So, the "one size fits all" isn't necessarily a good approach - people might think, "Well, if I can't bear to do it her way, in such an extereme manner, why try at all?"
Second, she takes an inconsistant approach, even within her own rather rigid plan. I was shocked to see that she breaks her own health-focused "Primarian" rules in odd ways...like allowing artificial sweeteners, which certainly aren't even vaguely "Primarian," and chemical-laden frozen "diet" entrees, like Lean Cuisine. I'm having a hard time picturing Og the hunter-gatherer chowing down on a Healthy Choice dinner and washing it down with a Diet Coke.
Most importantly, she rails against "moderation" as if it is more like wild abamdon. I am proof that moderation CAN work: I am careful to watch my eating and eat a very healthy, real-food based diet (no sugar, artificial sweeteners, or packaged, chemical-laden food) all week, and take a day off each week (over the Jewish Sabbath). On that day, I don't go wild, but I allow my self foods I don't eat during the week: some sugar, baked goods (no bread during the week, either), and other "treat" type foods. It's worked for me for four years, and can work for others, too. I think Dr. B's rigidity will discourage people before they even start...life need not be so bleak when maintaining a significant loss. And yes, I do exercise - but not an hour a day. I've stayed slim and fit with 25-30 minutes a day, about five days a week.
(As an aside, I'm a member of the National Weight Registry she refers to, and her characterization of what we long-time maintainers say and do is not entirely accurate...people should check out that source independently.)
Take heart, Big Losers - the maintenance picture's not as grim as Dr. B. paints it to be! Good luck to us all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This is a winner!, October 27, 2008
This review is from: Refuse to Regain!: 12 Tough Rules to Maintain the Body You've Earned! (Hardcover)
Smart and sophisticated, Refuse to Regain is a well written and well researched book that is a must read for anyone serious about being healthy. Although the book is geared primarily to people who are struggling to maintain weight loss, it is actually a fascinating read that would be valuable to anyone, as it lays out the basic principles for how to eat healthily and explains why so many Americans are overweight. Dr. Berkeley manages to present state of the art medical research in a way that is easy to grasp and her point of view is very convincing. Unlike other books about diet and lifestyle, this one is actually a good read! And there really are not any other books out there that address the specific question of what to do after you've lost weight to keep off the pounds. Kudos to Dr. Berkeley!
S. Jesmajian MD, Chief of Medicine, Sound Shore Medical Center, New Rochelle, NY
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not As Good As I'd Hoped For, April 5, 2009
This review is from: Refuse to Regain!: 12 Tough Rules to Maintain the Body You've Earned! (Hardcover)
This book was not as helpful as I had hoped for. The eating plan that she lays out is just so restrictive. I think it's making an already hard job (maintenance) harder than it has to be. I would look at her plan as one way among many ways that you can achieve your goal, not THE way. If you look at it as THE way I'm afraid you're going to set yourself up for failure. I found Anne M. Fletcher's "Thin for Life" a more practical guide.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No